are we ruining our photos with photoshop

for me if it looks like it's been photoshopped - you've iverdone it - unless the goal is to make it look artificial for "artistic reasons"
 
I do think that we all get infatuated with post processing at times and we are all probably guilty of overdoing it at times.However, as Rob says,it is subjective and as long as you are happy with the results,then so be it.
 
So this forum has ceased to be a place for learning and development for new (and old) photographers and is instead a place where you decide what can and can not be posted. Nice.

It seems to me that you took issue with the original point of this thread. But did you PM the OP?? I suspect a good few people have gained some insight into PP (and sharpening in particular) from this thread. Why spoil it?

I'm a devil when it comes to equality and I believe that EVERYONE has a right to use this forum in whatever legitimate way they wish.

I think you need a cup of tea and a sit-down somewhere dark and quiet for a while...
Where have I ever said or even implied that in any way...? Your assumptions appear more based on your own preconceptions rather than what I posted.

I don't dispute the right to debate - my humourous remark wasn't aimed at you, yet you took exception to it, and by extension, to me...
So take that to PM...
Debate about the issue at hand - that stays here in the open.
 
...When i exhibit art i do so for other people as well as myself, their opinions are just as valid, if not more so than mine. You are speaking just for yourself here and in future i guess everyone now knows that their opinions about your art are not relevant. I guess you are just in it for yourself. And that is what is great about art or conversation, you get to express who you really are.

Thats not a critiscm BTW, just giving you my opinion on what you have offered here, actually, maybe the only crit is that you are a tad over exposed :)

Maybe so....but if everyone says your art is rubbish, will you give up, Or carry on regardless...?
Does someone with no artistic training or interest in photography have as valid an opinion as someone with an in-depth understanding of the medium? Of course not - That a lay-observer likes or dislikes your work is fine in itself, but I certainly wouldn't put any weight behind those opinions...

Yes I take images to please myself for the most part - sometimes others find them agreeable and when that happy coincidence occurs that is a bonus, but I'm my own harshest critic...

As to being overexposed, I solved that problem with the advent of Matrix-Metering :lol:: I just make the most of a resource that I've been part of since its inception - it's up to you whether to read my posts or not...
or to take anything from them...
 
Arkady - if you're so keen on PM's be my guest. As you said to Huujuu you've been a part of this forum for a long time - it doesn't mean that you know any better than anyone else. And your original comment wasn't humorous at all - it was your way of saying "this thread is boring and I've seen it many times before". Just be honest and it'll make the whole debate far easier for all concerned. Perhaps a rest would do you good.
 
Arkady - if you're so keen on PM's be my guest. As you said to Huujuu you've been a part of this forum for a long time - it doesn't mean that you know any better than anyone else. And your original comment wasn't humorous at all - it was your way of saying "this thread is boring and I've seen it many times before". Just be honest and it'll make the whole debate far easier for all concerned. Perhaps a rest would do you good.

...and your misinterpretation of my earlier comments is of no interest to me either...

Your sense of humour failure is likewise a matter of supreme indifference to me...
 
Maybe so....but if everyone says your art is rubbish, will you give up, Or carry on regardless...?
Does someone with no artistic training or interest in photography have as valid an opinion as someone with an in-depth understanding of the medium? Of course not - That a lay-observer likes or dislikes your work is fine in itself, but I certainly wouldn't put any weight behind those opinions...

Lets re-phrase that, if everbody told you that they found you arrogant and self centred, regardless of if they had training in physcology, or the english language, or were young and inexperienced, would you re-consider your attitude or continue ?

Yes I take images to please myself for the most part - sometimes others find them agreeable and when that happy coincidence occurs that is a bonus, but I'm my own harshest critic...

Thats a beautiful thing, knowing how your self expression comes across better than everyone else, generally i have found that most people know what is in their heads best, but what is displayed on the outside is usually best judged by your peers....oh, now what are those words....ah, yes thats it, human relationships, community,empathy...i think you get the idea

As to being overexposed, I solved that problem with the advent of Matrix-Metering :lol:: I just make the most of a resource that I've been part of since its inception - it's up to you whether to read my posts or not...
or to take anything from them...

You see, thats just subjective again, maybe you like being overexposed, if thats your style then run with it, you are indeed free to express yourself.

Thanks for you permission to read your posts or not, or take anything from them, i hadnt thought of that ;)
 
I can sympathise :)

One notable photographic luminary was quoted as telling me "You don't DO subtle do you?" on my PP.

So, I have been trying to do more subtle, little touches. Or overall filters with the effects removed from the critical areas.

One of the posters suggested backing off your effects to half of what you like and to be honest, and from experience, that's not bad advice.

So don't stress but just learn that less IS more when it comes to PP :) and keep having fun experimenting :)
 
thanks guys looks like i know which one to put in my portfolio

Ok, if that is the criteria, I would try and stick away from anything which looks like it has obviously been post processed.

My original post stated there were 4 things I didn't like:
However, the unedited looks better to me for the following reasons.

1) The background is more pleasing to me
2) The face looks more natural.
3) I do not 'see' the skin in the neck and front on the unedited picture.
4) The angle of the chain looks like it is resting in the unedited, but taut in the edited

I think that only the second one is due to over processing, you have sharpened too much I think. The first one is of personal choice. Getting rid of the hair top left was possibly the reason for stretching?

The other two items are to me that it makes the monkey look more sad. Perhaps that is the story you are attempting to get across in your picture?
 
I think if you repost you should not say which is edited and which not, as the question is a bit leading and our subconscious will play tricks on us. Just ask people which they prefer and then reveal all (even though some will know which is which).
 
I do prefer the original - I think the edit is a bit overcooked. I think part of the problem with PP is that it can be used to try to make a crap photo acceptable which is never going to give great results... whats that saying - "You can't polish a turd".

If it is used to enhance a shot that had potential to start with then no, I don't think PP is ruining our photos.

Maybe so....but if everyone says your art is rubbish, will you give up, Or carry on regardless...?
Does someone with no artistic training or interest in photography have as valid an opinion as someone with an in-depth understanding of the medium? Of course not - That a lay-observer likes or dislikes your work is fine in itself, but I certainly wouldn't put any weight behind those opinions...

I get what you are saying Arkady but surely as a pro you set some store by what joe public thinks? You've posted before saying that your shots have been used in newspapers / on websites - which in turn have been created to appeal to and be used by the lay-observer.
 
I get what you are saying Arkady but surely as a pro you set some store by what joe public thinks? You've posted before saying that your shots have been used in newspapers / on websites - which in turn have been created to appeal to and be used by the lay-observer.

If a New-Image image is used, that in itself is validation enough - even though photographically-speaking thay may be appalling...We don't often have the luxury of being able to choreograph our image-taking in those situations...

My personal work is different - there I do care...
What YOU guys think of the images I post means a helluva lot...we are, as a Forum, mostly like-minded individuals when it comes to images...

What people think of my opinions though, that's different - and yep I'm an arrogant, opinionated SOB a lot of the time, but I'm often proved right in the end, so it could be argued that what one or more person(s) percieve as breathtaking arrogance is simply self-assurance to me...

I get the job done, no matter what - and in my world, that's all that counts...
 
Back
Top