What are the pros of photo retouching?

Messages
15
Name
Katherine Louise
Edit My Images
No
There is a new group or people that seem absolutely adverse to the idea of commercial editing. However it is thriving... as a general rule of thumb people do enjoy looking at things which are "beautiful"

What are you own personal opinions behind the pros of photo retouching?
 
Personally, I think PPing should be left at correcting things like white balance, exposure if you need to, and possibly a bit of cropping. And of course putting something into black and white. I can see the merits of clearing up skin a little, but you go too far and you make the model into something they're not. I prefer to do as little as possible as far as editing and PSing goes.

That's for portrait work, I don't do much else.
 
Remeber most of this retouching was able to be done with film it is nothing new, people seem to think it is a digital only thing and that its wrong, I don't have a problem with it at all, I think if you could do it on film then do it in digital, even heavily processed images have their place provided you are not trying to pass them off as real, something that probably happens with beauty or fashion pictures and should be stopped
 
something that probably happens with beauty or fashion pictures and should be stopped

:plusone: You're damn right there. If you wanted a picture of a model that had perfect skin etc, then hire one that looks like that in the first place. I prfer shooting people who look real anyway!
 
The same arguments, for and against "editing" were around long before digital.
Who is this new group of people ?
Commercial editing is part of creating the vision as seen by the client, its not about semantics, personal taste, photography or anything else, its about providing a service using the tools best suited for the job.
If the client wants a model with plastic skin, or a Landrover crashing through a glacier and you can supply it, you will get paid.

:)
 
I have a fairly open mind to PP and it is inevitable that every photo has had some editing even if it's only in camera sharpening and white balance setting. At the other end of the scale I think any processing is fair game if it makes it a better photo. It's all about the end result for me.

You also have to think about the end market as to why some of the more crass editing is done. The magazines do what they do to sell the photos to people who want to believe a model's skin is completely smooth and freckle free. In that respect they are doing the PP to make the photo better for their audience and in the spirit of free trade good luck to them.
 
I do professional photo restoration work, where the aim is to repair the photo as near as possible to how it looked originally but with due regard to it's age.. There are no ground rules to the work but the name of the game is restoration rather than converting an old shot to something which looks brand new and out of keeping with the time when it was taken.

Photojournalists can and do get fired for manipulating their images any further than levels adjustments or removal of dust bunnies. The cloning out of any tiny detail, however irrelevant, gets them queuing up at The Job Centre! Image integrity is everything in journalism.

There's also a place for image manipulation in it's own right, to produce something markedly different to the photo it started out as. We've all seen this type of image and some people are very skilled at it whether it's our cuppa or not.

Most photographers would limit manipulation of their images to levels, sharpening, dust bunnies, etc., and possibly the cloning out of very minor distractions, while others would throw up their hands in horror at the thought of any cloning or even cropping. Whatever your viewpoint, the only thing wrong with manipulating an image is to deny you've done it IMHO.

As pointed out, photos were manipulated in the darkroom long before digital anyway, although it's now undeniably much easier. I know a very talented artist who used to earn a nice income from retouching and colouring prints by hand to an impressive standard, but he's now completely blown out of the water by people doing the same job in Photoshop et al.
 
I am sorry. I shall clear up the confusion. I am well aware that this kind of editing happened before digital photography took its main stand. The focus of the question is mainly on the types of fashion and advertising images you see on an every day basis. The images that are used to sell an idea or product.
 
I am sorry. I shall clear up the confusion. I am well aware that this kind of editing happened before digital photography took its main stand. The focus of the question is mainly on the types of fashion and advertising images you see on an every day basis. The images that are used to sell an idea or product.

I've no doubt there are few if any, images we see in advertising which aren't manipulated. Cover girl type images of flawless goddesses is the obvious one, and I hate the excessive skin smoothing to the extent that they look like dolls. It's got more to do with the image of women which they're trying to get women to aspire to, than it has to photography of course. ;)
 
The images that are used to sell an idea or product.

Right, in which case PPing is unavoidable, you could take the moral stance and say 'natural beauty is real beauty' but then nobody else will and you're out of a job.

Joxby you raise a good point, I was talking more for my own purposes, s I'm not a pro, so I have the luxury of editing as I see fit, not so that my pictures sell.
 
Photo retouching is a multi faceted thing, how much, to what and for what purpose. I personally have no problems with retouching photos to make things look at their best. However, I think that if you are actually misrepresenting the product then things have gone too far.

That said, I will admit to "slimming" myself down in a recent family photograph I took. My excuse; it was a wide angle lens and I was on the edge so distortion was adversely affecting me. What I can't excuse is that may have made my skinny little sister's hips look slightly "larger" :naughty:
 
Well I get nearly as much fun out of Photoshop as I do out of photography. I am interested in the final result not how 'real' it is! I use photoshop quite heavily and have created some good pictures from some that were basically in the bin.

An example is this thread here where I have removed a bin then removed an open gate then cut the closed gate and mirrored it before placing it back again. It was a bit of fun and irrelevant due to the fact that it was easier to just open the other gate and get the shot but that was not the point.

I can accept others view in that they do not want to use Photoshop but it has its uses and like I said I am interested only in the final picture not how it got there.
 
I can accept others view in that they do not want to use Photoshop but it has its uses and like I said I am interested only in the final picture not how it got there.

A good attitude to have, I'll never think less of people who do use PS, no matter how extinsively, but personally I get far more enjoyment out of having camera in hand that sat at a computer feeling my eyes shrivel up :) No doubt this will change over time and as I get more involved with my togging.
 
Joxby you raise a good point, I was talking more for my own purposes, s I'm not a pro, so I have the luxury of editing as I see fit, not so that my pictures sell.

No, I absolutely agree with you're own personal view, but the op did say commercial, therefore that all goes out the window.
I shoot product for money, and whatever I want for myself, I couldn't alter my "whatever I want" to the same degree the market demands for product, and still call it a photo.
I know how much photo there is left in it, and it isn't much imo, I should shoot without edit, but time is money, and that's where personal preference and commercial business part company.
 
Back
Top