My approach was camera in manual then control flash with flash power. Yours is camera in manual + TTL flash and adjust flash with flash exp comp. Sounds about the same.
I can see how TTL flash is better with moving subjects or reflectors but overall the approach is similar?
This Is an interesting question, or at least it interests me, so I’ll bore you with a fairly full answer, but the short answer is to do whatever works best for you
Longer answer: ETTL flash is incredibly useful technology; basically it doesn’t always get it right but it nearly always gets it almost right, it’s a natural choice in many shooting scenarios because of this, even for very experienced photographers.
I know nothing about either your camera or your new flash, but I’ll say this; new flashes include a lot of technology that works extremely well, plus various “marketing benefits” that are really only useful to the sellers in the sense that they try to persuade us to buy that particular flashgun. Flashgun development hasn’t changed much for many years, they are still very low-powered tools that pretend to be powerful, and their various marketing features just make them over-complicated, slow to use and increase the potential for error. It’s probably because of this that a lot of the old boys like myself use them mainly on manual settings, I find manual to be easier, faster and much more reliable, but neither auto nor manual are “right” for everyone.
Manufacturers tell us all sorts of things about their wonderful products, some statements are true and some are blatantly false, for example, they tell us that their products produce “beautiful soft light” when the truth is that the softness of the light is only about the size of the tiny flash head, which can only produce soft light if we photograph something the size of a pea with the flash almost touching the subject - which is one of the reasons why we normally bounce the light whenever we can. Power is another deception. For some reason manufacturers seem to forget to tell us about the real power output of their flashguns, few if any produce more than 70-100 watt-seconds of light, which is low. What they DO tell us is the guide number; this is amplified partly because of the mirror-like surface of the reflector, with the downside of creating very harsh and uneven light, and partly by the zoom settings available, which means that the flashguns that have the highest guide numbers tend to also have the longest zoom settings – the quoted guide numbers are with the flash set to the longest zoom setting, which many of us never use. I’ve written an intro article about this, a bit dated now but hopefully still helpful
https://www.talkphotography.co.uk/tutorials/which-type-of-flash.153/
Yes, but I suppose because I come from film where the only way of knowing whether the flash exposure was correct was to calculate it, and for bounced flash that’s not easy.
I see TTL flash (and auto thryister flash before it) as a great help. But I suppose if you’re gonna chimp And adjust, it’s the same thing.
Yes, with film we had to get it right first time, and we’d only know whether it was right or not when we’d developed the film. This meant we had to calculate, and that we quickly learned to do it properly.
Go back even further, when the only flash we had was flashbulbs. I could write a whole article on their limitations. Still, basically they were single-use bulbs that were incredibly expensive, couldn’t be adjusted for power, had to be used at very low shutter speeds and so were overwhelmed if used in bright light. They typically had a guide number of just 24.4 or thereabouts at 100 iso. And, to make them even more limited, typical B&W film at that time was 100 iso, so was colour negative at best, colour slide, used by most pros, was originally 10 iso with Kodachrome, then improved to 25 iso, and my film of choice, Agfa CT18, was 50 iso. So, flash back then was limited, the real progress came with digital cameras and more powerful flashguns.
Let’s get right back on topic. It seems to me from what little you’ve said, that your main concern was exposure, i.e. that you wanted to have ENOUGH light for the shot to look right. That’s understandable and entirely normal for a beginner, but it’s the wrong approach. The right approach is to create the right QUALITY of light, not the right QUANTITY, i.e to create light that flatters the subject. It’s about creating the right shadows in the right places, and this applies to all photography regardless of the type of light used, and the trick is to make the lighting look so natural that non-photographers don’t even notice the lighting.
So, with this type of subject, we want the light to appear to come from where nearly all light comes from, which is basically from above, so bouncing the light from the ceiling and/or a wall behind you is the obvious way to go.
Personally, I’d do this.
- Get myself in the right place for the shot.
- Set the shutter speed to 1/250th, the fastest speed you can use with your camera I think, to reduce the effect of the ambient light as far as possible.
- Take a test shot WITHOUT flash, this will show just how badly the shot is affected by the window and any other ambient light.
- Turn on the flash, bounce it as well as you can and take a shot at full power. Does this show the window light adequately? – we don’t want the shot to look as if it was taken at midnight, and we don’t want the table lamp to look as if it’s switched off.
- Take more shots if and as necessary, reducing the power in stages until it looks right to you. ETTL may or may not produce the results you want.
Oh, and as an aside, forget about all of the gadgets such as diffusers, which make bold claims but basically just waste light.