Would you guys shoot your own sibling's wedding?

Would you photograph your Brother/Sister's wedding?

  • Yes

    Votes: 29 37.2%
  • No

    Votes: 39 50.0%
  • Yes - But insist on a pro-tog for the formals.

    Votes: 10 12.8%

  • Total voters
    78

Raymond Lin

I am Groot
Messages
10,564
Name
Raymond
Edit My Images
No
I just shot a wedding for my sister yesterday and in a thread in the crit forum another member mentioned that as a pro himself, wedding photography for his sister is a definite no go. I must admit i do have reservations, but not of my own ability, more of the fact that because the bride is closer to me than anyone else, may be i need that "distance" to remain more professional?

So, would you guys photograph your brother/sister's wedding?
 
Of course I would - and as for the above comment about not being in any of the formal shots, that's what tripods and self-timers/remotes were made for!!!
 
The only shots I've ever taken (or ever will take if I an help it :)) at a wedding were half a dozen formal groupshots for a mate who was a professional wedding 'togger, who was shooting his sisters wedding as her present. I offered to help out so that he'd at least be in the group shots as I knew my way around his (film) camera setup - he did all the work tbh. and I just pressed the shutter release when everyone was looking in the right direction :lol:

His take on the day "The single most stressful days shooting i've ever done in my life, and thank god I don't have another sister - she'd better not divorce this guy!". This comment came from someone who was shooting 40+ weddings a year for the previous 10 years.

So - in short - no. In full - Hell NO.
 
No - I have turned my sister down for March next year as she wants me to be chief bridesmaid aswell, my 7 yr old to be flower girl and my 4 yr old to be page boy. She also wants me to help look after her 2 boys age 3 and 5. Far too many jobs to also do the photography!
 
I wouldn't, simply because I'd want to be involved as a guest rather than as staff at my Bro's wedding. Sure, I'd take my camera.
 
Personally I wouldnt. Mainly because as much as I enjoy photography I would prefer to enjoy my brother/sisters wedding more :)
 
I wouldn't because even with the best intentions and will in the world, if something went disastrously wrong on the photography side including something completely out of your control... unlike a customer you dont know - you have an enraged brother/sister/whatever who in most likelyhood would hold you personally responsible.

An angry customer is one thing, an angry relative whose 'big day' was ruined is quite another something that they may never forgive you with for many years to come.

The above scenario is very unlikely to happen but for me the 'risk' factor and the consequences would make me think.. No! ;)
 
Personally, no. I would rather enjoy the day with them than have to worry about photographing it all.

I must admit i do have reservations

Bit late now isn't it Mondo?
 
As a student I worked in a camera store. A guy came in and asked about films specifically because he was going to photograph his sons wedding.

As the months progressed and the wedding date got nearer , this guy came in to the store more and more stressed out asking all sorts of questions.

On the morning of the wedding he rushed in to ask a few more questions and I thought he was going to have a heart attack, he was grey and wheezing.

On the Monday he came in with the films and asked loads of questions around what would happen if they got lost, and a bizzare fantisy that his whole family would break up, his sons marrage would fail should the pictures not turn out.

I have mever seen somone more releived to see a set of pictures in all my life, the happiness nearly did him in.

My observation, if you want to shorten your life and damage your mental health photograph a releatives wedding :bonk:
 
No I wouldn't, however I would if no one else was going to.
 
No and if I could have avoided it (without alienating the rest of the family), I wouldn't have attended it. Again, if it had been avoidable I wouldn't have had her at mine.
 
I couldn't if I wanted to as I don't have nearly the level of skill required.

Even if I did though I would say no - I'd want to go as a guest, maybe take my camera along for candid shots, but I couldn't enjoy the day if there was any pressure attached to taking any photo's.
 
Definitely, it would have meant I could have stayed out of the photographs


Same here, I did my dads and managed to esape with only a couple of shots that included me that I set camera up for and let someone else press the button. :woot:



However, seriously....hmmm....if I was a wedding shooter anyway, maybe. Hard to say isn't it unless you are asked and its a reality. I think if it was a full blown big wedding, probably not, but a smaller intimate affair, then maybe yes. :shrug:
 
I'd take a camera, but I wouldn't do any official photography. Personally if a family member is getting married I'd rather enjoy the wedding than spend time worrying about photography.
 
I refused to do a relatives wedding 9 years ago, they haven't spoken to me since, but I'm happy with that :cool: ;)

Nigel.
 
I really don't see how you can perform well as both a guest and "the" photographer at the same event. As a guest you should be relaxing, chatting, having a drink and socialising with friends and relatives, not really caring about the timing and order of events. As a photographer you should be working out the sequence of events, where to position yourself, the lighting, the perspectives, the backgrounds, the choice of lens, the camera settings, possibly organising people etc. etc.. Either you are part of the proceedings or you are documenting them. At my own sibling's wedding I'd far rather be part of the event, not merely a witness to it. The same goes for the wedding of any friend or family member.

I say this based on the experience of having photographed two weddings for friends/family. Apart from the hard work involved before, during and after, you really do miss out on the day itself. I will not shoot another wedding for F&F.
 
I would and in fact have done so. Did the photography for my sisters wedding a couple of years ago. I'm not in all the photo's but so what, as above thats what a tripod and self timer can be used for.

I still had a very good day, just happened to be taking photo's as well :D
 
I really don't see how you can perform well as both a guest and "the" photographer at the same event. As a guest you should be relaxing, chatting, having a drink and socialising with friends and relatives, not really caring about the timing and order of events. As a photographer you should be working out the sequence of events, where to position yourself, the lighting, the perspectives, the backgrounds, the choice of lens, the camera settings, possibly organising people etc. etc.. Either you are part of the proceedings or you are documenting them. At my own sibling's wedding I'd far rather be part of the event, not merely a witness to it. The same goes for the wedding of any friend or family member.

I say this based on the experience of having photographed two weddings for friends/family. Apart from the hard work involved before, during and after, you really do miss out on the day itself. I will not shoot another wedding for F&F.

Exactly, had to be 100% professional and take myself out of the day and photograph. Only stopped for the dinner, even at the speeches i picked up my camera again. You either do one or the other, or the photos will not be the best of your ability and then why bother in the first place?
 
As others have said, I would much rather be a guest than the togger, thats just me.

I love a good wedding, and dont appreciate them as much when I am working :)
 
I wouldn't. I'd like to do weddings one day, but right now I can't imagine how anyone does it when it's all they have to focus on, let alone having to do all the shots, AND be in them, AND be a guest and have some great memories of the wedding.

I'd do something stupid, mess up, and wouldn't have been a good guest or a good photographer!! But that's just me!
 
Back
Top