Best TC's for Canon 70-200 MkII

Messages
3,914
Name
Stuart or just Stoo!
Edit My Images
Yes
Okay guys, I've only had this beast of a lens for a couple of days and I already know it's fantastic. I now believe everything I've read about how good it is.

The one thing I want to know now is what are the best 1.4x and 2x converters available for it. I've got a Kenko Pro300DGX 1.4x which I haven't tried on it yet (over the weekend with a bit of luck) but I'm sure the Canon TC's will be the best bet, and if so which model works best with it.

I'm sure it's been mentioned on here before but I couldn't find the thread I was after with the search tool, so if anyone can ley me know I'd be grateful. It's more the 2x I'm bothered about as I'm sure the Kenko will do for now.
 
I would suggest using canons' own extenders. I've got the mk II versions of both the 1.4 and 2x and they work very well with only a small drop in iq. The mkIIIs are supposed to be better but do cost a bit where the older mkIIs can be had reasonably second hand.
 
I would suppose the "best" TC you could get would be the Canon mkIII version...

With regards to 1.4x or 2x, what suits your needs - at this point in time (as you'll probably end up with the other at some point down the line), I've a 1.4 and for my needs, it's the right one (I can also use it on my 300 F4), but will probably get a 2x in the future, for those times where the extra reach would be great...
 
Thanks guys, I read somewhere that the MkII exrenders were better on certain lenses but I can't remember if the 70-200 MkII was one of them. I going to go out and try my Kenko 1.4x and see what that's like with it.
 
I use the 2x MkIII with mine and I'd say it's easily sharper than my 100-400 was at 400mm. I also have the 1.4x MkII but haven't tried it with the 70-200 yet.
 
Thanks guys, I tried my Kenko Pro300 DGX over the weekend and I'm still amazed at the focussing speed and the IQ. I'm borrowing a 2x Kenko Pro300 DGX off a mate next weekend to see how that works with it. I'm very impressed with my 1.4x Kenko though, if the 2x is anywhere near as good I'll be pleased. Trying to find someone local with a Canon TC to see if I can shoot a few first and then I'd buy the best one.
 
modchild said:
Trying to find someone local with a Canon TC to see if I can shoot a few first and then I'd buy the best one.

where's local ? (can't see on phone)
 
I'm in Branston, near to Lincoln so I think you're a bit too far away. I've just tried my friends Kenko 2x (he came early for a change) and it seems to have a problem as it's still reporting my 70-200 2.8 MkII as f2.8 and not f5.6 as it should and it wont lock on focus. My Kenko 1.4x was excellent on both my 5D3 and 60D, but the 2x wont work with either so I think he's got a duff one. No wonder he wanted me to check it out, he's had the same problems.
 
modchild said:
I'm in Branston, near to Lincoln so I think you're a bit too far away. I've just tried my friends Kenko 2x (he came early for a change) and it seems to have a problem as it's still reporting my 70-200 2.8 MkII as f2.8 and not f5.6 as it should and it wont lock on focus. My Kenko 1.4x was excellent on both my 5D3 and 60D, but the 2x wont work with either so I think he's got a duff one. No wonder he wanted me to check it out, he's had the same problems.

Yes, otherwise you could have tried the mkIII.

Hope you manage to try one out, good luck with your search ...
 
Thanks anyway, I think I'm just going to get a Canon MkIII 2x instead of going for the Kenko. My birthday and wedding anniversary is coming at the end of the month and I've got a bit of money towards it already. Just didn't want to spend £300 + on a converter, but if needs must.
 
modchild said:
Just didn't want to spend £300 + on a converter, but if needs must.

No problems

Agree with that, but the way I'd think about it - your putting it on to an expensive body and an expensive lens, so in those terms, it's not actually that dear and do you want to be wondering if the shot isn't as good as you'd like, because of the cheaper TC you used - I know I would be .... hence why I decided on the Canon
 
Well, I've taken the plunge and ordered a Canon MkIII 2x, should be here sometime next week so will try it out asap. I'm going to keep the Kenko 1.4x for now as it works very well with the 70-200 and most of my other lenses that the Canon wont. If I'm going to use it with my 5D3 and 70-200 MkII I might as well spend the extra to get the best out of it.
 
paulbroad1965 said:
Whats a tc?

Teleconverter

If you have a 2x it doubles the focal length of your lens, so the 70-200 becomes 140-400 and the 1.4 is x 1.4.

You loose a stop on the appetite of the lens with a 1.4x and 2 stops with a 2x, so an F2.8 would be F4 with a 1.4x and F5.6 with a 2x

Hope this helps
 
I just bought a 2x MKII out of the classifieds to use on my 300mm 2.8L IS and have to say it's superb on that lens. tried it on my MKI 70-200mm 2.8 IS though (with the idea of selling on the 100-400mm) but unfortunately the results could only be described as average at best.

Would be interested in seeing some shots taken with a 2x and 70-200mm f2.8 MKII, see if that's just a bit .. or a lot better.
 
Set of shots with the 70-200 2.8 mkII and the 2x mkIII extender HERE

I sold my 100-400 the day after I bought these and have not looked back.

.DAVID.
 
Last edited:
Some good pics there David. I've got the converter and went out with it for a test on friday and I'm more than happy with the result. It was a bit more expensive than I'd wanted to pay originally, but then after seeing the results of this against shots with the 100-400 L then I've got to say I'm happy enough with the price now. The shots are as good IMO so it's worth it in the end, and only about a third of the price of the 100-400 too.
 
Thanks, they look good, how was the AF speed?

To be honest I didn't notice - as in - there was nothing that made me think "what the hell have I done" or "this isn't working" some of the closer shot's where I could have taken the extender off like this one:

BSB-Oulton-05-05-12-299-L.jpg


Really tested the AF as the bikes were going for it so were in 'frame' for a short amount of time.

If you are thinking of getting one then I highly recommend Ian / Kerso from flashcamera - details in the trader area at the bottom of the forum - cheapest I found with terrific service.

.DAVID.
 
I occasionally use my Kenko 1.4x TC on my 100 L macro, mainly for portraits though I have tried macro with it on. It just seems to screw up my focussing ability though. The camera still gets focus but it alters my working distances I'm used to. Well worth getting a TC though, specially something like the Kenko that's compatible with most lenses rather than the Canon ones that are limited.
 
thankyou Stuart for reply. Are you saying the canon has short comings compared to the Kenko? What do you mean limited? This is important to me because i'm thinking of going down the TC route
 
thankyou Stuart for reply. Are you saying the canon has short comings compared to the Kenko? What do you mean limited? This is important to me because i'm thinking of going down the TC route

I think Stuart is meaning the number of lenses you can use the Canon TC on are limited, rather than the actual convertor being limited (if that makes sense :thinking:)

If you look at the compatablilty chart, it doesn't show the 100mm Macro as a lens that is compatable with the Canon TC.

http://blog.wexphotographic.com/canon-teleconverter-compatibility-chart/


Hope this helps...
 
Hi Bob, sorry about the confusion, the Canon TC's are very limited in the number of compatible lenses (the 70-200 is the only one I've got). If you have a look at my camera bag on my profile you'll see all of my lenses and the Kenko works on all of them but one (I haven't tried it on the 40mm STM yet). The Kenko 1.4x is excellent, the IQ is hardly impacted and the AF speed is not really slowed down.

I did try a Kenko 2x the other day but it wasn't working correctly and got returned, but I did get some shots taken manually focussed and they were very good, but not as good as the shots taken with the Canon 2x.
 
I did try a Kenko 2x the other day but it wasn't working correctly and got returned, but I did get some shots taken manually focussed and they were very good, but not as good as the shots taken with the Canon 2x.

Just looking at getting a TC for my 50D to use with my 200mm lens.

The reading I've done suggests that you will mostly lose AF with the x2 converters.

Since I can't afford the Canon ones and can barely afford the Kenko I am wondering about the Jessops version, but I'd prefer to see some reviews really. Don't mind losing AF as I prefer MF, but I mostly shoot handheld so the tighter aperture might effect me more :shrug:
 
To get a reliable AF with a 2x TC you really need to start with a f2.8 lens, so that when you lose 2 stops of light it will drop to a f5.6 and still AF. However, with the Kenko Pro300 DGX models they usually allow Canon bodies to AF up to f8. I have a Kenko 1.4x (which loses 1 stop of light) and that allowed me to AF with a Canon 100-400 L on a 550D, 60D, 7D and 5D2 even though it reported as f8 on all of the bodies.
 
unfortunately my 200mm is f5.6 :(
 
Chances are if you got a Kenko 1.4x it would still AF, but then that would give you only 280mm, if you needed a 2x to get the reach you need then you're going to be manual focus only I'm afraid. That's not taking into account of crop factors though, only actual lens focal lengths.
 
Back
Top