- Messages
- 431
- Name
- Nick Grant
- Edit My Images
- No
At what point is the photographer not playing a role?
What camera should I buy?
Where should I shoot?
What should I shoot?
What lens should I use?
What settings should I put on the camera?
What lighting do I use?
:shrug:

I'm tounge in cheek about some of the questions asked on this board, but this goes full circle.
I've been at a magazine shoot where there are about 20 people on set. The celebrity (subject matter) is obviously not picked by the photographer (maybe the other way round), the art directors, stylists and agent are telling the celebrity how to pose (using pictures ripped out from other magazines as inspiration), the lighting man sets up the lighting, the asistant photographer reads the lights with a meter and tells the photographer what exposure to use and the photographer....pushes the shutter button.
The opposite to that is Gregory Crewdson who directs his shoots like a film, has the vision and employs a crew set up to his idea and doesn't even push his own shutter, he has a camera operator.
Both of these photographers are not hands on in post production.
So how much input does a "photographer" have to have in a shot to be the photographer? Is it the vision, is it the physical operation of the camera or something else?
What camera should I buy?
Where should I shoot?
What should I shoot?
What lens should I use?
What settings should I put on the camera?
What lighting do I use?
:shrug:
I'm tounge in cheek about some of the questions asked on this board, but this goes full circle.
I've been at a magazine shoot where there are about 20 people on set. The celebrity (subject matter) is obviously not picked by the photographer (maybe the other way round), the art directors, stylists and agent are telling the celebrity how to pose (using pictures ripped out from other magazines as inspiration), the lighting man sets up the lighting, the asistant photographer reads the lights with a meter and tells the photographer what exposure to use and the photographer....pushes the shutter button.
The opposite to that is Gregory Crewdson who directs his shoots like a film, has the vision and employs a crew set up to his idea and doesn't even push his own shutter, he has a camera operator.
Both of these photographers are not hands on in post production.
So how much input does a "photographer" have to have in a shot to be the photographer? Is it the vision, is it the physical operation of the camera or something else?

)