What should i buy, your opinions

Messages
146
Name
Rich
Edit My Images
Yes
Ok heres what i have
Canon 550d
Canon 70-200 F4 L USM
Canon 17-85 f4-5.6 USM IS

I'm looking to buy a 1.8 prime, and cant pick between the 50mm 1.8 new or a 85mm 1.8 2nd hand

I've been told that a focal length of 70mm is best for portrait, most flattering aparantly, so would the 50mm be best suited for me because of my 1.6 crop ?

( Can anyone tell that money is burning a hole in my pocket ? )
 
They're both f1.8, but that's about it. The 85mm replicates the long end of your 17 - 85mm, and gives you about the same field of view as a 135mm lens on a 35mm film camera or a FF DSLR. That is an excellent length for portraiture, and probably better than the 50mm which is about 80mm equivalent. The 85mm also has USM, is better built and has superior bokeh, from what I remember from a couple of times when I used one. It's quite a bit more expensive than the 50mm though, but I don't know what price you're looking at for a used one.

The 50mm is an entry level, fast, prime offering good IQ for a very attractive price and it's a popular choice; but build quality is poor and it doesn't have USM focusing.

I suppose it really depends whether you want a fast 80mm or 135mm equivalent. 50mm was the 'standard' focal length for a walk around lens on 35mm film, because it more or less 'sees' the scene as your eyes do, but I find it too long for this on a crop camera, and too short for a telephoto. 135mm was a very popular choice for a short telephoto in the film days. I'd pick the f1.8 85mm, but others may have different advice.

FWIW, the crop factor doesn't change the focal length, just the field of view.
 
I've been told that a focal length of 70mm is best for portrait, most flattering aparantly, so would the 50mm be best suited for me because of my 1.6 crop ?

In short, Yes.

You really can't go wrong with it for the price. They often crop up in the classifieds for peanuts. Grab one and be amazed.......:lol:
 
Oops, just realised you can't access the classifieds yet. Amazon have them for about £85 new.
 
50mm 1.8 would be a great addition, I've got one and love it, in fact its essential, although i am after a 85mm now myself.

Can i ask why your concidering an 85mm just now ?

i love the price of the 50mm but not the build but my other lens are USM and i love that too
 
Personally, I have the 50mm.. went through that phase of early experiments with primes and the 50mm, came out the otherside realising that primes are pretty much all I want to use but that 50mm is a pretty crap focal length on a crop sensor - always either too wide or too long, never just right. I'd go for the 85mm. Great portrait length, I almost always have my 17-85 at the long end with portraits. I'm not sure ehy I haven't bitten the bullet of selling it to put towards an 85mm (probably because I want the Sigma 85mm f/1.4 rather than the Canon 85mm f/1.8).
 
Can i ask why your concidering an 85mm just now ?

i love the price of the 50mm but not the build but my other lens are USM and i love that too

I just want a the 1.8 prime with more reach for portraits when i get get the cash, (mostly will just end up proberbly being candid stuff thou), the only lens ive got longer than 50 right now is 70 200 but its f4
 
The 50mm 1.8 is as has been said a cracker of a lens for the price, the problem with it is the build quality is lacking.

The 85mm 1.8 is much better built, but has a greater price tag - seem to remember its similar price to the 50mm 1.4.

You could get the 50mm 1.8 and if you found it wasn't to your liking, then you could sell on at a minimal loss
 
Just ordered a Canon 50mm f1.8 :) , 2 days and counting before i can try it :)

P.s. Also bought a eye fi 8gb card, Lowepro 350 & 2 Flower Petal hoods ....... :)
 
Last edited:
The nifty fifty is pocket money priced, I would grab a secondhand 85mm and a new 50mm, I wouldn't be without either of them..
 
The nifty fifty is pocket money priced, I would grab a secondhand 85mm and a new 50mm, I wouldn't be without either of them..

The 85mm f1.8 and the 24-70mm f2.8 are still on my shopping list ;)
 
Why don't you put your Canon 17-85 f4-5.6 USM IS lens on and shoot for a day at 50mm and a day at 85mm and see which you prefer. Take into account for the DOF for shooting at 1.8 on both though, as the bokeh should be similar on both lenses.
 
Why don't you put your Canon 17-85 f4-5.6 USM IS lens on and shoot for a day at 50mm and a day at 85mm and see which you prefer. Take into account for the DOF for shooting at 1.8 on both though, as the bokeh should be similar on both lenses.

:thumbs:
 
Back
Top