Another pet hate as well as blurry water...HDR's

:lol::D:police::yv:
 
pun-wise old chap
go with the flow

you dont have to like it but some do

i dont like the way out blurry water and as for HDR i think i would be jealous not being able to have a go...

chacun a son gout...;)
 
I use to loathe HDR, probably because I generally only saw OTT stuff.Done properly some of it looks ok.Hate it when it is overcooked though.

PS........OP,is there anything you do like?................:naughty:
 
i like anything that looks good and works well as an individual image. It either works or it doesn't and i'ts best not to pidgeon hole a certain processing style of an image. The more you alienate a style of photography, the less creative you become.

All my own opinion of course.

Some HDR's have the wow factor, some are gastly and that goes for any niche.

Al
 
How about blurry water and HDR. :)

z00636.jpg
 
How about blurry water and HDR. :)

z00636.jpg

I actually really like that shot! Although I'd say that it represents a very well done and subtle use of HDR rather than some of the garish images people end up with.

Personally, I see that it's got a place and I've used it recently on holiday when I just couldn't balance the exposure of a bright sky with a shaded temple.
 
Im no expert at HDR, only just actually tried some HDR but in my opinion this is my best yet will see if this can convince you.

Probably wont because as i say im just starting at HDR and compared to some my attempts suck.

2j14ll4.jpg
 
I hate HDR too, very few images actually do justice to the effect.

Some I like:

hdr-10.jpg


PERFECTION...
4920356-md.jpg
 
It definitely can work, but if you end up with something that looks like a 1980's Dr Who "dalek blaster effect", please, please, please just click "revert" in Photoshop and try something else.
 
well if those 2 shots don't help win you over i guess nothing will :)

liking & not liking something is just like having an opinion on something
there is no right or wrong, you either do or you don't :)

life would be pretty dull if everybody liked the same things :D
 
Im no expert at HDR, only just actually tried some HDR but in my opinion this is my best yet will see if this can convince you.

Probably wont because as i say im just starting at HDR and compared to some my attempts suck.
Sorry, but this does not work for me with such high saturation....
 
I actually really like that shot! Although I'd say that it represents a very well done and subtle use of HDR rather than some of the garish images people end up with.

Personally, I see that it's got a place and I've used it recently on holiday when I just couldn't balance the exposure of a bright sky with a shaded temple.

Cheers. :thumbs:
 
I'm not a fan, though I have dabbled. To me it seems like a "get out of jail free" card if you struggle a bit with composition.
 
I'm not a fan, though I have dabbled. To me it seems like a "get out of jail free" card if you struggle a bit with composition.

Some people treat it like that and they end up in the poor HDR category, HDR is no escape for poor composition.
 
How about blurry water and HDR. :)

z00636.jpg

:thumbs: but thaaaaaat waaaaaaaater :thumbsdown:

Just messin about.

Nice shot, I quite like it but, be honest now don't you think it would have looked better still (water), well, frozen in time I mean. :shrug:
 
what a strange concept.

I don't like something, try and convince me otherwise.

I don't like ritual scarification but I'm unlikely to ask someone to convince me otherwise
 
I hate most hdrs, most long exposure water and most monos :)

With all 3 so many people do them 'just because i can' and not because it adds to the picture. HDR improves a scene with extremes of bright and dark not every scene. Long exposure water can look good but mostly it can look very 'samey'. Mono works with good contrasts and strong textures and again most conversions don't have those.

As to Chilliz image above - it looks fine to me and apparently has all 3 of my dislikes :) I might prefer a vanilla colour version but the processing looks like it was done for a reason and not because someone found a mono button.
 
let's face it... blurred water and hdr is only old hat and cliche because we've seen sooo many good and bad examples and we want something fresh. But you could put this scenario into virtually every hobby / pastime / business where fads come and go and it's the people who are the 'experts' in their field that dictate that - doesn't mean that they should be frowned upon for other people to appreciate.
in my eyes... if i like an image, then i like an image - doesn't matter what genre it comes under - even selective colouring :$
 
I hate OTT hdr but I also love subtle efforts like shown on post #16.

Here is one i did using 5 exposures handheld last year which i actual find myself arguing the fact that yes it is HDR!

3704828388_1a03832809.jpg



Click link below for some work from Steve Carter who has plenty subtle hdr efforts...

http://www.stevecarter.com/hdr/hdr.htm

That's a good link, shows how HDR doesn't have look like something from Harry Potter
 
No, I don't like most HDR's for the simple reason that, for me, it ceases to become a photograph and becomes something else, missing the point entirely.
 
No, I don't like most HDR's for the simple reason that, for me, it ceases to become a photograph and becomes something else, missing the point entirely.

I disagree, it`s just another processing technique, the same as using levels in photoshop or burning and dodging with traditional printing. :)
 
OK, it's time for one of these... :dummy: ;)

I get quite frustrated by this sort of thread (and yeah, I know the answer is to not bother reading it) but can anyone here define EXACTLY what photography is supposed to be if not creative?

What's being done on computers now is simply a modern version of what's been done for donkey's years elsewhere. Just because you may not like HDR, mono (posh term for black & white), flowing water, selective colouring etc. doesn't mean that others don't enjoy it. Whilst I will concede that there are too many 'photographers' out there who try far too often to turn a sow's ear into a silk purse, there are also plenty who see these techniques as a means to an end as well as an end in their own right.

There are times when I wonder if these 'I-dislike-it' threads are due to a lack of technical competence on the part of the complainers and are therefore simply a retelling of the old Aesop's Fable about the fox and the grapes!

If people didn't innovate and experiment, we'd all still be shooting on glass plates or worse still, there'd be no photography at all! :bang:

Cheers,
Si
 
Don't see a problem saying what you do or don't like. Only becomes a problem if you start saying one is right and the other is wrong. Just a question of taste.
 
Don't see a problem saying what you do or don't like. Only becomes a problem if you start saying one is right and the other is wrong. Just a question of taste.

Fair enough Robert but define 'taste'? Everyone's different! ;)

I acknowledge that nobody's said any style is right or wrong but even to sit here and dismiss different techniques or styles isn't beneficial either. We've all got our likes and dislikes but since photography's supposed to be the result of us finding our own creative sides, surely anything that makes the creator happy should be reason enough for doing it?

Cheers,
Si
 
Back
Top