At what point is the photographer not playing a role?

bbb

Messages
431
Name
Nick Grant
Edit My Images
No
At what point is the photographer not playing a role?

What camera should I buy?
Where should I shoot?
What should I shoot?
What lens should I use?
What settings should I put on the camera?
What lighting do I use?

:shrug: :p :D

I'm tounge in cheek about some of the questions asked on this board, but this goes full circle.

I've been at a magazine shoot where there are about 20 people on set. The celebrity (subject matter) is obviously not picked by the photographer (maybe the other way round), the art directors, stylists and agent are telling the celebrity how to pose (using pictures ripped out from other magazines as inspiration), the lighting man sets up the lighting, the asistant photographer reads the lights with a meter and tells the photographer what exposure to use and the photographer....pushes the shutter button.

The opposite to that is Gregory Crewdson who directs his shoots like a film, has the vision and employs a crew set up to his idea and doesn't even push his own shutter, he has a camera operator.

Both of these photographers are not hands on in post production.

So how much input does a "photographer" have to have in a shot to be the photographer? Is it the vision, is it the physical operation of the camera or something else? :thinking:
 
Interesting - for me - and I admit to having a purist approach to these matters - a 'photographer' is the one who has full control of (or at least significant input to) the creative process from start to finish, including pressing your own shutter button and post-production...:eek:
That's not to say that art-directors and stylists don't have a role to play, but at the end of the day the photographer was chosen because his or her style matches the expectations of the client...

Anything else is just being a camera-operator...and there are some very talented camera-operators out there, it must be said...
 
The photographer has the vision, he/she has the picture they want to capture in their mind.
It doesn't matter who presses the button/measures the light/adjusts the whatever, they are all working under the photographers direction.

I have more of an issue with what happens after the shot is taken, and whether that constitutes photography or not, than who physically operates the equipment.
 
The photographer has the vision, he/she has the picture they want to capture in their mind.
It doesn't matter who presses the button/measures the light/adjusts the whatever, they are all working under the photographers direction.

I have more of an issue with what happens after the shot is taken, and whether that constitutes photography or not, than who physically operates the equipment.

Agree completly.
 
I don't think it makes much difference whether its the photographers or the clients vision, the photographer still creates it, and all the peeps that help are still working under his/her direction.
I'm also not too sure that the hypothetical scenario you give, and Crewdsons method are that different, in both cases the actual photographer appears to do very little physically.
That aside, I kinda feel from your first post that you put some weight of authenticity on the dynamics of doing your own post production.
I think its really just a walk on non speaking part, whether one does ones own or not, it doesn't seem that important, I think the content of post production is far more likely to define a photographers worth as a photographer.
I dunno much about Crewdson, so maybe its not fair to judge him but, I saw a documentary a while ago in which he was setting up a snowy night scene on a street corner in the US, he went to enormous lengths to create his vision for the camera, then in PP completely dismantled the scene he had so painstakingly constructed.
He was interested in making an image, not a photograph, and will use all the tools available to create it, the original photograph was just another tool in the work flow of this particular project, used to realise the vision.
A photographer ? probably not, an artist...definitely.
 
Having been the photographer thousands of times, the client chooses the subject we both choose the models ,the art director chooses me, I choose the stylist,hairdresser,assistant the lighting is definitly me , after all that's why I was chosen, As to telling the subject how to pose That is definitly me ,the art director may make a sugestion to me and only to me.
Any post production that is not run of the mill, I would always be present, believe me without being strict on all this the shoot is certain to turn into an argumentative and unsure session.
 
Interesting - for me - and I admit to having a purist approach to these matters - a 'photographer' is the one who has full control of (or at least significant input to) the creative process from start to finish, including pressing your own shutter button and post-production...:eek:
That's not to say that art-directors and stylists don't have a role to play, but at the end of the day the photographer was chosen because his or her style matches the expectations of the client...

Anything else is just being a camera-operator...and there are some very talented camera-operators out there, it must be said...

I think my opinion on this, albeit from an 'amateur' standpoint, is pretty much in line with Rob. I think purely from a commercial pov, it would seem pointless employing a photographer with a chosen style, only to then direct the shoot to be something totally different. I think if the photographer doesn't have a 'significant input' into the shot and its pp, then why would he/she want to put his/her name to it?

Mind you, if anyone wants to pay someone a goodly wedge to be a 'camera operator', I can be free most days :p ;)
 
Interesting - for me - and I admit to having a purist approach to these matters - a 'photographer' is the one who has full control of (or at least significant input to) the creative process from start to finish, including pressing your own shutter button and post-production...:eek:

Agreed. Regardless of the crew compliment including stylists and MUA's, the photographer should have as much influence on the final result as a director in a film IMO (Hollywood executive influence and forceful persuasion aside :lol:)

Also I've never really understood the folk that shoot and then have zero to do with post.

I agree it's seems to be a run of the mill thing with some, maybe fashion shooters primarily? :shrug:, but, it really subtracts for me personally.
In addition, an absence of post production skills and knowledge is a serious disadvantage in this day and age IMO.

As for post production technique and photography - if the final piece could not have been created with camera and lens, IMO it remains to be photography and the artist remains a photographer.

I was recently subjected to the opinion that Drew Gardener is not a photographer because he sometimes composites. :cuckoo:
 
I was recently subjected to the opinion that Drew Gardener is not a photographer because he sometimes composites. :cuckoo:

Some peeps may feel that his final output is no longer a photograph, that's not to say he can't shoot, or he isn't a photographer, it just means he didn't make a photo in this particular instance in their opinion.

If nobody is to know the image is a composite or whatever, and it sits ok with the creator and other interested parties, what does it matter, its not an authenticity competition.
Jealous peeps spend too much time rubbishing material and reputations they know little about..
 
At what point is the photographer not playing a role?

What camera should I buy?
Where should I shoot?
What should I shoot?
What lens should I use?
What settings should I put on the camera?
What lighting do I use?

:shrug: :p :D

I'm tounge in cheek about some of the questions asked on this board, but this goes full circle.

I've been at a magazine shoot where there are about 20 people on set. The celebrity (subject matter) is obviously not picked by the photographer (maybe the other way round), the art directors, stylists and agent are telling the celebrity how to pose (using pictures ripped out from other magazines as inspiration), the lighting man sets up the lighting, the asistant photographer reads the lights with a meter and tells the photographer what exposure to use and the photographer....pushes the shutter button.

The opposite to that is Gregory Crewdson who directs his shoots like a film, has the vision and employs a crew set up to his idea and doesn't even push his own shutter, he has a camera operator.

Both of these photographers are not hands on in post production.

So how much input does a "photographer" have to have in a shot to be the photographer? Is it the vision, is it the physical operation of the camera or something else? :thinking:

does one need a photographer to do this...'photography'
and is ine a 'photographer' because one takes part in that event

:'(
 
Back
Top