Another Police v Photographer incident....

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just had an interesting little episode very close to my house.
A production company is filming a TV advertisement for an insurance company just across the road and using a neighbours front garden.
I popped over with camera and 70-200 to get a few shots, the security guard came over to me and simply asked whether my shots were for commercial purposes.
After he was reassured we had a friendly chat about a variety of topics and he left me to get on with it.
Shortly after a quite irate woman from the production team came over requested that I "stop taking pictures now".
Of course I stayed pleasant and smiled and told her I could take photos in my street if I wished.
She became very upset, almost tearful, so I promised that any shots would not be put on the web just to pacify her.

I've just heard her bellowing in the street so I think I'll go outside and take a few more shots:D

Reminds me of when I was involved with an episode of `Casualty`. We were doing a street shoot and some bloke was playing music that was interfering with the sound. It wasn't that loud, but the effects mike was getting it. He, quite rightly, said he had every right to play music in his lounge and have his windows open. They had to bung him some licence-fee-payers' money to shut up.
 
Last edited:
It's fairly rare for a wedding photographer to complain that someone else is shooting at a wedding:cuckoo:

I've read a number of threads on here about it and I personally thought they were nuts complaining about it.

I'm talking about someone standing next to them taking a photo etc. not the saying 'I was the wedding photographer'
 
well the police officer is innocent until proven guilty of assualt..

getting back on topic ;)

You're absolutely right of course but i can't see why the photographer would make it up, ok, being a devils advocate I'll accept the fact that someone may be tempted to embellish the truth, but if there were as many witnesses as there seem to have been, and if he sustained injuries consistant with his account then there'd be no point in lying?

I would be interested to hear the final outcome, but personally, I think that the discussion has evolved to a point were we are discussing the general lack of knowledge by a large section of the police force.

other than all that in between about wedding photography of course :bonk:
 
Forbiddenbiker

Convicting after the offence in some sort of public display doesn't help the public's opinions if the occurrences continue to show up

I'm not sure when you expect a conviction to take place?

By definition, there cannot be a conviction in anticipation, something has to occurred first.

Of course there are bad Policemen, like there are bad Doctors, bad Solicitors bad Soldiers and bad photographers. If for no other reason than they all come from one source, human beings.

The problem in all accusation is though, that Bad can mean a lot of things, because a Policeman sticks you in the book for speeding makes them bad in some peoples eyes. Asking questions makes other Policemen bad in others, but these are parts of their job. .

You were I am guessing ex army from what you originally said. I'd suggest you read the Articles of War, the part about the Provost (the Source of Military Police Authority), after the bit about having a horse allowed to him, and some men to attend him, him riding between garrisons making sure the squaddies behaved, it says that he would not be loved by all. I'm afraid that was a very early assessment of how Police were always going to be seen. What a Policeman prevents you doing, makes someone else happy, but when that person is stopped from breaking the law, or prosecuted for doing so, he in turn thinks Police are bad, they are never going to win! You think Tommy Atkins had it bad!

Donnie

You are talking utter rubbish. Firstly wait for the investigation, means just that. However, just because a photographer says it happened does not mean it did. People lie, and all thats happened is a suggestion of balance and caution, nothing more.
 
Well done Ding, which is why I made my original point, wait until its investigated, instead of assuming its the Police at fault.
I've not expressed an opinion either way, but as its dragged on, I will give it now, I doubt whats been reported is what happened. It may well have been a much milder version, or be invention, but I'd prefer to wait until either the Police Officer is prosecuted, or nothing happens, meaning he is innocent.
 
Donnie

You are talking utter rubbish. Firstly wait for the investigation, means just that. However, just because a photographer says it happened does not mean it did. People lie, and all thats happened is a suggestion of balance and caution, nothing more.

You don't have to get personal Bernie :shrug:

I've not said that people don't lie, but they also tell the truth too? I think from your balanced cautious replies you certainly seem to be overly sceptical of the persons accusations and by default don't believe them.

Seems contradictory to me.:|
 
Well done Ding, which is why I made my original point, wait until its investigated, instead of assuming its the Police at fault.
I've not expressed an opinion either way, but as its dragged on, I will give it now, I doubt whats been reported is what happened. It may well have been a much milder version, or be invention, but I'd prefer to wait until either the Police Officer is prosecuted, or nothing happens, meaning he is innocent.

Ah, read this after I posted the reply to your other post rubbishing my opinions.

Nice to see that your siding with the police then and have effectively decided the guys a liar and the police are vindicated....

By the way, do you work for the police or have someone in the family in the force?
 
I'd prefer to wait until either the Police Officer is prosecuted, or nothing happens, meaning he is innocent.

That's not what happened the last time though.....

Stuart Littleford:

"I have decided to have the matter resolved locally which means instead of it going through the process, courts etc, the copper will get a talking to and whatever action the inspector thinks fit. I have done this after taking advice from the Chartered Institute of Journalists (CIOJ) and to maintain relationships with the police in my area, not because I think I was not assaulted,"
 
Often you will never hear the end result. If the policeman in this case is NOT prosecuted do you think you will get to read about it anywhere? Unlikely. Similar to terror suspects getting picked up. They always report the arrests. They rarely report the fact when they get released without charge.
 
Flash
You are mistaking two things.
Local resolution means that the matter isn't investigated, a Senior Police Officer makes apologetic noises irrespective of what really happened, and thats that.
Which is whats happened in the case you quoted, it isn't an indication of guilt or otherwise. The officer concerned gets no say in the matter, and on the 3 occasions when complaints against me were resolved this way, I made it clear i objected and wanted it investigated, as I had no doubts my actions were completely correct. It's a good way out for some complainants who really have not got a substantive complaint.

Donnie
I mentioned you are talking rubbish, because you are. No one has decided that either side is right or wrong, and your replies to other accusing them of that, are not based on what has been said.

Nice to see that your siding with the police then and have effectively decided the guys a liar and the police are vindicated....

No, I've said that I doubt what was reported was what happened, It MAY WELL have been a much milder version, or be invention. The words may well, and the sentence containing 2 alternatives opinions quite clearly display no fixed support for either side of the argument.
I can't spell, and would never castigate people for that, but to be honest your lack of ability to comprehend whats written is astounding. Have you considered seeing if your local Adult Education Center can help you?
Moving on to the substance of your comments, I doubt it's as reported for very simple reasons. The days of Police being able to cover things up are long gone. CCTV, and the prospect of being prosecuted with the catch all offence of Malfeasance means that the likelihood is any other Police Officers present, and from the description there were, would have gone straight to the local management or PSD.
Yes, in answer to your question I was a Police Officer, which means as I keep saying, I've seen things from both sides. Unlike you. I have also seen Photographers stopped and asked what they are doing, to hear them a week give a totally different and fabricated version of it. What reason they have for that, I've no idea. I also don't doubt that there the odd bent or dishonest Police Officer about. It happens, as it does in all walks of life.
 
Last edited:
Forbiddenbiker



I'm not sure when you expect a conviction to take place?

My first post on the original subject.
....

...Then all the other officers are also aware of this chaps manner and possible bad behaviour, should have administered their own disciplinary methods to correct him, or have him removed from the force.

I suggest its you who isn't comprehending others overall opinions Bernie. ;)


I was hoping you'd accept my word and assurances, If I get a speeding ticket it will be because I was driving like a ****. ...but like I said, my three main experiences with police officers over the last two years have been little if nothing do do with my actions or attitude. Simpy school yard bulling tactics., totally discussing behaviours for anyone let alone an officer... nothing more nor less.
 
Last edited:
You were I am guessing ex army from what you originally said. I'd suggest you read the Articles of War, the part about the Provost (the Source of Military Police Authority), after the bit about having a horse allowed to him, and some men to attend him, him riding between garrisons making sure the squaddies behaved, it says that he would not be loved by all. I'm afraid that was a very early assessment of how Police were always going to be seen. What a Policeman prevents you doing, makes someone else happy, but when that person is stopped from breaking the law, or prosecuted for doing so, he in turn thinks Police are bad, they are never going to win! You think Tommy Atkins had it bad!

Yes I was once. Army officers can't deal on the same team level as a soldier, the soldiers would eat most alive in a second, not the greats though. No an officers job is to command the soldiers and to me the police on the streets are the soldiers but some are under the illusion that they can act like army officers.

can I suggest you read up on Neuro-linguistic programming. :D
 
Donnie
I mentioned you are talking rubbish, because you are. No one has decided that either side is right or wrong, and your replies to other accusing them of that, are not based on what has been said.

Now now Bernie, don't get frustrated, calm down.

I'd like to see where you think I was specifically talking "rubbish". What I said was that there seem to be replies on here leaping to the police's defence based on the article and by default accusing the reporter of lying, let's see if I can find some examples from your own replies.........

"At the moment, as with all of these Police V others, you have the other's side, and not the Police's. " - obvious pro police stance

"If he is telling the truth, and theres a 50/50 chance hes not, then the Police Officer will hang. If he's not of course then he goes off scot free." - obvious pro police stance again.

" although most Police officers will tell you the Police system is very heavily biased against Police Officers..............any wrong doing by the photographer in relation to his complaint will be ignored. So he could lie with complete immunity, no matter what harm that does to respect for Police." - and again.

"However, just because a photographer says it happened does not mean it did. People lie, and all thats happened is a suggestion of balance and caution, nothing more." - and again.

"I doubt whats been reported is what happened................wait until either the Police Officer is prosecuted, or nothing happens, meaning he is innocent." - and again (as well as incorrect as if nothing happens it doesn't mean he's innocent, just that he's not been found guilty)

Now before you try to come accross all wounded about the quotes above and try pointing out they are out of context or some other issue here's the link to the beginning of the thread for all to ensure they can have a good read through and agree or disagree with me.

http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?t=368182
 
No, I've said that I doubt what was reported was what happened, It MAY WELL have been a much milder version, or be invention. The words may well, and the sentence containing 2 alternatives opinions quite clearly display no fixed support for either side of the argument.

No they don't, it quite clearly shows your bias to be pro police.

I can't spell, and would never castigate people for that, but to be honest your lack of ability to comprehend whats written is astounding.

who mentioned your spelling?

Have you considered seeing if your local Adult Education Center can help you?

Oh dear. I can hardly see you down there now Bernie sorry....:shrug: I'm afraid though I can't stoop to that level but hope you're comfortable down there.

Moving on to the substance of your comments, I doubt it's as reported for very simple reasons. The days of Police being able to cover things up are long gone. CCTV, and the prospect of being prosecuted with the catch all offence of Malfeasance means that the likelihood is any other Police Officers present, and from the description there were, would have gone straight to the local management or PSD.

I see. So, you are basing your bias against the photographer on the fact that the police could get caught on cctv, not on the fact that they are professionals? That's a bit of a worry, good tip though, Ill make sure any dealings with the police are near cctv for my own safety.

Yes, in answer to your question I was a Police Officer,

Thought you might have been.

which means as I keep saying, I've seen things from both sides. Unlike you.

And a mind reader to boot, how do you know anything about me? For all you know I'm a Special or have just passed the OSPRE Part 2 exams?

I have also seen Photographers stopped and asked what they are doing, to hear them a week give a totally different and fabricated version of it. What reason they have for that, I've no idea. I also don't doubt that there the odd bent or dishonest Police Officer about. It happens, as it does in all walks of life.

Indeed!
 
Dale_d3100 said:
I've read a number of threads on here about it and I personally thought they were nuts complaining about it.

I'm talking about someone standing next to them taking a photo etc. not the saying 'I was the wedding photographer'

In my experience the complaints are based on more than just shooting, but the trolls tend to argue simply that there's nothing we can do to stop someone shooting. Usually only inexperienced wedding photographers will get narked about other people shooting alongside, or real old timers (rare nowadays) who see it as damaging print sales.

But like I said before, we are used to the fact that people take cameras to weddings and it causes no problems at all.
 
Donnie

You feel free to put your skewed understanding to what I have said, but whether you like it or not, its reasonably balanced. I'm not wounded by your comments, if you are a special, or worse passed Osprey part 2 then that explains a great deal.


Forbiddenbiker

The Police isn't the Army.
What you said, and its in post 30 is this
Sure I know. ... after the act rather than before isn't helping our excellent police force with its due/or not due, respect though.

Which is where what you have said doesn't make sense. Firstly, you have assumed it happened. And secondly if it did, you have assumed its a regular thing. Neither is a given. You can't discipline, or take action against someone before they have done wrong. There's no misunderstanding on my part, its your words. People sometimes act out of character, you can't anticipate that.
If whats alleged happened, how do you know that the others there have not done something about it? You don't.

You also said in post 27, you said

I also hold all other officers that know and work with this officer as accountable as well.

Why? I know a PC that was convicted of theft. Just because I knew him and worked with him, it does not mean I have to be guilty by association. Nor should I have done something about him before he was caught, simply because I couldn't have known.
 
Oh poo Bernie. It was you who started the military bit by patronisingly suggesting I read Articles of War, remember? I originally simply mentioned a technique soldiers might use to ensure their team could do their job properly as part of my first post adding some context for my opinion.

My post 30 was still in reference to my post 27. Post 27 clearly states words like IF and IF TRUE. So no, its you who have mistakenly decided to link my answer to your question with making assumptions like those you've listed.

I'm simply pointing out a fact within all teams, (and from experiences myself I've seen it in the police many times, as i've referred to and many others) ...there are bad player and the rest of the team know who they are.

I don;t want to get into some daft play on thieves or some such Bernie. If you can't see I'm making a reasonable judgement on the idea above, then your not trying at all, and are in may ways treading on the grounds of irresponsibility within the officers that we are complaining about.

---
To castigate a member of a team to either fit within the team or leave, you must castigate the whole team and point at the troublemaker.
The team will retaliate their punishment onto the trouble maker, abandonment, denial of social, etc.etc.
Eventually the troublemaker will concede defeat and work with the team or leave.

From football teams to army regiments onto the police its all the same and no ones teams true purpose can work effectively if the peers of the troublemakers don't take their responsibilities to the team seriously, and are, in effect, just as guilty of failing us as the troublemakers themselves.

You don't need the system to fix it afterwards, you need the team to fix it before hand.
 
Donnie

You feel free to put your skewed understanding to what I have said,

I'm failing to see how it's skewed to be honest. I think it's fairly obvious to anyone that reads the thread, with an open mind, that my point, about you being pro police, is a valid reflection of opinion.

but whether you like it or not, its reasonably balanced.

see previous reply?

I'm not wounded by your comments,

Good, I wasn't looking to wound you or try and belittle you

if you are a special, or worse passed Osprey part 2 then that explains a great deal.

Nice :D

Love how you "respect" the specials and sergeants of the police force of this great country while also peeing on their status from a great height.

(that's irony by the way, in case that wasn't in your customer services course in your basic training).
 
Forbiddenbiker

Firstly, you have assumed it happened.

Does the guy that reported the alleged assault do so on a regular basis for fun then? What I mean is, you are basically saying that the guy actually sat down one day and decided to make up a story completely from imagination?

[/quote]

And secondly if it did, you have assumed its a regular thing.

eh? where did he say that then?

Neither is a given. You can't discipline, or take action against someone before they have done wrong.

Ummmmmmmmm beg to differ, in fact, and you really should know this if you really were a police officer, that anyone can accuse anyone of pretty much anything, and if that involves an arrest of the accused then they can have their dna and prints taken, forcibly if need be, and kept on file for up to 6 years currently.


If whats alleged happened, how do you know that the others there have not done something about it? You don't.

But you don't know they have, hence the discussion on this thread is based about what we know to be in the public domain, i.e. the story originally linked to back in post 1. If, of course, you have further pertinent information to add, please feel free to add it.

I know a PC that was convicted of theft. Just because I knew him and worked with him, it does not mean I have to be guilty by association.

Pretty sure that's not the point that was being made, it was in fact (at least this is how I read it) referring to those colleagues that had knowledge about the behaviour, i.e. ongoing knowledge.

Using your volunteered information about a colleague of yours convicted of theft you are quite correct, you should not be guilty by association.

However, Forbiddenbikers point, as I see it, was if you were aware of this colleagues behaviour / thefts and did not report it or take meaningful action, you would indeed be; in your own words be, guilty by association.

that Nor should I have done something about him before he was caught, simply because I couldn't have known.

See previous point.
 
For goodness sake. Have you nothing better to do?

I haven't read all of the posts because it became apparent halfway through that it was descending into futile points scoring.

You both have differing opinions. Deal with it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top