The 2nd is better in terms of composition but I would crop the mutt out of the shot, edit out the lens flare and try to lighten the dark areas. Says me like I could ever do that satisfactorily!
Thanks simon, this one was bracketed manually, and i like this version best.
I'll have to get a bigger card and start shooting in raw then. i just need to get a program that lets u veiw them first. Dont want to have to look at 50-60 photos in ps, that'd take me ages.