Another story of a truly terrible 'pro' tog

Messages
1,310
Name
Amir
Edit My Images
Yes
Visited some friends yesterday who showed me the school group photos of their 5 year old. Wow was I shocked! The group was only about 7 kids wide and 2 rows deep yet the photo was suffering from terrible wide angle distortion so the people on the ends looked flat. The shots of the girl and her mum were posed really nicely but the colours were terrible and it was obvious someone had gone to town with the post processing and made things worse. Apparently not many parents bought the pics and the ones that were sold were only sold because that was the only group photo of the class.

I know people don't have to buy the pics. I know the school should have done their homework better. Seriously though, how does this togger sleep at night having done such a horrendous job. :shrug:

My friend asked me to do next years photos. Of course I refused but I did offer to help them find a genuine pro by vetting his/her previous work.

Dub
 
the starting point for companies offering this sort of work is low...

"no experience needed, full training given"
Salary - low as it goes
Car - you provide the car
 
Why did you refuse, if you could do better?

To be honest, it doesn't take a 'pro' tog (as if that's some mystical spell that gets cast on people) to shoot a couple of rows of kids and some posed family shots nicely.
 
Was the wide angle down to space constraints?

I don't know, i did think about that myself - but no pro would have put out shots like that mate. At the very least he should have shot wider and corrected in photoshop or insisted that another classroom be used...
 
Why did you refuse, if you could do better?

To be honest, it doesn't take a 'pro' tog (as if that's some mystical spell that gets cast on people) to shoot a couple of rows of kids and some posed family shots nicely.

I refused because I know there are people offering these services who can provide stunning results every time. I could probably get some good shots.. but there would be a fair few misses in there too i'm sure :)
 
Just remember... you didn't see the pro's misses either :D

True I guess :) Their next shoot is not for several months. If I can raise my game in that time I will throw my hat in the ring. It's not mega money I don't think - but it would be a fantastic experience :)

Dub
 
I think you should do it.
Pushing yourself out of your comfort zone is the best way to learn. You could always take someone else along as a second shooter/helper/moral support etc.
 
Perfect timing there. Looks like Daryl & I cross posted.
 
the starting point for companies offering this sort of work is low...

"no experience needed, full training given"
Salary - low as it goes
Car - you provide the car

That's true, an acquaintance of mine was a school tog' and the camera was tapped up to prevent changes in settings. I inquired as to why this was and to cut a long story short it boiled down to no understanding of photography. It was a matter of turn up, setup, point and shoot. Quite sad really.
 
That's true, an acquaintance of mine was a school tog' and the camera was tapped up to prevent changes in settings. I inquired as to why this was and to cut a long story short it boiled down to no understanding of photography. It was a matter of turn up, setup, point and shoot. Quite sad really.


EEk!!
TBH that's what steriotype that I have of those certain companies that state "no photography experience needed"
 
You say that Boru, but why does it need to be any more or less than that?

How much do you think the guy who fixes your washing machine knows about engineering or the exhaust fitter at Halfords about cars? How about the Chinese worker who builds your I-Phone - an electronics and computer whizz? I think not.

Why pay an expert to shoot non-creative shots when you can document the simple process and give it to cheap labour?

This is about making money, not making creative work.
 
You say that Boru, but why does it need to be any more or less than that?

How much do you think the guy who fixes your washing machine knows about engineering or the exhaust fitter at Halfords about cars? How about the Chinese worker who builds your I-Phone - an electronics and computer whizz? I think not.

Why pay an expert to shoot non-creative shots when you can document the simple process and give it to cheap labour?

This is about making money, not making creative work.

I disagree with you for the following two reasons:

- human beings are all different and this job requires you to interact with human beings. You have to connect with them to make them smile or pose in a pleasing way and to stop them getting the hump and having a temper tantrum

- the guy making the iphone is doing the same thing over and over again in a static non-changing environment. Every time he puts a component on that circuit board it is the same. The same temperature, the same component, the same everything. The school photographer, or any photographer come to that is dealing with a LOT of variability. Variance in lighting, clothing colours, skin colours, space, everything! He/she should have the skills to adapt to each circumstance to get the best shot! Furthermore he/she should have the artistic talent to create the most visually pleasing arrangement of individuals based on heights etc. All in all there is a skill required which allows the photographer to adapt.

Just my 2 cents.

Thanks for the offer of help Daryl! I will check out your site :)
 
Really? All of that?

I guess I am missing something here - show me a "good" and a "bad" mass produced school photo and maybe I'll see it.

When you are in control of the scene, how difficult can it be?
 
You say that Boru, but why does it need to be any more or less than that? SNIP

I understand your point, my point being that it is sad for the individual taking the photographs. No real road for progression or career building down to very limited training.
 
I understand your point, my point being that it is sad for the individual taking the photographs. No real road for progression or career building down to very limited training.

Welcome to capitalism comrade :help:
 
Really? All of that?

I guess I am missing something here - show me a "good" and a "bad" mass produced school photo and maybe I'll see it.

When you are in control of the scene, how difficult can it be?

I am not speaking from any practical experience but that is what I assume based on taking photographs in other scenarios. If you have experience of it though I'll bow to your greater knowledge :)
 
Having seen the business side of one school photography business, I can say that for the most part it's a completely cut throat business cornered by a handful of big players. The only way to make money is to save on cost including hiring people fed up with telemarketing work to become togs.

Not a market I'd want to be in as a single pro shooter for sure. It's not art, not even craft, it's like a TV dinner served cold :)
 
If you have experience of it though I'll bow to your greater knowledge :)

I've never tried shooting the same shot in the same type of indoor location lit with my portable lighting against my portable background. All of my photography is documentary where everything changes all the time... which is why I say there's no reason for it to be anything but p*ss easy.

About as hard as selling motor insurance over the phone and requiring the same level of industry knowledge.

Not a market I'd want to be in as a single pro shooter for sure. It's not art, not even craft, it's like a TV dinner served cold :)

Indeed... what I politely refer to as "human gatso" photography.
 
Its not really any different to a lot of studio photography.
Preset the lights, set the camera to manual, f8, 1/125, iso 100 and thats it. There isn't a need to alter the camera setting.
Being creative in interacting with the subject, now thats a different matter....
 
That's true, an acquaintance of mine was a school tog' and the camera was tapped up to prevent changes in settings. I inquired as to why this was and to cut a long story short it boiled down to no understanding of photography. It was a matter of turn up, setup, point and shoot. Quite sad really.


From what I remember, one of the main photo agencies (either AP or Magnum) used to send the togs out with the aperture mechanically locked (by means of a screw through the lens) to cover news events.

It wasn't so much a case of "no experience required", more that they required a certain "look" to their images.
 
I was speaking to someone the other week who freelance for a school photography company. The lights are apparently pre set, and you just need to maesure distances to set up. You get issued with Fuji s5 and a kit lens.
 
Back
Top