What to say or ask if Togs are stopped by the Police

Messages
406
Name
Steve
Edit My Images
Yes
This may have been covered before but thought a thread might help on the do's and dont's of what to say and ask the boys in blue if you are stopped under section 44..

Also what is the correct way that the boys in blue should treat you ie what they should say and ask..
 
If you are stopped under section 44 then ask if the area you are in is actually a designated section 44 zone (not many are). Even if it is, there is nothing in that act to prevent you taking photographs.

If you think the officer or PCSO is wrong or doesn't know, ask them to make a call to the station for clarification.

If you want to, you can ask if you are being detained. If the answer is no, you can move on with no further dialogue needed. If the answer is yes then ask on what authority you are being detained.

In all cases, be polite and do not raise your voice or use bad language (even if you want to) as that may be enough to get you a caution for a public order offence.


Steve.
 
I didn't even know such an act existsed!! :)
 
Remember that no-one can ask you to delete photos - a lot of PCSOs especially seem to be demanding this.

If the image if of something illegal or if taking it was an illegal act then it needs to be preserved as evidence. If it's not illegal then you're fine to keep hold of them!

Although if you don't feel happy standing up to them like this I'd carefully consider the method of deleting them... perhaps something which you could later recover with software? Just saying... ;)
 
If they ask you to delete pictures they are committing an offence. It is an offence to destroy evidence!
 
Good summary by Steve.
They also do not have the ultimate right to ask you to delete photographs, or confiscate them. I would think however, that should you be witness to some terrorist act, that someone with a greater authority than just stopping you wandering down the street might request it.
And, as long as you are not threatening, or disrupting their actions, you may take photographs of the policemen involved in their duties (obvious exception to this is if they are plain clothes, as that could be counted as disrupting their activities?). If you are asked to stop, you might wish to remind them of this, but I wouldn't press the point, as they might start to get arsey.
 
I think the 'safest' deletion method is a format, then use a different card. A format should just delete the filenames and leave the rest of the data intact for recovery software.
 
polite, informed, ask them to refer to the station's supervising sergeant, stand up for your rights but made friends not enemies.
impolite bolshy attitudes can go both ways. "flea in ear" etc.
you can be just as annoying with reason and logic should you feel the need
"are you invoking the anti-terror laws to question me today"
"what has made you think that I might be a terrorist?"
"are you invoking the anti-terror laws to question me today"
"if the photos themselves are offensive/lawbreaking then deleting them is destruction of evidence"
"public place does not require any permit for non-commercial photos"
etc

I haven't had this conversation yet but frankly I feel it comes down to discrimination...try that one they'd be on their toes :)
i'll be a charmer when this happens to me :cool:
(unfortunately I feel that it's when..not if)
 
"Wow I love people in uniforms, smile darling, yes look this way...." ? :D
And what was his reply? :naughty:

I've not had the chance yet, perhaps when given the opportunity I should use my best D ick Emery voice?
n7900598549_6687.jpg


Edit - ah cannot use the shortened form of Richard
 
polite, informed, ask them to refer to the station's supervising sergeant, stand up for your rights but made friends not enemies.
impolite bolshy attitudes can go both ways. "flea in ear" etc.
you can be just as annoying with reason and logic should you feel the need
"are you invoking the anti-terror laws to question me today"
"what has made you think that I might be a terrorist?"
"are you invoking the anti-terror laws to question me today"
"if the photos themselves are offensive/lawbreaking then deleting them is destruction of evidence"
"public place does not require any permit for non-commercial photos"
etc

I haven't had this conversation yet but frankly I feel it comes down to discrimination...try that one they'd be on their toes :)
i'll be a charmer when this happens to me :cool:
(unfortunately I feel that it's when..not if)


But when it comes down to it will you remember what to say at the time..I was thinking of a card to carry with the correct questions to ask..
 
If they ask you to delete pictures they are committing an offence. It is an offence to destroy evidence!

The legal term is attempting to pervert the course of justice.

Aside from this, if anyone tries to delete pictures from your camera, they are commiting an offence under the computer misuse act.
 
If they ask you to delete pictures they are committing an offence. It is an offence to destroy evidence!

No, the pictures are only evdence if they contain images relating to a criminal act, so you'd be arrested first if this was the case!

If they are your normal photos that we all take, they dont form any evidence so this is irrelevent.

However they cannot tell you to delete your photos.

Legally, if we are looking at breach of laws, you could argue it would be criminal damage as they would be disrupting and destroying data on the card. The computer misuse act would only come into play if your camera was taken off you by someone and deleted by them - under 'unauthorised access'.

As someone just said though, be polite and just show them your pics and they'll be on your way. This forum is turning into a big brother / state oppression paranoia theatre of late, cant everyone just chill??!

The chances of any of us being stopped and questioned outside of London are remote.
 
I only use film, might be a little difficult to delete the images other than by removing the film. In which case I would be seeking compensation for the replacement of the film (assuming I'd not contravened section 44), The only place I've ever been asked to refrain from taking photographs was in Odessa in 1975, this was by the military though they didn't confiscate the film.

Nigel.
 
Back
Top