Another Police v Photographer incident....

Status
Not open for further replies.
The fact that he's been (allegedly) assaulted before might suggest that he has a provocative manner...
 
I must have a different type of face.. I have been sent to cover road accidents (night and day) fires, bank robberies and the police in Accrington and east lancs have been nothing but helpful.. these stories always amaze me when i get the opposite reaction..
 
To be fair there's a lot of police out there that are great but there are also a lot that are frankly, idiots.

The only thing that does surprise me about the article is the alleged intensity of the assault ie the smashing of his hand in an attempt to get at the phone, but then I've met my fair share of ignorant (in all senses of the word) police.

It does tend to be the panda car police officers that have a crappy attitude, sometimes the traffic lot too, but I know several that are in serious crimes and robbery and they're top blokes.
 
I quote "Littleford said he may sue for damages over injuries to his hands and legs and has the backing of the Chartered Institute of Journalists." So he's not to interested in the alleged assault, he's playing the compensation card.
 
another thread on this, same old arguements from both sides
 
how do you make that judgement?

If the assault happened as alleged is he not entitled to take action?

not if the officer used, and can justify, reasonable force.

if the officer was concerned for his own safety then anything up to and including death can be justified.
 
Oh why, oh why is society so aggressive today?
Why can't we all adopt polite mannerisms, we would all achieve such a lot and indeed be far more productive.

Lets face it, we all have a job to do, lets all get on and do it with as little fuss as possible.

That’s the end of my rant!
 
not if the officer used, and can justify, reasonable force.

if the officer was concerned for his own safety then anything up to and including death can be justified.

I did put "as alleged"? :thinking:
 
another thread on this, same old arguements from both sides

Yup. Some well-entrenched prejudices in this thread. :bonk:

But I can only add that old insurance claim "I ran over a man. He admitted it was his fault, as he'd been run over before!"
 
Wouldn't it be better to wait for it to be investigated before jumping tot he conclusion that someone publicising the incident was telling the truth. I seem to recall a recent illustration of where so many leap on the outrage bus, only to find it terminated very early.
 
Let see what happen,if he is telling the truth then officers,should face a discipline board,as I have said before, even an police officer on duty is not above the law :)
 
Wouldn't it be better to wait for it to be investigated before jumping tot he conclusion that someone publicising the incident was telling the truth. I seem to recall a recent illustration of where so many leap on the outrage bus, only to find it terminated very early.

I'm not sure what point your actually trying to make here to be honest, ie which side of the debate you're siding with?
 
I'm not siding with either.
What I am doing is pointing out the obvious, which is being ignored. There are 2 sides to every story. At the moment, as with all of these Police V others, you have the other's side, and not the Police's.
Given that the Glasgow incident started as a howl of outrage, but the story turned out to be a contender for Jackanory I would have thought that the usual suspects who can't contain thier rush to attack the old bill might have restrained themselves to save showing themselves out to be numpties again.
 
I'm not siding with either.
What I am doing is pointing out the obvious, which is being ignored. There are 2 sides to every story. At the moment, as with all of these Police V others, you have the other's side, and not the Police's.
Given that the Glasgow incident started as a howl of outrage, but the story turned out to be a contender for Jackanory I would have thought that the usual suspects who can't contain thier rush to attack the old bill might have restrained themselves to save showing themselves out to be numpties again.

But its ok if you rush in,the case in Glasgow is still not resolved yet :D
 
I'm not siding with either.
What I am doing is pointing out the obvious, which is being ignored. There are 2 sides to every story. At the moment, as with all of these Police V others, you have the other's side, and not the Police's.

I wasn't ignoring anything as I don't think you pointed it out very clearly, at least it didn't read like that to me. :thinking:

Given that the Glasgow incident started as a howl of outrage, but the story turned out to be a contender for Jackanory I would have thought that the usual suspects who can't contain thier rush to attack the old bill might have restrained themselves to save showing themselves out to be numpties again.

OK, ummmmmmmmmmm now you're losing me again as I find no mention of a Glasgow incident anywhere, unless you are assuming that everyone reading the thread knows some sort of history about his guy:shrug:

I don't which may explain my confusion?:bonk:
 
(OK, ummmmmmmmmmm now you're losing me again as I find no mention of a Glasgow incident anywhere, unless you are assuming that everyone reading the thread knows some sort of history about his guy) It was an another thread

The case is still outstanding,but as Bernie174 seem to think its all
Jackanory,hopfully if it go to court,we will hopfully find out the full story :)
 
Last edited:
Perhaps I could suggest that only those who were present at the incident and are in a position to shed light on what happened should be allowed to comment. Anything else is speculation at this stage.
 
I think that if you applied your suggestion throughout the forum there'd be a heck of a lot less threads on here Ken.

Nothing wrong with a little speculation / discussion / debate

Exactly right :thumbs:
 
I have been sent to cover road accidents (night and day) fires, bank robberies.

Why does all this ***** happen when you're around Tony?
 
If the police officer did lose it and behave like that. I also hold all other officers that know and work with this officer as accountable as well.

Why because if true (which unfortunately is very possible) Then all the other officers are also aware of this chaps manner and possible bad behaviour, should have administered their own disciplinary methods to correct him, or have him removed from the force.

This is what the army would do, one bad seed and poor member of the team...out they go, by hook or crook and I'm pretty sure the population we might have fought for couldn't give a damn.
 
Simon
Whats outstanding about the shopping centre incident? Nothing so far as I can see. Most of the fact, or rathr all those that can be released by the Police have been, they are under an obligation to tell the facts, unlike the person concerned, who can say whatever he likes, and seems to have done that, without reference to the truth.

Forbiddenbiker. If this incident happened as described, then give the Police a chance! They are investigating the photographers complaints. If he is telling the truth, and theres a 50/50 chance hes not, then the Police Officer will hang. If he's not of course then he goes off scot free. Equitable system isn't it!
 
I have told journalists a million times to stop exaggerating
 
Hmm that's so true.

Forbiddenbiker. If this incident happened as described, then give the Police a chance! They are investigating the photographers complaints. If he is telling the truth, and theres a 50/50 chance hes not, then the Police Officer will hang. If he's not of course then he goes off scot free. Equitable system isn't it!

Sure I know.:) ... after the act rather than before isn't helping our excellent police force with its due/or not due, respect though.
 
Forbiddenbiker

Which was my original point, let an investigation reveal who was right and who was wrong. Until thats done, what the photographer says isn't the entire story, so leaping to his defence is not yet, and may never be right or appropriate.
Again, you can't predict crime, nor disciplinary acts.You have to have a proper investigation after such an incident, and then a proper and fair system of dealing with wrong doing if its proven. The Army, to use your example do exactly that, as do the Police (although most Police officers will tell you the Police system is very heavily biased against Police Officers). So the before the event is in reality impossible to achieve. As with disciplining anyone who has ever worked with the Police officer...I mean, how on earth can someone who worked with him 15 years ago be guilty of anything????

But its also important to remember that whatever the outcome, any wrong doing by the photographer in relation to his complaint will be ignored. So he could lie with complete immunity, no matter what harm that does to respect for Police.
 
Last edited:
Your misunderstanding my point Bernie. I was referring to my first post in my answer. Not directly on the outcome of this incident.

So I'm not saying one has to predict anything.

I'm saying their are absolutely definitely bad police officers amongst the majority of good.

I know this from several personal experiences of bulling, aggression and threat...none of which where called for I assure you

The good officers know who the bad officers are and their behaviour is accepted or deemed acceptable...hush hush say no more. Unfortunately this is a desperate answer to the problems of good policing, aggression and violence will never set any examples other than more aggression and violence.

Convicting after the offence in some sort of public display doesn't help the public's opinions if the occurrences continue to show up... whether this threads subject is one or not, the problem is still their.
 
Just had an interesting little episode very close to my house.
A production company is filming a TV advertisement for an insurance company just across the road and using a neighbours front garden.
I popped over with camera and 70-200 to get a few shots, the security guard came over to me and simply asked whether my shots were for commercial purposes.
After he was reassured we had a friendly chat about a variety of topics and he left me to get on with it.
Shortly after a quite irate woman from the production team came over requested that I "stop taking pictures now".
Of course I stayed pleasant and smiled and told her I could take photos in my street if I wished.
She became very upset, almost tearful, so I promised that any shots would not be put on the web just to pacify her.

I've just heard her bellowing in the street so I think I'll go outside and take a few more shots:D
 
^ I would def go and do that.

It's your bloody street! As for saying they won't go on the web, you should be ashamed of yourself.
 
^ I would def go and do that.

Yet people on here complain when they are an official photographer at a wedding, they have setup a photo and others are taking the photo they setup???

If they are a production company and are setting up the house for the shoot and you start taking photos, are you not doing the same?
 
Just had an interesting little episode very close to my house ...... I promised that any shots would not be put on the web just to pacify her.

What a shame. I'd have liked you to put up a few for critique so people could see how your technique is affected by a security guard being nice and by a harridan screeching at you! :)
 
Yet people on here complain when they are an official photographer at a wedding, they have setup a photo and others are taking the photo they setup???

If they are a production company and are setting up the house for the shoot and you start taking photos, are you not doing the same?



Not at all. First will normally be on private property. Second was stated to be taken from a public road.
 
Yet people on here complain when they are an official photographer at a wedding, they have setup a photo and others are taking the photo they setup???

If they are a production company and are setting up the house for the shoot and you start taking photos, are you not doing the same?

It's fairly rare for a wedding photographer to complain that someone else is shooting at a wedding:cuckoo:

However, you'll find legitimate complaints where people have then presented those photographs as their own work, or distracted the B&G, or got in the way of the official tog. All of which are unreasonable behaviours that a wedding photographer could rightly complain about.

There are rare (:cuckoo:) exceptions but wedding photographers understand that other people like to take pictures too.

And back to the OP, he's free to shoot these pictures in public, and it's up to him how he reacts to this unreasonable behaviour.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top