Why would I buy a Fisheye lens?

Speaking of screw in fisheyes, Nikon produced a surprisingly good one for their Coolpix 9XX digital cameras, the ones with the twist screen & lens design.

Nikon Coolpix 990 1577.JPG
 
It's been a while (long while) since I looked at crop sensor lenses, but Tokina 10-17mm fisheye zoom every time. Should be easy on the budget.

It's a bonkers 180º rectilinear (so square image, not a circle in the frame which personally I'm not a fan of) fisheye at 10mm, but to stop it being a one trick pony, zoom in to 12-15mm and it's just a bendy bonkers super wide angle lens. So it's not the usual fisheye one trick pony.
I suspect the Tokina may be much the same as my Pentax 10-17 (possibly even identical?). In which case I agree an excellent option. But it's not rectilinear as that term means it presents straight lines as straight lines with minimal distortion - basically all lenses other than fisheyes.

I couldn't recommend a macro for Canon, the only Canon macro I know id the MPE 65 which is fantastic but somewhat more specialised than normal macro options
 
Decent budget(ish!) macro options are the Tamron 90mm and Sigma 105mm. I ended up with a Tamron purely because that was what turned up on a local 2nd hand shelf first.
 
Decent budget(ish!) macro options are the Tamron 90mm and Sigma 105mm. I ended up with a Tamron purely because that was what turned up on a local 2nd hand shelf first.
You probably don't mean the same Tamron 90mm macro as I have, mines an old Adaptall2 model, an excellent lens but only managing half life size. Sadly mine is not in great condition, but it did only cost me £1 with the right mount fitted :)
 
You're right, I mean the (relatively!) modern f/2.8 version rather than the older f/2.5.
 
I've got an R7. Although I've always had a 10-18 lens I wanted something wider. After an abortive trial of Sigma 8-16 (not wide enough and too heavy ) I bought a 7Artisans 7.5mm fish-eye. Only £149 from Amazon (DO NOT BUY FROM 7ARTISANS!. Cheaper but major hassles)
Manual focus, but set it to 2/3 way between 1metre and infinity and everything from 50cmto infinity is in focus.
Some shots from Oxford Open Doors
Atrium, Schwarzman Centre, Oxford
View: https://www.flickr.com/photos/kenbarley/55544669742/in/album-72157665753456421/

Staircase, Rhodes House, Oxford
View: https://www.flickr.com/photos/kenbarley/55558602060/in/album-72157665753456421/

Staircase, Rhodes House, Oxford


Ken
 
I suspect the Tokina may be much the same as my Pentax 10-17 (possibly even identical?). In which case I agree an excellent option. But it's not rectilinear as that term means it presents straight lines as straight lines with minimal distortion - basically all lenses other than fisheyes.

I couldn't recommend a macro for Canon, the only Canon macro I know id the MPE 65 which is fantastic but somewhat more specialised than normal macro options

[Edit] PS yes the Pentax 10-17 & Tok 10-17 are one and the same. Not the only Pentax lens that's made for Pentax by Tokina.

The MPE is a specialist lens, for true Macro geeks. For the rest of us

All 1:1 capable
Tamron 90mm Macro
Sigma 100 (could be 105 can't remember)
Canon 60mm USM? EF-S
Canon 100mm USM (and the even older non USM)
Canon 100mm L USM (IS?)

I'd say the 60mm EF-S or the 100mm USM should be the good budget options nowadays. I still use the 100mm USM (non L) on my my modern R6

Even the ye ancient Canon 50mm F2.5 macro. This is only 1:2, bloody slow focus, needs extension tubes or Tele-converter for 1:1 (there was a proper Canon adapter for it for 1:1), I had one many years ago & used it with a Kenko 1.5x TC & Jessops extension tubes and still some of my fave macro images are from this.
 
Last edited:
I bought a 7Artisans 7.5mm fish-eye.
I wonder if that's the same design as the Samyang 7.5mm that I've used for ten years or so....

Fisheye leaning tree Glasshouse Lane E-PL5 P7200003.JPG
 
Now theres a point.I'm accident prone,my children refer to me as Mr Bump so it's very likely that if I stepped back somewhere without looking there's going to be a 1000ft drop into a river full of crocodiles. Although thinking about it there aren't many 1000ft drops around Huddersfield and I'm sure we don't have crocodiles, still,it looks like a good reason to buy a fisheye.
Emley moor mast, might be interesting with the fish eye
 
Emley moor mast, might be interesting with the fish eye
Now there's a thousand foot drop although there weren't any crocodiles there the last time we went . But,being serious for a nanosecond, I will bear that in mind when I get a lens. I remember when the first one fell down,I was on my paper round in Kirkheaton and was looking over at the mast and suddenly it wasn't there, I didn't really think anything of it until I got home and my Mum said the tv was off. You can still make out where one of the stay cables cut the chapel in half across the road.
 
It's been a while (long while) since I looked at crop sensor lenses, but Tokina 10-17mm fisheye zoom every time. Should be easy on the budget.

It's a bonkers 180º rectilinear (so square image, not a circle in the frame which personally I'm not a fan of) fisheye at 10mm, but to stop it being a one trick pony, zoom in to 12-15mm and it's just a bendy bonkers super wide angle lens. So it's not the usual fisheye one trick pony.
Thanks,I'll have a look.
 
It's been a while (long while) since I looked at crop sensor lenses, but Tokina 10-17mm fisheye zoom every time. Should be easy on the budget.

It's a bonkers 180º rectilinear (so square image, not a circle in the frame which personally I'm not a fan of) fisheye at 10mm, but to stop it being a one trick pony, zoom in to 12-15mm and it's just a bendy bonkers super wide angle lens. So it's not the usual fisheye one trick pony.
£75-£120 so easily affordable, I'll have one of those in the next couple of weeks.
 
I've still got an OM2 and an OM2N, brilliant lightweight cameras, the viewfinders are so clear and bright.
I sold my Om2n about 5 years ago for twenty sodding quid and regretted it immediately, I should have kept the camera even just to look at ,I started with a Zenith 11 with slr cameras,it was all I could afford at the time but the photos it took were light years ahead of the crappy 110 and disc camera thing I had been using. It taught me how to take half decent photos and how to use a light meter,f stop ,iso and so on,( something I have forgotten how to do in the last 25 years ). I then got the Olympus with a 135mm lens,an 18-70(?) and another which I can't remember, I took thousands of photos with that ,the action of the shutter compared to the Zenith was like driving a Serie II Landie then driving a Ferrari, the quality was again light years ahead. Then digital cameras arrived and I remember buying a 3.5mp Olympus zoom camera for £350. That burned through AA batteries using the zoom like they were going out of fashion. (Just before the arrival of the digital camera I bought an Olympus 35mm compact which I loved,brilliant for carrying in your pocket and the quality of the camera and the images were as good as the Om2n, that fortunately is still sat in the cupboard, unused and unloved for 25 years,however, unlike the Om2n it's going nowhere).
Then 15 years ago my sons bought me the 600d and,because it's got a sports mode I can machine gun images so again I have got lazy. Now with the R7 and the new 100-400 Rf lens ,an adapter and my EF lens I am going to start learning to take photographs again. And,where did we start with this thread? Oh I know, why should I buy a fisheye? No reason other than I always wanted one for the Om2n. Look what just got delivered. 56497.jpg
 
Ooo jealous. As I say really missed the 10-17. Can be bendy bendy, or slightly less bendy as a daft wide angle. Look forward to the results
I've got the 10-17,now I just need to take it out and use it. I only paid £100 + postage and it looks to be in really good condition (I've probably spent more than that tryingto make sourdough bread and failed miserably,this is much more use), it's something I have wanted for many years. Now I'm trying to find a 4mm lens for use on either the 600d or the R7, the mad circular images they produce are something I would also like to have a go at.
 
The hood looks much bigger than the Pentax 10-17 fisheye, is that because of the slight difference in APSC crop factors?
PK is 1.5x & EF is 1.6x
I haven't a clue,I'm just starting again with photography really, I last used an slr with any kind of knowledge or skill over 25 years ago, I've got lazy since,sticking the 600d on auto and machinegunning everything, time to get back to learning how to use my new R7 properly. And the 600d.
 
The hood looks much bigger than the Pentax 10-17 fisheye, is that because of the slight difference in APSC crop factors?
PK is 1.5x & EF is 1.6x

2 versions of the Pentax 10-17 IIRC - one (the HD) is full-frame compatible, the other (SMC) isn't....the Tokina is equivalent to the SMC, I stand corrected if I am wrong..

Returning to OT.. I've been eyeing the Nikon 8-15, it gets really annoying when you are framing a shot in a cathedral/basilica with a Z14-30 or Hd-DFA 15-30 you can't quite get it all in, and then someone with a mobile stands straight in front of you, having something wider allows you to jump back in front of the offender..
 
...and then someone with a mobile stands straight in front of you, having something wider allows you to jump back in front of the offender..
"Offender"? I didn't know there was a law against standing in front of another person... :thinking:
 
2 versions of the Pentax 10-17 IIRC - one (the HD) is full-frame compatible, the other (SMC) isn't....the Tokina is equivalent to the SMC, I stand corrected if I am wrong..
..
Mine is the SMC version (I got it years before the HD one came out). From what I've heard on Pentax forums the difference is only improved coatings.

I have tried it adapted on my A7ii, where it obviously doesn't cover the sensor, the adapter mounted the lens slightly rotated so the hood (now visible) was noticeably out of alignment - so no geed for a nearer circular image.

Checking on-line sellers describe the HD version as for APS-C, but I notice several of the pictures show it without a hood, while the hood on mine is permanently fixed. So the HD version might be better for FF (with the hood removed).
 
Last edited:
Golly gosh...

I begin to imagine a spin off thread starting on the subject of "entitled photographers"! :exit:
 
Ooo jealous. As I say really missed the 10-17. Can be bendy bendy, or slightly less bendy as a daft wide angle. Look forward to the results
I've just been up to both Castle Hill and Emley Moor mast with the 10-17mm Tokina and I'm over the moon with it. Whoopee.
 

Attachments

  • 57073.jpg
    57073.jpg
    79.8 KB · Views: 7
  • 57074.jpg
    57074.jpg
    94.8 KB · Views: 7
  • 57084.jpg
    57084.jpg
    52 KB · Views: 7
  • 57083.jpg
    57083.jpg
    36.2 KB · Views: 5
  • 57082.jpg
    57082.jpg
    34.7 KB · Views: 4
I've found in the past that there are alternatives to a brought fisheye lens, but the enclosure certainly wasn't very portable & resolution wasn't that good: :D
IMGP9750ac.jpg
 
Last edited:
If you don't know where you'd use one you don't need one.
Twas really a rhetorical question to get those who know more than me - which is just about everyone- to show me subjects I might not consider
Like Emley Moor mast, which I can see out of my room window.
 
I like fisheyes, even those allegedly horrible "screw on to the front of your standard lens" lens ones...

View attachment 495189
I now have two, a second hand Tokina 10-17mm and a brand new IAOWA 4.5-10mm- after 40 years of wanting one of them I couldn't resist it. Now all I need is some spare time to go out and use them, I'm over the moon with the Tokina,my brain is still fizzing from programming my camera to get the other to work but just messing around in the house with it I'm giddy with excitement. Now,do I get the 4mm 210° lens as well?
 
Might have already been mentioned in the thread somewhere, but maybe just buy a standard wide angle lens and apply the fisheye effect in Photoshop?
 
Back
Top