which magazine for the least edtted photos?

Messages
2,839
Name
Dale
Edit My Images
Yes
I've been looking at various magazines, but I'm finding some seem to be full of photos overly edited in photoshop. I'm looking for inspiration ie how did they do that, only to find they've removed bits from the photo or replaced something and its a long way from the photo they took.
 
Any photo appearing in a magazine will have gone through a number of Photoshop procedures. Conversion to cmyk, cropping, possibly colour adjustment depending on how the original came in, almost certainly some sharpening. The colour balance will have shifted depending on which calibration profile has been used and the printing process will vary from magazine to magazine in some cases.

Then, many shots will have has some in-camera adjustments made. Camera calibration again, colour saturation possibly, sharpening, a lens filter perhaps...

In the old days an emulsion of silver halide crystals was bonded to a strip of cellulose acetate before undergoing a number of treatments with poisonous chemicals to produce an image on one of a number of different media selected by the photographer.

In those days it was largely chemical, today is is mostly electrical.

There is absolutely nothing natural about a photograph. As long as the end result is pleasing, why does in matter how it was arrived at?
 
I agree but all of that is tweakng what is already there, not adding details from other photos or removing features.
 
I haven't looked at a photo mag in ages. Are they putting up many shots with substantive alterations these days? When I worked for Archant (publishers of Professional Photographer,British Photographic Industry News and Photography Monthly among others), very few shots had details added - and if they did, this was made clear. Taking stuff out was more common. Trees growing out of heads and so forth, and small blemishes, as when old-style photography used `spotting out` to do the same thing, only with less accuracy and far less ease.

In news photography, where I mostly worked, making substantive alterations to any picture was a hanging offence. (And still is - read Getty's Editorial Policy for example).
 
There is a snowboard magazine in canada which only runs shots strait from the camera, Its amazing some of the best sports photos i have ever seen
 
go to waterstones, buy the book ' the great life photographers' or '5000+ days'. both will inspire you.
 
There is a snowboard magazine in canada which only runs shots strait from the camera, Its amazing some of the best sports photos i have ever seen

That's interesting. Do they say how much in-camera tweaking is allowed? And why don't they allow RAW photos?
 
charleyboy14 said:
There is a snowboard magazine in canada which only runs shots strait from the camera, Its amazing some of the best sports photos i have ever seen

Which one is it? I get a few boarding mags that carry subtle but definite tweaks, plus a lot of those overlay sequence shots :)
 
Back
Top