5D Mark II - Tests

Messages
1,511
Edit My Images
No
I have a new 5D Mark II due to arrive today, can anyone suggest how best to test for the following, which I believe are some of the problems people have been having (hopefully mine will be spot on!). It's obviously got 12 months UK warranty but I just want to make sure all is OK from the start:

- Vertical banding at low ISO
- Hot pixels
- Err99 message - what causes / triggers this?

Is there anything else I should check?

Thanks in advance

Dave
 
I can remember when I got my 20D testing it and finding a few hot pixels etc and worrying about what to do... then I realised I couldn't see any problem in the pictures and have never bothered with testing a camera since.
Personally I'd just take some pictures and see how they come out :)

Enjoy the 5D2. Might join you next year.
 
Dave - before you do any tests make sure you are using the latest firmware otherwise you will need to repeat the tests.
Good luck finding problems - you are likely to struggle!

Black dots - in the year I've had my 5DII I've only ever spotted them on only one image by taking pixel peeping to extreme levels. That was with the firmware update that was supposed to fix it. It will never cause you a problem.

Vertical Banding - I have seen this at ISO 100 when I fluffed my exposure and tried pulling the shadows in PP by over 4 stops. Still wasn't stupidly bad but did have banding. If you take the shot even approximately right you will never suffer from this. High ISO is a different matter H2 cannot be pulled without lots of banding, H1 is a lot better and 6400 is wonderful. I know I can take an image at 6400 and print at A3 with no noise reduction and the print will look superb.

Hot Pixels - it's weird but Lightroom shows a few hot pixels in the low quality image displayed before it fully loads the rest of the RAW file, then they vanish as soon as it finishes loading. Like Robert I have never seen a hot pixel in a production image. I read hot pixels can more easily be spotted in high ISO video, I tried but failed to spot any.

Err 99 - I had that. I think it was dirt on the lens contacts as cleaning then with my lens cloth sorted it out. My 20D used to get that with the same lens - same fix too.

I've had one weirdo where the camera locked up on me. Even turning it off and on didn't fix it. Battery out for a minute sorted it out.

Long exposures (15min+) and Live View eat batteries. I twice managed to flatten a fully charged battery in a single day. I eventually managed to find a source for a second battery; they were unobtainable for a LONG time.

IIRC your old 5D metering is similar to my old 20D. I believe the evaluative metering changed significantly on the 40D onwards - you will notice! I gave up guessing whether the evaluative metering would get it right and now use center weighted metering.

I was initially very disappointed by the 5DII. It was better than the 20D but wasn't producing the jaw dropping image quality I was hoping for, just a lot more pixels. After a lot of navel gazing I found the problem - my technique. To get the best image quality you have to be a HUGE perfectionist but when you get it right by god it delivers. Producing an A0 print you can walk right up to 10 inches away from and still feel you aren't seeing all the detail is an amazing thing. But it took a huge learning curve to get that image and you should not expect it from day one.
 
Thanks guys - very helpful indeed. It has arrived, why do Canon never charge the batteries?! Thought it was a DOA for a minute!

Charging now so will let you know how I get on - fingers crossed all will be fine.
 
LOL - I forgot about that!
The other annoying thing you have probably just discovered is the neck strap - Canon have gone the Nikon route with the model number in large bold letters - GRRRRR
One of the things I like about the 5DII is that it is so discreet, virtually indistinguishable from the lesser models and does not shout LOOK AT ME.
I will never use my 5DII neck strap..............
 
LOL - I forgot about that!
The other annoying thing you have probably just discovered is the neck strap - Canon have gone the Nikon route with the model number in large bold letters - GRRRRR
One of the things I like about the 5DII is that it is so discreet, virtually indistinguishable from the lesser models and does not shout LOOK AT ME.
I will never use my 5DII neck strap..............

Lol, I did the same with mine, apart from this posh work-related do where I wanted to look the bee's knees ;)
 
Well, I've given it a thorough test and it seems perfect to me - no problems at all.

Loving the 5D Mark II so far.
 
Congratulations on your new purchase!

After our swapped PMs I went with the 7D. I can see two hot pixels on long exposure in the dark but I'm not worried. From what I've read they are common place in small numbers.
 
Congrats on your new purchase Dave & thanks for all your help and advice. I'm sure you will love the full frame goodness of the 5D MkII. :lol:

As a newbie here I am just about to get into the highly addictive world of digital photography and quite honestly......i can't wait.
 
I never even bothered with the micro adjustment on my 5d2, it was jaw dropping from the off. I see no reason for me to interfere with that :)
 
I never even bothered with the micro adjustment on my 5d2, it was jaw dropping from the off. I see no reason for me to interfere with that :)

Same here!

I agree that the 5D mk II will mercilessly show up poor technique. For example, forget the rule of thumb about using a minimum shutter speed of one over the lens focal length to eliminate camera shake, e.g. 1/50 sec for a 50mm. In my experience you'd want to double or quadruple this for absolute sharpness - those tiny pixels will reveal any degree of blur.

A.
 
Anaorakus - yup - been there!
Also cable release and mirror lockup (or live view) is essential
Also the slightest wind buffetting, even on a decent tripod
Also avoid using lens wide open unless shallow DoF needed or it is an exceptional lens
Also avoid f16/f22 unless the big DoF is needed as diffraction softens the shot

I'm sure I've missed some!
 
Back
Top