are we ruining our photos with photoshop

Messages
168
Name
M J Holder
Edit My Images
No
basically i have been told that many of my photos arent that pleasing to the eye because of the over processing that i have done in photoshop so i am just wondering which photo you believe is better

1-un edited
4115824133_22efe857a6.jpg

2-edited
4115831629_a67c7f5c94.jpg
 
These are two different photographs so it's not really possible to make a fair comparison.
 
The un-edited one by a long way for me. The edited version has been oversharpened and has lost the lovely softness in the fur and features. The problem isn't photoshop per se but the over-use of photoshop - it usually works best when the changes are subtle.
 
somewhere in between would be right

and when comparing two pics they should be the same pic:)
 
Thanks mate but they are the same picture the 2nd ones just been stretched abit because i edited it

They're not. Check the amount of blue awning (I think that's what it is) to the left of the monkey's arm along with the position of the metal ring hanging loose from the chain.
 
I thinks it's sad that the monkey has a chain around it's neck. :thumbsdown:
 
They're not. Check the amount of blue awning (I think that's what it is) to the left of the monkey's arm along with the position of the metal ring hanging loose from the chain.

Agree. Building morphs bewteen the images...
 
Even so the OPs question is still valid since he's talking about processing not the actual image. I think the second shot looks over processed, too harsh, but that might have been the intention i.e. to to say this monkey should not be in chains. To my mind processing should be kept to a minimum wherever possible if you want to show the scene as you shot it.
 
The unedited image by far is the better one in my eyes but i'm no expert. The over sharpeded second image makes the monkey look less real, almost fake
 
Would we have been so harsh on the edited one if we hadn't got the original to compare it to?

Seeing the two side by side, yes, I'd say the second one was OTT...

But can you tell use what you've done in photoshop to it? Maybe you are doing something that you don't need to do or maybe you are just doing each thing too much.

On the other hand, don't worry what others think - its your art, you make what you want.
 
To me the 2nd photo (edited one) gives a better/more suitable mood considering he's got a chain around his neck. It looks more grungy and lonely. The monkey (or whatever it is) Looks sadder, and angrier.

For the mood 2nd one, but only just it is a tiny bit over cooked, a little less would be great.
 
Number 1 for me, it's more natural and suits the subject especially as it is being judged as an individual image (maybe as part of a set then #2 would work better than the first, depends on the other elements, theme etc of the set) but as far as the original question goes then in general no, photoshop is designed to totally change images if required right up to the point where you can create an image unrecognisable from the original, which you may want to do for artistic effect. It is a powerful creative tool and slightly tweaking, sharpening etc is only a very small part of what it is capable of. In some ways photoshop (and similar programs) are a bridge between the skill of taking a photgraph and the skill of a painter who creates something from scratch.
 
Surely it's only poor use of an editing program that could ruin a photo.

Even then, it's only subjective... How many of us think there's some crap in the tate modern? What one person hates, another loves (even evidenced within this thread)

I doubt it's any different now than it was before photoshop existed to be honest.
 
Sharpening a photo should be done to suit the chosen medium and final viewing size. A 'general' sharpen may appear even sharper if the file is then vastly reduced and displayed on screen.

In a perfect world, you would specifically produce a version for showing us your samples. But then you may already be aware of whether you have gone too far anyway.

It's only the 'print' that is less than perfect, because the 'negative' should remain intact. ie shoot raw and process for the intended audience/size.

However, if you are getting a significant amount of feedback suggesting they are over-processed, you may well want to ease off a little. I do tend to agree with most that somewhere in between would be best in this example.

Graham
 
There is no reason that the edited one should be any worse.
However, the unedited looks better to me for the following reasons.

1) The background is more pleasing to me
2) The face looks more natural.
3) I do not 'see' the skin in the neck and front on the unedited picture.
4) The angle of the chain looks like it is resting in the unedited, but taut in the edited
however, the light on the right hand shoulder looks nicer in the second picture
 
I actually think the face is better in the 2nd one, but the fur looks like the monkey has been in a fire.
 
It's fine...now, move along everyone - nothing to see here...
 
The un-edited one by a long way for me. The edited version has been oversharpened and has lost the lovely softness in the fur and features. The problem isn't photoshop per se but the over-use of photoshop - it usually works best when the changes are subtle.

I agree with you - the edited image looks far too unnatural for me.
 
It's fine...now, move along everyone - nothing to see here...

Why would you want to wind up someone's thread ?? If you don't like it fine but let the guy ask a question and let the rest of us provide an answer/opinion.

Or am I missing something...
 
one rule i sometimes use is however far i think a slider should go to make a picture look better, put it halfway inbetween. I think that logic applied to the above would have worked.
 
photoshop has put the surreal at our finger tips...art work dependent on true life base image
i like the first shot..with some lightening only
tonality and sharpening...cropping and cloning...all very well
but why was the photo taken...record or art
i am guilty of this as well...so i tend to use the auto button first just to see the difference

ps your monkey looks like mine...on gibraltar...a Gibraltar Barbary Macaque

as i understand it if it has a tail its a monkey if not its an ape

barbary_ape_2.jpg


used a sprinkle of fill flash so lightening the countenance and forming highlights
 
Except in Gibraltar you won't find any with chains around their necks... ;)

you got it...they are our protectors...if they dont like gib..we are out!!
so they say
;)
 
Why would you want to wind up someone's thread ?? If you don't like it fine but let the guy ask a question and let the rest of us provide an answer/opinion.

Or am I missing something...

Sense of humour fail??? :thinking:

It's just a case of bad processing. Try to be a little more subtle, learn better techniques to blend changes in less noticably and you'll get a much better response.
The second is waaaaay too much here. The lightening of shadows has gone a little too far, it's massively oversharpened, and too much saturation for me.
 
I don't particularly like the processing on the 2nd shot but that's purely my opinion, that's not to say I'm right.

To the OP; what you do is up to you and if you like processing in that way then keep doing it. I know what you're going for, can appreciate it but that's what experimenting is all about - finding a style you can live with and progress.
 
Sense of humour fail??? :thinking:

It's just a case of bad processing. Try to be a little more subtle, learn better techniques to blend changes in less noticably and you'll get a much better response.
The second is waaaaay too much here. The lightening of shadows has gone a little too far, it's massively oversharpened, and too much saturation for me.

Seeings as my sense of humour has failed perhaps you can explain the "joke" to me......
 
Why would you want to wind up someone's thread ?? If you don't like it fine but let the guy ask a question and let the rest of us provide an answer/opinion.

Or am I missing something...

Yes, you are missing something.

PP is subjective - what works for one person is anaethema to another...

We can list 100's of opinions as to the rights and wrongs of a particular method of PP, but in the end the only opinion that matters is the person who shot the photograph.

Next time you wish to take issue with one of my responses, kindly take it to PM...
 
Photoshop is a tool and we all have to learn how to use this tool. Using it correctly will improve your photos but as already said over doing it will ruin them.

Stew
 
Yes, you are missing something.

PP is subjective - what works for one person is anaethema to another...

We can list 100's of opinions as to the rights and wrongs of a particular method of PP, but in the end the only opinion that matters is the person who shot the photograph.

Next time you wish to take issue with one of my responses, kindly take it to PM...

So this forum has ceased to be a place for learning and development for new (and old) photographers and is instead a place where you decide what can and can not be posted. Nice.

It seems to me that you took issue with the original point of this thread. But did you PM the OP?? I suspect a good few people have gained some insight into PP (and sharpening in particular) from this thread. Why spoil it?

I'm a devil when it comes to equality and I believe that EVERYONE has a right to use this forum in whatever legitimate way they wish.
 
Yes, you are missing something.

PP is subjective - what works for one person is anaethema to another...

We can list 100's of opinions as to the rights and wrongs of a particular method of PP, but in the end the only opinion that matters is the person who shot the photograph.

Next time you wish to take issue with one of my responses, kindly take it to PM...

ALL art is subjective (otherwise its called science) if people only pm'ed each other when opinions on subjective qualities was an issue there would be no forum.

And no, you are wrong. When i exhibit art i do so for other people as well as myself, their opinions are just as valid, if not more so than mine. You are speaking just for yourself here and in future i guess everyone now knows that their opinions about your art are not relevant. I guess you are just in it for yourself. And that is what is great about art or conversation, you get to express who you really are.

Thats not a critiscm BTW, just giving you my opinion on what you have offered here, actually, maybe the only crit is that you are a tad over exposed :)
 
Back
Top