accepted crops of people

Messages
3,749
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi all,

Just a quick question, what do you think are accepted crops of people?

For instance, headshots, waist up and full body seem to be generally accepted however chopping people off from the knee isn't.

Are there any crops you don't think work and should never be done?
 
I think if you're going to crop, it needs to look like it was intentional. So I'd be annoyed if I cut off just the tips of the fingers, or just a hand in a whole body shot. I think it varies from shot to shot, but that's my general rule.

Chris
 
Don't crop AT joints - crop BETWEEN joints.

REMEMBER: whilst you're shooting, it is far better to include too much and crop later (especially if you have a reasonable sized sensor). But this doesn't mean shoot "wide", it means shoot further back and include more - wide (short focal lengths) can make people look uglier than required.

Steve
 
+2 on this advice. :thumbs:

Don't crop AT joints - crop BETWEEN joints.

REMEMBER: whilst you're shooting, it is far better to include too much and crop later (especially if you have a reasonable sized sensor). But this doesn't mean shoot "wide", it means shoot further back and include more - wide (short focal lengths) can make people look uglier than required.

Steve
 
This is from someone else, can't recall who though, it's just been languishing in my MacJournal notes for some time...

1. DON’T let the model put two hands behind her head with the elbows flung out like chicken wings unless she is in Kate Moss’ league. This is the most amateur of all poses. Corny is never in style!
2. DON’T crop your model at the hips. Let the body resolve itself to a thinner area between the knee and the waist. For female models, this lets the hourglass contour of a woman’s body reveal itself.
3. DON’T crop a person at the joints. This will lead the viewer out of the image, wherever that appendage exits the frame.
4. DON’T let your model lock an arm in a straight vertical position. This creates a big shoulder which, besides being a distraction, makes the head appear smaller.
5. DON’T say, “No, no, no,” if you don’t like a pose your model takes. Rather, direct the model into a position that works for him or her. Sometimes, exposing a frame or two in a less-than-ideal pose keeps the session flowing and helps protect shy or inexperienced subjects from becoming overly self-conscious. If you’re not getting the pose you want, demonstrate what you want him or her to do. At the very least, you’ll get a good laugh; at best, you’ll get a great shot.


Now for the “Dos”
6. DO take advantage of the knowledge of others. When I photograph a professional model for a fashion shoot, I ask the designer, fashion editor or a stylist what elements of the clothing should be highlighted and how a particular outfit or dress should hang. When taking the photograph, it’s vital to look at the whole ensemble, not just the model’s face or body position. This applies to photographing friends and family, too. Talk to your subject about what she’s wearing, jewelry or other personal effects that you can highlight. It will make the portrait more meaningful for her.
7. DO try shooting headshots from slightly above your subject’s eye level. When the subject looks up at the camera, the eyes are more open and a double chin, if there is one, is reduced. This angle also creates a nice jawline. Focal lengths between 85mm and 105mm (on a full-frame 35mm sensor) work well because of the lens compression. An aperture around ƒ/4.5, because of its shallow depth of field, helps focus the viewer on the eyes—which, as they say, are the windows to the soul.
8. DO try shooting from a slightly lower angle, aiming up, if you want to convey a sense of power. Your subject appears to loom above the viewer in a dominant position.
9. DO make sure to separate the arms from the waist. Arms flat against the side of your subject create the illusion of a very wide waist.
10. DO study classic photographs created by photographers such as Irving Penn and Richard Avedon. There’s a reason why they’re legendary. When you come across portraits that make you stop and look, take note of what’s working for you and try those ideas yourself. Learn from what you like.
 
If I recall correctly, (don't shoot me down if I'm wrong), David Bailey made a set of photographs where he cut a bit of the head at the top and chopped around the knees at the bottom. And again , if I recall correctly, got a lot of critiscism for it but is still used today with some fashion photogs to make their subjects look taller.

I may have dreamt this or got the wrong end of the stick, but Ive just got back to the computer after shutting the pub....been a long day!
 
Just pasted Jason's post in Word to refer to later. Cheers!
 
Back
Top