A rant on prices, economics, and trade barriers

Messages
832
Edit My Images
Yes
I am just fed up with this whole situation on photo equipment prices. I mean, why can't they realise that everybody is better off by the abolition of any trade barriers, both tariff and non-tariff? They've been on and off on that Doha Round since 2001 and everybody is just keeping their stance, trying to protect markets that are just out of date, uneconomical, and expensive to maintain. I mean it's the basics in game theory, it's the simplest form of the prisoners dilemma. Everyone is reaching an equilibrium of protectionism, without it being the optimum outcome. In every possible step of the game, each country thinks that it would be better off to just protect their markets, without realising that if they all open their economies to the global market, there would be such an increase in total revenue that in the mid run everybody would be better off. I mean, the reason we tax imports from Asia and the States is not for the tax revenue, but for retaliation for their import taxes, and their export subsidies. It's ridiculous. I mean, it's just a vicious circle: the Brazilians are protecting their sugar, cotton, coffee and whatever, so the French are protecting their agriculture, wine etc, so the Dutch are subsidising their tulips, the Japanese and Chinese in retaliation are pouring sh!t-loads of money on their electronics sector, and in the same time imposing taxes from every market in the EU, so the EU imposes silly taxations just to retaliate for the Asian's market protectionism. The result of this? ALL prices go up and the consumers have to pay the bride.

And then the credit crunch comes. And what do countries do? Protect their economies, giving more subsidies to local market sectors, bringing more retaliation from trade competitors, and in the same time, decreasing their interest rates, bringing their currencies down, with the effect of the consumer having to pay 50% higher prices on imported products, and another 17% on top of that as import tax. Can't they just realise that eventually everything will go belly-up and we'll use any trade advantage that we once had?

I don't want to sound mean, but why bother protecting markets that are bound to fail anyhow? Why don't countries just specialise in what they are comparatively advantaged? Asian countries are better at producing high-tech products, the Europeans are the best in mid tech products, like machinery and pharmaceuticals, the Americans have huge expanses of land and have the advantage of producing cheap agricultural products. If everyone specialises in what they are best at and able to produce it cheaply and in good quality, then we wouldn't spend resources on products that are too expensive for us to produce, and this vicious circle of protectionism and trade barriers would seize to exist. The advantage would be a HUGE decrease in prices of ALL products, and an increase in everybody's utility and well being because everybody could enjoy more goods and services for less money.

I know that I'm opening a can of worms here, but I would love to hear other people's opinions on this matter because I think it's just ridiculous.
 
I don't want to sound mean, but why bother protecting markets that are bound to fail anyhow? Why don't countries just specialise in what they are comparatively advantaged?


Because, to paraphrase Napoleon,we are now a nation of shop keepers. The days of this sceptred isle being the workshop of the world are long gone.
 
I know, and I think that's the problem. If everyone thinks that way, then no one will be better off.
 
Why don't countries just specialise in what they are comparatively advantaged?
We did. We were the best in the world at financial services. Probably still are, for what it's worth.

The trouble that some people see with the comparative-advantage strategy is that it looks awfully like the eggs-in-one-basket strategy.
 
Human nature is to protect what you've got first. Number one priority, always will be. In stable markets, the risk of losing what you've got is always perceived as higher than what you might gain, so market leaders will always try to protect their position first.
 
Back
Top