canon 30d + 50mm f1.8 vs sony a390 + 50mm f1.8. which wins for iq?

Messages
952
Name
keith
Edit My Images
Yes
assuming the same shot is taken with both cameras, with all in-camera aids turned off (sony's steady shot for instance) which would win for image quality?

the sony has a 6 mega pixel advantage over the canon, but it's a ccd sensor as opposed to the canons cmos unit. anything over iso 800 is pretty poor from my sony to be honest, even with noise reduction switched on. from what i've read the less densely packed cmos should be better in low light, producing less noise than the relatively dense 14 megapixel sony sensor. am i correct in this assumption?

i'm looking at the 30d and 50mm as a cheap entry point into the canon range to see how i get on. the added size, metal body, top l.c.d. and extra on-body buttons are all things i'm craving at the minute and the low price of this combo is looking too good to pass by. it'll let me get a feel for canon with the option to upgrade easily but at the same time if i don't get on with the kit it should be pretty easily moved on to another home.
 
It's been a long time since I used my 30D, but I have no complaints about the IQ up to 1600 ISO. This was shot at 1600 ISO in raw and converted to JPEG in Lightroom with no edits except white balance.

20080829_201442_2921_LR.jpg


100% crop, no further edits....

20080829_201442_2921_LR-2.jpg


With a little bit of cleaning up in Lightroom....

20080829_201442_2921_LR-3.jpg
 
Last edited:
30D is a great camera, for its age. It preforms really well if you know how to use it. :)
Don't have anything to show of with 50 1.8 but my flickr is full of 30D photos, only few taken using other cameras. :)
 
It's been a long time since I used my 30D, but I have no complaints about the IQ up to 1600 ISO. This was shot at 1600 ISO in raw and converted to JPEG in Lightroom with no edits except white balance.

20080829_201442_2921_LR.jpg


100% crop, no further edits....

20080829_201442_2921_LR-2.jpg


With a little bit of cleaning up in Lightroom....

20080829_201442_2921_LR-3.jpg


thanks for the pics tim, that is a hell of a lot cleaner than the shots i get from my sony at 1600. it's making a good arguement for the 30d to be sure
 
When I bought my 30D, back in 2006, noise was the number one factor in my decision to go with Canon rather than Nikon. I know things have moved on since then, but the 30D was and still is a very nice camera. Light on bells and whistles it may be, but it is a solid performer.
 
When I bought my 30D, back in 2006, noise was the number one factor in my decision to go with Canon rather than Nikon. I know things have moved on since then, but the 30D was and still is a very nice camera. Light on bells and whistles it may be, but it is a solid performer.

solid is what i'm looking for at the minute, tough build, able to do the basics well and give me a platform to build upon in the future. a standard f2.8 zoom like the tamron and an 85mm f1.8 should round out a decent budget kit that will see me right for a while.
 
Back
Top