50mm 1.2 vs 70-200 2.8 IS at a wedding?

Messages
356
Name
Jon
Edit My Images
No
I need some opinions from people that have shot weddings...

Which lens is more valuable?
 
i would say the 70-200mm would be more useful for its range and is still quite fast!

you may be limited by the fixed focal length of the 50 but i guess it will have merits over the 70-200 as well.
 
I think they both have a place at weddings. The 70-200mm is ideal for catching more modern reportage shots where people are unaware you are photographing them, I love these types of shots, they are so natural.

50mm 1.2 is ideal for low light scenarios when you can't use the flash, ceremony, speeches etc. etc.

What are the couple looking for? If they are wanting just formal shots then I would go with the nifty, if they are wanting candid shots of their guests the 70-200 is perfect.

I know this probably doesn't help too much, but its a bit like saying what would you prefer to use a Ferrari or a Range Rover............. both are lovely motors, but it all depends what type of road you are going to be driving on!!!!

To call it I would say 70-200
 
I have the 70-200 IS 2.8 and a 50 1.4 and shoot weddings quite often.

The 70-200 is great in churches as generally they're not well lit and every now and again you'll find that the people in charge want you right out of the way if you're taking photos. This will give you a damn decent reach and 2.8 should be plenty open enough to get some decent shots!

However! The aperture on the 50mm is really great, you can take shots in super dark environments as if you're in a much lighter place without any trouble at all. The bokeh from the 50mm is also pretty awesome!

If I had to choose between the 50mm 1.2 and the 70-200 I'd cheap out on the 50mm 1.2 and get the 50mm 1.4 and the 70-200. Sure it's a little extra cash but if I had the 50mm 1.2 I'd be wishing I had the 50mm 1.0!

I definitely think that both lenses are well worth having and are invaluable for weddings. Also I completely agree with "The Bulb" the 70-200mm is excellent for catching reportage shots, the extra length on the lens will catch people's natural expressions far more easily.

Here's a selection of shots using both lenses .. Just incase you want to see them!

50mm 1.4
50mm 1.4
50mm 1.4
50mm 1.4
50mm 1.4
70-200
70-200
 
Thanks for the input guys!

I guess I'll go for the 70-200, since I already have the 50mm 1.8.

I'd be wishing I had the 50mm 1.0!

I thought that the 1.0 was discontinued because of optical issues?
 
I have to 24-105 as well .. I do find that F4 isn't enough. Even with the IS, sometimes you just need a faster shutter speed. When shooting weddings I guess it depends how you shoot but if you're trying to do any reportage shots with a 24-105 in low light it's hard to get the shutter quick enough to avoid motion blur.

Still a great lens though! The IS definitely works well too.
 
what body?

how about the 24..105 F4L?

even with it's 3-stop IS?

I have to 24-105 as well .. I do find that F4 isn't enough. Even with the IS, sometimes you just need a faster shutter speed. When shooting weddings I guess it depends how you shoot but if you're trying to do any reportage shots with a 24-105 in low light it's hard to get the shutter quick enough to avoid motion blur.

Still a great lens though! The IS definitely works well too.


It will struggle. I'm talking from experience, excellent lens but not very good in low light conditions :(

JMPhotographic has it spot on.

Hope this helps
 
Sorry to hijack this thread but do you think the 24-70 2.8L on a 5D body would be a good lens for a wedding?
 
Definitely .. I'd recommend the 24-70 2.8L and the 70-200 IS 2.8L they're both excellent lenses and make a great pair, perfect for weddings!

You've got to bear in mind that 24 is quite wide on a 5D though. You'll probably want something a bit "zoomier" to go with it (depending on how close you want to get of course).
 
I recently shot a gig in very low light, the 24-105 F4 IS struggled big time, the best shots I got were all with the 50mm F1.8.

The 24-105 is great outside or with flash, but in low light it's not going to deliver!
 
Back
Top