can canon 17-55 2.8 / 85 1.8 be adapted for macro work?

G

grifter09

Messages
45
Edit My Images
No
Hi all.
This is my first post on what looks like a great forum.
Im a video professional with photography experience.
I recently got a 7d with the efs 17-55 2.8 and an 85mm f1.8

My question is in relation to macro photography. From what i have read id be best off to go for a dedicated lens like the canon 100mm macro. But before i outlay the cost i think id like to dabble a little with a cheaper alternative.
Can either of the two lenses i already have be adapted to work as macro?

Mods, if you feel this needs to be moved to macro section please do.

Thanks,
G
 
Extension tubes...
Close up lenses (filters)...
Reversing ring?

I have a set of close up lenses and I love them. They're not great optically but then again, you might like a bit of distortion! I think that my set cost £28. They come in different thread sizes and the bigger diameter ones will probably cost more.
 
grifter09 said:
efs 17-55 2.8 and an 85mm f1.8
But before i outlay the cost i think id like to dabble a little with a cheaper alternative.
Can either of the two lenses i already have be adapted to work as macro?
Click to expand...


Yes, they can and as has already been mentioned you have a number of choices:

1. Extension tubes, which either provide AF links between the lens and the camera or don't, depending on price/quality. Whilst ultimately macro photography will involve much manual focus, I'd recommend keeping it simple at this stage. Buy the ones which provide AF.

2. Lens reversing rings/adapters: again they can be made to work but I'd expect a high frustration factor to begin with.

3. Close up lenses. You buy the right size to fit your lens/es. AF is maintained, as are all metering functions. Optically not the sharpest tool, a great and easy way to start.

I tried all three before committing to macro and quickly offloaded the frustration factor items: you'll have plenty to contend with with zoom lenses sorting out focal lengths and MF was simply a complication too far.

IMHO, close up lenses are the simplest solution, AF-capable extension tubes give you the broadest range of options and can still be used with a macro lens should the bug bite.
 
Thanks for the help guys.
I must do further research on these particular items. Will let you know
what I decide to go for before I actually do, just to get some reassurance.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top