A quickie for those of you who understand resolution, sensor sizes, image sizes etc

chris321

I like the ginger one
Messages
3,575
Name
Chris
Edit My Images
Yes
Right then gang, here's my situation:

I'm considering buying a backup cropped sensor body to compliment my 5DII. The main reason for this is to firstly have a smaller body for those times when I want a scaled down kit (probably going for an xxxD one), and also to get a little more length out of my longer lenses.

It got me thinking however, what resolution cropped sensor would I need to provide an advantage over just cropping the image on my 5DII?

Now I think:

The 5DII's sensor is 36x24mm, and a resolution of 5616 x 3744
A crop sensor is 22.3 x 14.9 mm.

This means that 5616 pixels along 36mm equates to 156 pixels per mm on the sensor, and 3744 pixels vertically along 24mm also equals 156mm per mm (I thought they would be the same, but wanted to check)

So multiplying the cropped sensor size by the same pixels per mm as the 5D sensor, that gives 3478.8 x 2324.4, which equates to 8MP. So that means the sensor region on the 5D's sensor that would fit a crop sensor onto it would be 8MP, so theoretically...

If I got a crop sensor camera with resolution greater than 8MP, this should give more 'reach' that cropping on my 5D?

Yes? No? Am I barking up the right tree? In the right forest?

I know there are other issues to consider like noise, quality, etc etc, but just humour me purely based on what gives greater reach please :)

Chris
 
Makes sense to me for what it's worth.
 
The higher the MP density the greater the crop potential but resolution counts a great deal and the resolution of your 5D II is recognised as superior to virtually all crop cameras.

This means that, in reality, your 5DII would give better cropping potential than a 1.6 or 1.3 "crop" camera.

Plus it has far superior noise, which would also limit how much you could crop an "inferior" camera.

.
 
Makes sense to me for what it's worth.

Cheers :)


You know what other things dogs do to trees?

I think the short answer is yes.

Not a clue, I'm a cat person :D


This means that, in reality, your 5DII would give better cropping potential than a 1.6 or 1.3 "crop" camera

But if I cropped the 5D image to what a cropped camera with the same pixel density would create, you'd only be left with a 8MP image... So if I had a 12MP image from a crop camera, if I were to crop that, it would give 'better' (in one sense of the word, ignoring noise etc) results than cropping the 5D image to the same framing (i.e. the final image looking the same).

Anyone following? I can picture it all very clearly in my head, it's coming across less eloquently in writing :D
 
One thing I'm thinking of though isn't just about how many pixels you have to crop but the quality of those pixels. No point being able to crop in closer if the quality of those pixels is not so good.

Technically you'd be able to zoom in closer, but would you want to? Hmmm, now I'm thinking about this I wonder how many paces forward you'd have to go to make a full frame show the equiv of a cropped?
 
One thing I'm thinking of though isn't just about how many pixels you have to crop but the quality of those pixels. No point being able to crop in closer if the quality of those pixels is not so good.

Technically you'd be able to zoom in closer, but would you want to? Hmmm, now I'm thinking about this I wonder how many paces forward you'd have to go to make a full frame show the equiv of a cropped?

Hmm, good point! It's something to sleep on I guess!

As for how many paces, I'd have thought it varies with the situation (and how far away your subject is). For example, if it was a landscape, you may have to move metres forward to get the framing the same. If it's macro, then millimetres!
 
A little googling threw up some reading for you

http://www.robsphotography.co.nz/crop-factor-advantage-7D-5DII.html

and a bit more with some examples

http://www.thephotoforum.com/forum/...s-news-reviews/187958-eos-7d-eos-5d-mkii.html

http://digitalphotobuzz.com/canon-7d-vs-5d-comparison


I guess it's also a question of what you're going to do with those extra pixels. Planning on making 30 x 20 prints? or just posting them on the web?

If you just want a smaller camera body, then get a smaller camera body. :thinking:
 
A little googling threw up some reading for you

http://www.robsphotography.co.nz/crop-factor-advantage-7D-5DII.html

and a bit more with some examples

http://www.thephotoforum.com/forum/...s-news-reviews/187958-eos-7d-eos-5d-mkii.html

http://digitalphotobuzz.com/canon-7d-vs-5d-comparison


I guess it's also a question of what you're going to do with those extra pixels. Planning on making 30 x 20 prints? or just posting them on the web?

If you just want a smaller camera body, then get a smaller camera body. :thinking:

Cheers for the links, I'll definitely have a read through that in the morning. Haha, definitely want a smaller body, but I want one that I can also use for sports occasionally to get a little more reach, or just as a backup to the 5D, hence I'm interested in how many MP I need to make it worthwhile, which determines which smaller body I get :)

Cheers for posting though at this unpleasant hour :lol: :thumbs:
 
Taking your last post into consideration I'd perhaps not worry so much about the resolution but more about the camera's focusing ability and FPS.

The 50D can do over 6fps and the 7D can do 8fps, both good for sports etc. But one has to wonder if the camera's AI Servo focusing system can keep up with such fps speeds?

I personally believe a camera's resolution should only be taken into consideration in relation to the final output size of the photograph. Otherwise, if you want to get closer then either move closer or use a longer lens so that image quality isn't sacrificed. The D3 is an excellent example because they ensured that although it's not jammed packed with pixels, the pixels that are there are of the highest quality and will allow tons of flexibility with high ISO.

I'm rambling now. Damn that wine.
 
Your leaving out one thing, the pixel size, the pixels in the 5D are larger and thus grab more light, they are also arranged slightly differently.

But the crux of it is that you wont beat the resolution of your 5D cropped but will get close..

The obvious choice would be a 7D, but that's not light, if you want to pop round some afternoon/evening with a couple of lenses you would use your welcome to try my 500D, its dinky enough that I would consider popping it in a large jacket pocket with the nifty on it.
 
Taking your last post into consideration I'd perhaps not worry so much about the resolution but more about the camera's focusing ability and FPS.

The 50D can do over 6fps and the 7D can do 8fps, both good for sports etc. But one has to wonder if the camera's AI Servo focusing system can keep up with such fps speeds?

I almost posted something similar, but figured from the language that it was to be for relatively casual sports use.

And it may depend on the sports Chris is shooting. I guess for golf or bowls, for example, AF tracking isn't so critical as it would be for football or motor racing :)
 
Last edited:
Taking your last post into consideration I'd perhaps not worry so much about the resolution but more about the camera's focusing ability and FPS.

The 50D can do over 6fps and the 7D can do 8fps, both good for sports etc.

.......

I'm rambling now. Damn that wine.

Sorry, probably should have given you guys a bit more background! I shoot for my university paper, I'm not a professional sports photographer. When I do shoot sports, the only requirement is that I get a few showing some action of the game, my livelihood doesn't depend on it :D

I've previously used a 450D and a 50D with a sigma 70-200 for sports stuff (just chose my locations carefully so as not to be hugely limited by lack of length). I never really found the AF to be an issue, and to be honest as long as it's relatively in-focus, a slight error is unlikely to be noticed! Having used the 50D at full 6.3 once, I vowed never to do it again! It just filled up my cards in minutes, my technique was awful and meant I got 6 rubbish shots per second rather than just one :lol:. So now I stick to composing the shot, waiting for the right moment, and taking them individually. If I miss a vital moment, it doesn't mean I don't get paid (I don't anyway!) so I'm not hugely fussed!

No apology needed re: the wine, I wasn't expecting such coherent posts starting a thread at midnight, so I was pleasantly surprised :D


Your leaving out one thing, the pixel size, the pixels in the 5D are larger and thus grab more light, they are also arranged slightly differently.

But the crux of it is that you wont beat the resolution of your 5D cropped but will get close..

The obvious choice would be a 7D, but that's not light, if you want to pop round some afternoon/evening with a couple of lenses you would use your welcome to try my 500D, its dinky enough that I would consider popping it in a large jacket pocket with the nifty on it.

I think I get the pixel size bit, but larger pixels in the same area means a lower resolution, and less cropability, doesn't it?! Getting confuzzled with myself now :bang:

Thank you very much for the kind offer to try the 500D :thumbs:. Unfortunately i'm back up to uni in a few days and it's going to be crazily busy, but I believe it's the same size as my old 450D so I can hazard a guess how it'll feel in the hand. Cheers for the help :)


I almost posted something similar, but figured from the language that it was to be for relatively casual sports use.

And it may depend on the sports Chris is shooting. I guess for golf or bowls, for example, AF tracking isn't so critical as it would be for football or motor racing :)

Yep, as above, I'm still going to have food on the table if I miss that crucial action shot! As for the sports, it's usually rugby or hockey, sometimes floodlit, but I can't say I've every really struggled with either the 450D or the 50D. I've never used a 1 series so obviously can't compare (I don't dare to either for my bank balances sake ;) ), but I reckon the AF the the lower-end bodies is better than many people would have you believe!

Cheers everyone, got lots to think about and even more to read up on :thumbs:

Chris
 
Back
Top