A loch through a time gone by.

[Galaxy66]

A few I have found from my recent trip to skye.
Which do you prefer?
1.

2.

3.

 

[hillwalkinggirl]

I prefer the composition of No 3 but it does look a little soft. I think it could be improved by adjusting the levels and then sharpening it up a bit. A nice shot of a beautiful place though.

 

[sawman]

Do not take this the wrong way. I think you should have made more of the old hay turner. Getting closer, different angles etc. Of the three though no2 has it for me as you are left wondering what the wheels are connected too.

 

[CT]

No3 for me with perhaps a tad more contrast?

 

[Galaxy66]

No3 for me with perhaps a tad more contrast?

Thanks CT not sure if I have replaced it with the re-edited version maybe I should have posted it in a reply.

I prefer the composition of No 3 but it does look a little soft. I think it could be improved by adjusting the levels and then sharpening it up a bit. A nice shot of a beautiful place though.

Thanks, I had forgotten to sharpen it, better now

Do not take this the wrong way. I think you should have made more of the old hay turner. Getting closer, different angles etc. Of the three though no2 has it for me as you are left wondering what the wheels are connected too.

You say what you like, good or bad, it's all good advice

 

[Galaxy66]

One more bit cluttered maybe:thumbsdown:

 

[hepburn]

i actually prefer that one mal, perhaps improved by cloning out the boats...?