Amateur Photographer - Neyekon lovefest??

Messages
1,461
Name
The King Of Prestwich
Edit My Images
Yes
Afternoon,

I had never bought a copy of Amateur Photographer up until Monday when I bought a copy because they had a feature on sharpening which I was interested in reading. The article in question was excellent, but the rest of the magazine seemed to revolve around all things Nikon (50mm lens review etc)

Are they tied into Nikon in some way, or are they just a bunch of Nikkoff fan boys who write it?? :shrug: :D
 
You'll find they probably have an advertising deal with Nikon - the way the magazine business runs unfortunately.
 
Afternoon,

I had never bought a copy of Amateur Photographer up until Monday when I bought a copy because they had a feature on sharpening which I was interested in reading. The article in question was excellent, but the rest of the magazine seemed to revolve around all things Nikon (50mm lens review etc)

Are they tied into Nikon in some way, or are they just a bunch of Nikkoff fan boys who write it?? :shrug: :D


Have Canon released any new gear lately for them to review? :shrug:
 
Possibly not, but why have a 'brilliant 50mm lens' review that only includes Nikkor 1.4 v Sigma 1.4 and not the other manufacturers??
 
You'll find they probably have an advertising deal with Nikon - the way the magazine business runs unfortunately.

That's not the way it's done at all! Magazines have to be very even handed with all the major camera brands. It would be commercial suicide if they didn't.
 
Possibly not, but why have a 'brilliant 50mm lens' review that only includes Nikkor 1.4 v Sigma 1.4 and not the other manufacturers??

Maybe they should have substituted the word brilliant for latest? Nikon and Sigma have recently launched their new 50mm lenses to market so it makes sense from that perspective.
 
Afternoon,

I had never bought a copy of Amateur Photographer up until Monday when I bought a copy because they had a feature on sharpening which I was interested in reading. The article in question was excellent, but the rest of the magazine seemed to revolve around all things Nikon (50mm lens review etc)

Are they tied into Nikon in some way, or are they just a bunch of Nikkoff fan boys who write it?? :shrug: :D

Talk about being paranoid! Did you actually read the review? If they were biased don't you think they'd have rated the Nikon over the Sigma?
 
i missed that one can i buy it of you by any chance?

wanna find out about sharpening and the new 50mm


thans john
 
Have to say that as an AP reader for 50 or so years it's the magazine I most rely on for factual reports warts and all. When they test a camera or lens they test it and don't just rewrite the manufacturers press release as some of the monthly seem to do. Also being published weekly it's up to date hence the recent lens test not containing all the similar lenses already tested. The only down with AP might be the severity of their tests if you're a dedicated 'one make' owner whether Nikon, Canon, Leica etc. They have a horrible propensity for reporting actual facts which can be disappointing if you're convinced that your make is the only quality option.
 
It is a well known fact that AP is biased towards Nikon and at the moment very anti Canon in every respect. Even to the point when they list RRP in that they cite 'should be available on the street at x £ for other brands, where as with Canon they use the full RRP.

As Velocette says, Geoffrey Crawley rips lenses to pieces even to the point where he listens the the focus and measures the DB.

But yes, they are certainly not doing Canon any favours at the moment and the 5D Mark II review was about as bad as it gets.
 
I don't see the point in tests where they compare lenses from different systems.

So what if a certain Nikon lens is better than the equivalent Canon one or vice versa? What help is that to anyone (unless they are going to choose to buy into a system based on the results), it's not as if you can go and buy the Nikon one and stick it on a 40D
 
It is a well known fact that AP is biased towards Nikon and at the moment very anti Canon in every respect. Even to the point when they list RRP in that they cite 'should be available on the street at x £ for other brands, where as with Canon they use the full RRP.

As Velocette says, Geoffrey Crawley rips lenses to pieces even to the point where he listens the the focus and measures the DB.

But yes, they are certainly not doing Canon any favours at the moment and the 5D Mark II review was about as bad as it gets.

They praised the 1D Mark III to high heaven.

Then a few weeks later had to apologise for missing the AF problems.
 
It is a well known fact that AP is biased towards Nikon and at the moment very anti Canon in every respect. Even to the point when they list RRP in that they cite 'should be available on the street at x £ for other brands, where as with Canon they use the full RRP.

WTF? Well known fact? On what eveidence? They were decidedly down beat about the D3x, the Sigma 50mm out scored the Nikkor, how can you say that they're biased towards one manufacturer?
There's no bias in AP, in fact, I'd say that out of all the publications, AP is the one which is the least likely to be influenced by manufacturers or advertising revenue (unlike some of the monthlies and their 'advertorials',
but just maybe Canon have been a bit underwhelming in their last few releases i.e. the 50D and 5DII haven't set the world alight, whereas the D300, D3, D700 and then D90 each set the bar higher than it was previously for their particular class.
 
Actually, I was thinking of Photo Plus...

Yes, that is the first ever brand-specific magazine launched for newstand sale. But it's a flawed concept, and is not exactly ripping up trees. (It was supposed to be followed by a Nikon edition, then Oly 4/3rds etc.)

It is flawed in that it forgets that photographic technique articles apply to all, and that almost all Canon owners are as interested in what Nikon/Oly/Sony is doing as everybody else!

All they have done with that magazine is cut their readership potential in half.
 
It couldn't possibly be that Nikon have just made some really good kit lately could it?

No, it must be bias. Even when they test a Nikon against a Sigma and the Sigma comes out on top....

By the way, next week they test the 5D II against the A900. Damn their Canon and Sony bias!
 
By the way, next week they test the 5D II against the A900. Damn their Canon and Sony bias!

That should please the Canon owners for a while, can't see Sony causing any upsets in that one.
 
I won't dispute any of the Nikon users claims with regards to superior kit recently but my observations of the magazine bias I find hard to argue with - even the adverts seemed to be Nikon focused!!??

As there was only 1 non biased article that interested me, I will probably only buy it again if there is something similar - they have lost a potential subscriber based on 1 issue!! :D
 
Well the adverts are probably Nikon biased because Nikon are paying for them. Canon aren't exactly shy of advertising.

This issue has a Canon and a Sony - so what?
 
Excellent, I might buy it if it has an article that interests me, but I won't buy it otherwise! :D
 
That's not the way it's done at all! Magazines have to be very even handed with all the major camera brands. It would be commercial suicide if they didn't.

As a journalist, I've actually worked on magazines and I can assure you that the big ad' spenders DO receive special treatment in the way of editorial coverage - often referred to as 'advertorials'.
 
As a journalist, I've actually worked on magazines and I can assure you that the big ad' spenders DO receive special treatment in the way of editorial coverage - often referred to as 'advertorials'.

Are these different to the ones marked as such in every photography magazine currently on the market?

For example, Nikon in Digital SLR Photography, Ilford in Black & White Photography and Samsung in Amateur Photographer.
 
Correct, they are marked as such. The bias is paid for and obvious. That's very different to the accusations of bias simply because Nikon happened to be making some damn good kit.
 
As a journalist, I've actually worked on magazines and I can assure you that the big ad' spenders DO receive special treatment in the way of editorial coverage - often referred to as 'advertorials'.

That's not special treatment - it's paid for, just like a regular ad. Anybody can have an advertorial. And if the big spenders get special treatment of any kind, then by definition all the big camera brands get equally special treatment.

There is no bias in the mainstream consumer photo mags. No magazine can afford to mess about with their core market clients. If there was even a hint of it, the opposition titles would hammer them for it.
 
We can only assume that Canon don't share the OP's view that AP is Nikon biased, otherwise they (Canon) wouldn't be supplying the prizes for the APotY competition.

I would suggest that the OP airs his concerns with AP - their letters page address is

Letters,
Amateur Photographer,
IPC Media,
Blue Fin Building,
110 Southwark Street,
London,
SE1 0SU

and their e-mail address is

amateurphotographer@ipcmedia.com

or you can fax them on

020 3148 8130

Don't forget to tell them which you'd rather receive should your letter be letter of the week - a 20 roll pack of Fujifilm Superia ISO 200 print film or a 2GB card (CF, SD, xD or Memory Stick). Every letter published gets a roll of the film.
 
Yes, that is the first ever brand-specific magazine launched for newstand sale. But it's a flawed concept, and is not exactly ripping up trees. (It was supposed to be followed by a Nikon edition, then Oly 4/3rds etc.)

It is flawed in that it forgets that photographic technique articles apply to all, and that almost all Canon owners are as interested in what Nikon/Oly/Sony is doing as everybody else!

All they have done with that magazine is cut their readership potential in half.

I thought it was pretty good and while your right i want to keep up with the other brands, i'd rather read about canon equiptment than a nikon lens I will probably never consider buying.
 
Back
Top