unsharp photos Samyang 14mm 5Dmk2

Me too :thinking:


And that bit also, I see no moderator posting??

I'm assuming ploddles thinks i'm a moderator as it was me sam was having a pop at right before he said that. Why i'm not sure, as it would likely be a cold day in hell before they let me in the staff room.

(for starters, i'm so ruggedly handsome and suave and debonair that i'd make all the guys feel inadequate and distract all the ladies :exit: .. plus they'd have to double the jaffa cake ration ;) )
 
What 9 months ago?!!! I said I never had the lens before! Why are you so annoying guys? This thread is about the samyang lens and not about myself!!! It is supposed to deal with photography! If you are accusing me of spamming read my next post which proves I have the camera and lens, and leave me alone! Follow some good guys who tried to help me here and start talking about the lens or otherwise don't say anything. Stop irritating people and just go somewhere. :bang::help::thumbsdown:

Really ? :thumbsdown: - If this is 100% true why did you open this thread by writing



Assuming you've actually bought the lens this time and its not just another flight of fancy, this is a clear example of why it was more than a little misleading to write 9 months ago that it was "sharp and excellent"

If you really must give advice based on what you've read rather than personal experience, you could at least make that clear like writing " I have no personal experience of this lens but reviews say ... "
 
Last edited:
I love my 5D and 2 cheap but excellent lenses as well as the cheap Canon flash with HSS.
Uploaded some photos (5D mk2 + Sigma 50mm 2.8 macro, and some with Samyang 14mm 2.8 mostly cropped and pp in PS5).
Sorry I took photos of myself but wanted to test high speed synchronization and didn’t have anyone to pose for me (I used wireless remote).
I know those photos are not perfect but I am learning and in the future it should be better.
I love the HSS in my flash and decided to buy Nissin with HSS as it will produce much stronger light:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/niuniakaka/
 
Are you drunk man?! What 9 months ago?!!!

my bad it was actually 11 months ago on the 9th of june

I would buy used and good condition canon 20d or 400d or 450d body for 200-250 and good glass like samyang 14mm 2.8 for about 250 and used canon 55-250 for around 100
And if you want camcorder get cheap one separately
I know what I say from experience
 
Last edited:
I didn't say I owned samyang 14mm but I only meant I had some experience with slr cameras and different lenses. I owned Nikon D90, Sony A100, Canon 20D, 40D, 550d 3 times, Samyang NX10 and NX5, and many lenses. I can prove it.
Apart from that, I already mentioned there was a time when I was quickly writing here as many posts as possible because I was desperate to buy a cheap used camera before going on holiday so what I wrote sometimes could be confusing.
But I apologized for that a long time ago and don't have to do it again now. So, why are you still picking on me? I am not doing anything bad now asking about samynag 14mm lens I own!!! If you don't believe I recently bought one, returned it and bought again I can easily prove it to the moderator. I hope this will finally keep you quiet...
 
But I apologized for that a long time ago and don't have to do it again now. So, why are you still picking on me? I am not doing anything bad now asking about samynag 14mm lens I own!!! If you don't believe I recently bought one, returned it and bought again I can easily prove it to the moderator. I hope this will finally keep you quiet...

I'm not picking on you - you asked if i was drunk for suggesting you'd said that you'd owned the lens before , and I responded by illustrating that last june you were saying that you knew it was excellent from experience (and last april come to that)

I've got no real argument with you - but like i said its difficult to give photographic advice to someone who's kit bag changes so fast and who's made so many contradictory statements about the same kit before

Returning to your original topic did you ever find out what was wrong with the lens you returned ?
 
Last edited:
Looks like you like the moon too :cool:

Thanks mate, at last a normal reaction :thumbs:
I am not a moon's fan but my friend wanted to take some photos of the moon yesterday. Unfortunately it wasn't possible so I've found a photo of the moon, cut it, added to my new photos and shared with my friend. :bonk:
 
If you thought I started to spam again you should have sent a message to a moderator instead of trying to confirm your suspicions here and carrying on your own investigation. Unfortunately I see that there is no moderator who would care about it anyway. :shake:

I'm not picking on you - you asked if i was drunk for suggesting you'd said that you'd owned the lens before , and I responded by illustrating that last june you were saying that you knew it was excellent from experience (and last april come to that) if it'll make you happy i'll edit the post above to those sailent points.

I've got no real argument with you - but like i said its difficult to give photographic advice to someone who's kit bag changes so fast and who's made so many contradictory statements about the same kit before

Returning to your original topic did you ever find out what was wrong with the lens you returned ?
 
I'm still confused.
 
yeah you arent the only one
 
If you thought I started to spam again you should have sent a message to a moderator instead of trying to confirm your suspicions here and carrying on your own investigation. Unfortunately I see that there is no moderator who would care about it anyway. :shake:

FWIW I'm not accusing you of spamming (if that had been the case i would have reported it) I was just somewhat confused by you posting a thread about a lens not being sharp which you'd previously said was sharp which you knew from personal experience, and which you've since said that reviews of it being sharp are 100% reliable even though you've now owned and returned a soft copy. :shrug:

but no matter as you've now got a sharp copy and have taken decent pictures with is I guess the main reason for this thread is resolved.

On the other point thats come up , ie whether its okay to post advice on kit you don't own based soley on reviews you've read ? I guess we'll have to agree to differ as I generally feel that its both misleading for other members unless you clearly state that the advice isnt based on first hand experience, and secondly it stores up confusion for the future if you later buy the item concerned and your experience differs from that you've previously posted (as with your experience of the samyang).
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately I see that there is no moderator who would care about it anyway. :shake:

Oh I can assure you that we all do care about the forums and what is posted.
I'm not quite sure what your complaint is though?

If you do have a complaint, the report this thread / post, button is in the corner
of each post, or there is a contact us button at the bottom of every page.
Feel free to use either.:thumbs:
 
big soft moose said:
Really ? :thumbsdown: - If this is 100% true why did you open this thread by writing

Assuming you've actually bought the lens this time and its not just another flight of fancy, this is a clear example of why it was more than a little misleading to write 9 months ago that it was "sharp and excellent"

If you really must give advice based on what you've read rather than personal experience, you could at least make that clear like writing " I have no personal experience of this lens but reviews say ... "

Agreed. Recommendations should be based on personal experience. Being a very helpful forum member by supplying links and info on what you read is just as important although not as reliable.
"Can't we all just get along"? :)
Wait, that's an American quote, it probably isn't funny to you. But its still funny to me. Lol
 
Back
Top