Another pet hate as well as blurry water...HDR's

what a strange concept.

I don't like something, try and convince me otherwise.

I don't like ritual scarification but I'm unlikely to ask someone to convince me otherwise

I don't usually agree with you but this time I do - this 'I don't like it, convince me otherwise' is gettin' on my nerves a bit.
 
All I will say is that the world would be a very boring place if we all liked the same things.
 
The only problem with HDR is Photomatix imo! If it was a little more difficult, and you had to think a bit more about what tone-mapping actually does and how it works, people would use HDR as a means to an end rather than an end in itself.
 
The only problem with HDR is Photomatix imo! If it was a little more difficult, and you had to think a bit more about what tone-mapping actually does and how it works, people would use HDR as a means to an end rather than an end in itself.

Sounds like you are tarring everybody with the same brush, there is a learning curve with HDR... eventually you don't go mad with the leavers, but it takes CC from forums like this to convince you, or you give up.
 
Yay! An HDR is this or that thread! Woo hoo!

Seriously though, it's mostly already been said. When people say they dislike HDR what they usually mean is they dislike cartoons. HDR is a process designed to enhance a picture where there is too much contrast range to produce a workable shot from one image. This can obviously be done with layer masks, buy HDR works too.

I've posted a couple of these shots before as examples of work you'd be hard pressed to tell was HDR, and another that I chose an HDR (and mono, Robert) because the sky was dead as a dodo and it was the only way to save it.

All clickable.





 
Nothing wrong with those images but the first one shouts hdr at me (the other two don't). Apart from overdone cartoon versions you refer to hdr also removes a lot of natural shadows leaving a scene with impossible lighting. Your first picture has a bright sky in the background but instead of a silhouetted statue the near face is lit and so is the ground all around. To me it just looks wrong. It is 'to me' though not you or anyone else so please do carry on regardless :)
 
The first one is an example of trying to make something out of nothing. However 'wrong' it looks it's still a more interesting picture than if I'd left the sky a bland and dull grey.:)
 
Like I said not wrong just a different approach. I don't like editing so I'd rather take a shot that was a keeper to start with rather than try to 'make something out of nothing'. hmm that sounds like a dig but wasn't meant to be. hopefully you know what I mean :)
 
Like I said not wrong just a different approach. I don't like editing so I'd rather take a shot that was a keeper to start with rather than try to 'make something out of nothing'. hmm that sounds like a dig but wasn't meant to be. hopefully you know what I mean :)

Robert, I do know what you mean and didn't take it as a dig. As I get better I did I'm having to edit less and less, but sometimes it takes a bit of imagination to see a keeper in something you might have binned. We have the technology so I say use it.
 
HDR is great if you cannot immediately tell it's been used.
Unrefined use of the effect should be kept for playgrounds and skateboard parks, until it matures. This way it will be able to compliment, rather than lead an image.
 
i'm a beginner i know nothing of HDR?, i know nothing of tonemapping?, my own interpretation of a photograph = "a moment frozen in time, to evoke a feeling or emotion which in turn awakens the memory, or is embedded in the memory to last forever, and to make that particular moment last forever".

thats my own feeling anyway. :thumbs:
 
Try and convince me otherwise.

Why bother convincing you at all, if you want to be silly and say 'I hate HDR's' with little or no logic behind your statement then who really cares either what you dont or do like.

Some HDR's are poor, some are average and some are absolutely fantastic - fact.

Even out of focus shots can be amazing if that was the intention (or maybe not) and the result looks good.
 
Back
Top