Any easy way to get shots like this better?

Messages
1,179
Name
Gemma
Edit My Images
Yes
Vague title sorry - playing with new camera I took this earlier, I played with settings but couldn't seem to find a way to make the flower look better/sharper without the background going dark, this was the best I managed:

Lily001.jpg



Sure there's probably something I'm missing, think I was at about 40mm (on a 18-105) and apeture of 7ish. Don't remember other details :nuts: Just wondered if there was an easy way when you've got light on dark?
 
Quick tip.....get an exif viewer - this will help you know what settings you used. There are plenty of free ones out there, just google!

It gets rid of guessing at things like focal length, aperture etc.

For example the picture you posted above shows.......

Camera Maker: NIKON CORPORATION
Camera Model: NIKON D90
Image Date: 2008:01:10 05:03:30
Focal Length: 52.0mm (35mm equivalent: 78mm)
Aperture: f/5.0
Exposure Time: 0.0050 s (1/200)
Exposure Bias: none
Metering Mode: Matrix
Exposure: aperture priority (semi-auto)
White Balance: Auto
Flash Fired: Yes (Manual, return light detected)
Color Space: sRGB

Regards

Neil

PS I am a complete novice too! But given that there is a big contrast between the light flower and darker background you might have been better using spot metering to give the correct exposure for the flower, which at the end of the day is the main part of the image.

Like I said though I'm a complete beginner too, and I end up taking, and binning, loads of pictures!!

Just noticed you used flash.....did you try a longer exposure with a tripod?
 
The problem, as you have discovered, is that the lily is too bright and the pads are too dark. It's a dynamic range thing, which is too much for the sensor to reproduce in the same way as you see it with your eye. You can fiddle with the exposure settings as much as you like but all you will get is a compromise between the two.

Turn off the flash would be the first thing. That's probably what's finally blitzing the white into blown over exposure.

And reduce the contrast. With Canon the contrast setting is adjusted in Picture Styles in the menus, I think Nikon calls it Picture Control?

The ultimate solution is to shoot two images at different exposure levels, one maybe two stops 'over exposed' and one two stops 'under exposed'. They are both actually 'correctly exposured' but for different tones within the image. Then combine the two in post processing. This is known as HDR technique - high dynamic range.
 
Hello Gemma!

:)

Try not to be too disappointed by this. The main problem here, as HoppyUK has pointed out, has to do with how your camera calculates exposure. Also, all DSLRs struggle to capture the range of brightest tones you can see with you eyes. It’s a real hassle with digital technology and like it or not we are stuck with it for some time to come. So we just have to work around it as best we can.

Your camera has based its exposure on the entire image. In this case most of the image is taken up with the leaves which are perhaps a shade darker than the mid-tones cameras are (more or less) calibrated to. This means that the exposure is pretty good for those tones but way too much for the brightest tones in the flower’s petals. Does this make sense?

Here are a couple of histograms that show the overall image and just the flower. You can see the peak on the right that shows many bright tones are completely lost.

gemallim.jpg
gempetonly.jpg


In a shot like this it might just be possible to carefully take two handheld shots – one for the overall scene and one that lets less light reach the sensor. Try not to move position too much. A tripod is ideal because when holding the camera you run the risk of blurring the image if the shutter speed is too long.

Keep the aperture the same but use negative exposure compensation to shorten the shutter speed. Then in software you very carefully ‘cut out’ the flower’s brightest details and paste them over the other image. Then you should feather the flower just a little. Sounds tricky! But it is in fact quite simple to do with a bit of practice.

As already pointed out fill-in flash is not ideal. It's possible to use reflectors to put lots more light on the leaves to help compensate for exposing for the flower only. But...

There are other auto-software techniques out there but I’ve found that in practice manual approaches work best and offer much more control when working in layers.

Easy way? Probably not!

Sam
 
One final point about fill-in flash...

Fill-in flash has a significant effect on shadow areas but has virtually no impact at all on the brightest tones in a scene. This is a popular technique in the movie industry.

Very bright tones are largely unaffected by bright light that's much the same as the light already falling on them. But areas of shadow, being starved of bright light, respond very well.
 
Sparkoss, I'm thinking that the problem here isn't really the time of day or the quality of light, it's the very wide range of tones that exists within a single frame?
 
One other aspect - composition.

Its often that an image will be more appealing with the subject off centre and, although only there for guidance and often to be broken to good effect, the rule of thirds is something to be aware of :)

Excellent thread here on the topic: Rule of Thirds
 
One final point about fill-in flash...

Fill-in flash has a significant effect on shadow areas but has virtually no impact at all on the brightest tones in a scene. This is a popular technique in the movie industry.

Very bright tones are largely unaffected by bright light that's much the same as the light already falling on them. But areas of shadow, being starved of bright light, respond very well.

I dont think this is so much of a case of 'shadow' but the flower being more reflective than the surroundings. Flash would probably give the same result, with the added shadows from the flash.

i'd go with the earlier responses of a) waiting for better light b) spot metering for the flower and underexposing the background (this can sometimes give pleasing results as the eye is drawn to the flower, with the correct exposure and the uninteresting background is softly lit.

Unfortunately with photography like this, if you are looking for great images you need to be picky and wait for good light.
 
Thanks for the responses :D

Will take them on board and try for a better picture later :)

As above really, but simple answer is to turn off the flash and zoom in to get the lily to fill more of the frame. Let the pads go dark.

I'm guessing the flash may have turned itself on as the light is a bit low, in which case watch your shutter speed doesn't get too long for hand holding.
 
I would expose for the flower and lift the background as desired with the levels control when post processing.
 
fill in flash would blow out the lilly as done previously, after all white is always gonna be more reflective than the pads. exposing the flower correctly then using a raw processor to add some fill light could work, of if you have an external flash you may be able to use it to selectively light up the pads but I think that would be pretty complicated, and not really worth it for the time you could spend messing around with it.
 
Back
Top