UWA lenses & landscape photography

Messages
4,240
Edit My Images
No
Hope everyone is having a good Christmas !!

I'm currently re-considering UWA lens options although being honest I'm not 100% sure if I need one. The reason I say this is that I previously owned the Sigma 10-20 and never found it quite to my taste, distortion was a bit too heavy and I often felt that UWA just left landscapes feeling a little lost/distant (hope that makes sense).

I currently use a 17-70mm (pentax) most of the time but I'm thinking again about adding the option of UWA but with a 12-24mm. Perhaps the range would be more suitable for my needs than the 10-20 and the 12-24 should exhbit much less distortion than my current 17-70 in the 17mm focal range.

Although it's obviously up to me to make up my own mind I'd appreciate any thoughts on this from others into landscape photography - it's not really about the qualities of the 12-24/10-20 etc, more about the usefulness of UWA lenses for landscapes

thanks

Simon
 
I have a 17-40 but don't use it very often. Mostly I use the 24-105 - both on full frame.
So the 17-40 compares to an extra wide on a crop camera.... but I don't use it much for landscapes as 24 is generally wide enough for me.

There are a few situations where you need a wider view so the 17-40 is staying but for the majority of landscapes I'd say ultra wide views just lose your subject into the distance.
 
the human eye enjoys a landscape...but roams a bit
35mm used to be favoured
i like 28 but my digicamera only does 36

the thing about uwa is the tilt effect and whether you want all sky or all earth
middle horizons i do not favour so the wider the angle the more surreal the shot

good compact landscapes which contain near middle and far interest dont need to be all that wide...constable shows this in his landscapes
 
Personally, I love ultra wide angle lenses and my favourite is the Nikon 14-24mm on full frame. It helps me get the kind of landscapes I like.

What's driving your reconsideration of ultra wides?
 
I hardly ever take my 12-24 off for landscapes. Distortion of buildings etc is easy corrected. I find my 17mm + lenses most of the time don't get enough of the shot. Of course there are always exceptions.
 
12-24mm is a very nice lens to have if you can spare some cash. I do use mine fairly often, along with 24-70mm and 70-200mm. Remember, you need a perfect scene for UWA, as any rubbish can easily ruin the shot.
 
I think the key to using an ultra-wide lens is make sure you have something in the foreground. I've taken out my 11-18 before, and come back with a load of rubbish because I got sucked in to thinking that wider was better, and the subject is barely visible.

I think DigitalRelish's set linked to above is brilliant, and shows sort of what I mean. Almost all of them have fairly prominent features in the foreground, which fills out the photo much more than I've often been able to achive with mine! :thumbs:

Chris
 
With an UWA for landscapes you have to think about the shot - you have to have the foreground interest. It is very common to go down the line of 'getting everything in' but without strong composition it just looks cluttered.

I have a 12-24 and in reality I rarely use it much below 14mm. It's nice to have 12mm available but I make a mental effort not to simply zoom righ tout and work from there.
 
As with all lenses really - you use the appropriate lens for the shot you want. There is no *need* for an ultrawide for landscapes. These days, I mostly shoot landscapes with a 45mm lens (normal length) on 35mm or 90mm lens (slightly wide) on medium format 6x7. I think the images are just fine and probably better than the ultrawide shots I used to do on my DSLR. In fact, I bet any famous landscape shot you can think of was probably made without using an ultrawide.

As you (the OP) said, ultrawides tend to result in photos with too much foreground and sky and everything feeling a bit distant. Sure, the widest focal lengths have their uses (for which I am glad I own a Sigma 10-20) but I don't use it often and I don't think anyone needs to kid themselves into thinking they *need* one. It's just a little bit less novel than a fisheye.
 
I love my 12-24 for landscapes but I'm increasingly using it more for pure landscapery at 15mm or above; less distortion yet still wide enough to give that extra oomph. Personally, I think 10mm is far too wide, especially on a 1.5x crop sensor. It's very much like a 17mm lens on FF - just a bit too exagerated and comic-book when used incorrectly.

Purely down to personal taste and what you want to achieve I suppose....
 
Rather than use an ultrawide angle to take a landscape which as has been said requires something in the foreground to create interest, why not try using a longer focal length on a tripod and creating a panorama to capture the vista you require.
 
Thanks everyone for the comments...

As mentioned "Digitalrelish" has some great shots showing the capabilities of UWA although a couple of his shots, the Buttermere reflection ones, also show exactly the issue I mention - lost/distant mountains. Fleetwith Pike & Haystacks are really distinctive & dominant mountains but have little or no impact shot at 10mm - that's not to take away anything from the photographer, just helps illustrate my point.

The suggestion to try using longer focal lengths is a good one, something I've rarely done

thanks

Simon
 
Oh well seems i'm in a minority then as I really like a nice UWA and happily use a Sigma 10-20mm
Suppose it all comes down to what you enjoy looking at although I would agree that if there is a specific feature like a mountain it can get a bit lost

Here in the flatlands we don't have that luxury and the wide open spaces actually look better the more you can see of them. Their only feature is the expansive view and the UWA makes them look a bit more dramatic, well it does to my eye anyway
 
Oh well seems i'm in a minority then as I really like a nice UWA and happily use a Sigma 10-20mm

Don't get me wrong, I love my UWA (shame I can't use it properly!). I just find that it's so hard to get the best out of them, and some people initially think that wider is always better for landscapes, then lose their subject!
 
Back
Top