What's wrong with the 70-200L f2.8 IS MK I?

Messages
358
Name
Rebecca
Edit My Images
Yes
Hey,

I'm looking at buying a 70-200 range lens, I've used the 70-200L f4 IS with superb results so I'm now looking at buying a lens in that range. I'm thinking of buying it along with a **-70 f2.8 lens so it would be nice to have the constant aperture of f2.8 throughout all ranges.

With the release of the new 70-200L f2.8 IS MK II one can only expect that the prices of the original will start dropping and they're going to be quite popular on the second hand market, but is all this down to the fact that it's actually quite a poor quality lens, hence canon having to bring out a replacement.

I've read a few stories about it being a little soft. Really what I'm looking for is some recommendations on people who have used this lens. I really can't afford to stretch out to the price of the new 70-200 but if it really is the case that the original isn't up to scratch then I'd rather not waste any money on it at all and just go straight to the f4 IS which I have experience using.

I would also consider Sigma's EX f2.8 if people recommend that..
 
it depends on the aperture you mostly shoot, go through your images using adobe bridge or some other similar program and see what aperture you shoot most at because if its f8 or above you won't see much difference between the f2.8 and f4 version.
 
I love my 70-200 f2.8, not tried the mrk2 but my mrk1 is as sharp as a sharp thing on a sharp day, i would never part with mine great lens to have in the bag. Imho i can't see how the mrk2 will be £1000 better than the mrk1.
 
Interesting! It's very nice to hear from some owners of the lens to say how much they like it.

What were the reasons why they bought out the new 2.8 model and slapped such a huge price tag to it?
 
No idea what the difference is between the two lenses but the Mk1 is brilliant. I bought mine just before Christmas and love it. It's bokeh is beautiful and it's ability to lift/isolate items from the background is just to die for.

120592658.jpg

122924983.jpg
 
The 70-200 f2.8 IS is one of the very popular lenses in the canon EF range everyone pretty much has one. Canon have made some small improvments to the lens adding fluorite element and UD elements and updated the IS system. Other things like closer focusing distance All the small changes come together to make the new lens better than the old one in all aspects. Why release a new version of it? to make money every one knows they nailed it with the old lens make some improvements to that and your on to a winner and people will buy it.

The problem the price, £1500 is sort of affordable for quite a lot of people which I think is what has made the lens so popular the new lens has jumped in price by about £700 quite a lot and pricing most people out of making the upgrade to the new one especially when the old lens is so good. The result not many are upgradeing so the influx of 2nd hand 70-200's hasn't happened so they are holding their price on the 2nd hand market.

Why the huge price increase? Canon have probably spent a few years developing the new bits in the new lens and quite a bit on investment on their part so they need to recoup some of it, saying that the price has dropped about £550 from its original launch price.
 
I don't know very much at all about this lens, BUT I have read from two people on here (tdodd and philthejuggler) who both said that at the 200mm end @ f/2.8, the lens is soft.

Also Byker, I wouldn't say the background blur on those images was great for such an expensive high spec lens, in fact it's quite harsh blur in my opinion. I'd also say that second one was quite soft.
 
I'm lucky enough to have access to the 2.8 IS and 4 IS versions of this lens and tend to use the f/4 unless I need 2.8 or faster / more accurate focusing. The f/4 is a sharper lens but the 2.8 had seen me well.

I am tempted by the new f/2.8 but largely because it seems to offer better performance with teleconverters.
 
Interesting! It's very nice to hear from some owners of the lens to say how much they like it.

What were the reasons why they bought out the new 2.8 model and slapped such a huge price tag to it?


I have owned both 70-200 2.8 IS lenses (currently I own the MKII) and I've also owned/used the 200 f/2.8 Prime.

I sold my 70-200 IS MKI as although it was mostly excellent I found it slightly soft wide open (@ 2.8) at the longer end of it's range. It is very good @ f/2.8 through 70-150 ish. You shouldn't be put off this lens because a MKII is out - the MKI is excellent.

Having said that I ditched the 70-200 f2.8 IS, instead opting for the 200 2.8 prime and the 70-200 f4 IS. The F4 is noticeably sharper than the original f2.8 and I used the 200mm prime for great sharpness @ 200mm 2.8 where you can get a lovely 3d-effect.

The 70-200 MKII is sharper than the f4 version and at least as sharp as the prime so totally is worth the extra in my opinion. Although it doesn't go to f2 it is also as sharp as the legendary 135L f2.0 which I'm holding on to at the moment just because of the portability.

Phil
 
I'm lucky enough to have access to the 2.8 IS and 4 IS versions of this lens and tend to use the f/4 unless I need 2.8 or faster / more accurate focusing. The f/4 is a sharper lens but the 2.8 had seen me well.

I am tempted by the new f/2.8 but largely because it seems to offer better performance with teleconverters.

The MKII is staggeringly good with and without converters! I was very impressed with it's performance with the 1.4x II converter.


Phil
 
I have the MK1 70-200 2.8L IS - it's probably my least used lens, but that's because it's a mite short for what I mostly so. I don't part with it because I find it simply superb in every respect from IQ to build quality, and I'm sure I'd regret it if I got rid.

This was at 200mm and f2.8...

4336_1122201644464942ff1a6f3.jpg



This was at handheld at 200mm with the 2XTC - not brilliant, but better than I should really expect...

4336_17045508084649401431839.jpg
 
I first got the f/4 IS because of cost & weight mainly, but living up here in Finland there's not that much light so years later I looked again at the f/2.8 mk I but it was not up to par with the f/4 in IQ unless stopped down so I just lived with the slower lens.

However the mkII version came out and I thought it was silly money.. then I tried one out and was sold. I find it amazingly sharp even wide open (with my limited experience) and takes a 1.4x TC very well.

It stings in the wallet though! And has put my plans for a 400/5.6 or 100-400 back a bit.. :bonk:

All that said, the mkI f/2.8 is by no means a crappier lens because of the mkII .. it's just second best now :) If most of your shooting is at f/4 or narrower apertures, I'm not sure the mkII is worth it.
 
the first L lens I got 4 years ago was the Mk1, still got it to this day - stunning, stunning lens which I'll never get rid of! :) Must have in any serious photographer's camera bag

drew
 
Looking at the comparison shots in the link Phil posted no one would ever buy the mk1 based on those shots but it works and the images are fantastic from it. I think we need to look at how much of an improvment has been made, the mk1 is fantastic the mk2 is better.

The only other thing I can think about is car wax, I have a pot of £100 wax, it looks fantastic and durability is great. Zymol make their royale wax which costs £7000 is it that much better than my £100 pot of wax? No they both enhance the shine and protect the car for some time I am sure royale is better but can anyone else see the difference? probably not. Infact a blind test was done and a pot of £20 wax was prefered to the more expensive waxes.
 
Looking at the comparison shots in the link Phil posted no one would ever buy the mk1 based on those shots but it works and the images are fantastic from it. I think we need to look at how much of an improvment has been made, the mk1 is fantastic the mk2 is better.

The only other thing I can think about is car wax, I have a pot of £100 wax, it looks fantastic and durability is great. Zymol make their royale wax which costs £7000 is it that much better than my £100 pot of wax? No they both enhance the shine and protect the car for some time I am sure royale is better but can anyone else see the difference? probably not. Infact a blind test was done and a pot of £20 wax was prefered to the more expensive waxes.


I'm certainly not going to be negative about the Mark I - it does produce great images and to answer the OP question there is nothing wrong with it. The 70-200 MKII is better though and the differences are there in real world situations. One negative of the MKII is occassional random mis-focusses but these could be user error (although I know others have mentioned this).

FWIW I do have shots taken wide open with the MKI at the long end which I thought were reasonably sharp, but there is a certain 3D effect you can get @ 200mm, f2.8 which requires better sharpness than the MKI delivered in my opinion.

Unless you are expecting prime sharpness from a zoom you won't be disappointed with the MKI. If you are, you won't be disappointed by the MKII.

Phil
 
different make, but i've got the Sigma 70-200 2.8 EX, 2nd hand so got it for about £400 but a very sharp lens for not a lot of money

This is just a test shot taken with the sigma, f9, a 100% crop, think thats fairly sharp!

Large
4666010843_bca3dfca60_d.jpg
 
Back
Top