Canon 50mm 1.8 query

Messages
740
Edit My Images
Yes
I took delivery of my nifty-fifty a few days ago. I wanted to check whether I have a grey import or if it is normal?

The one I received has a USA/Canada warranty card inside.
Mine is made in Malaysia (which is fine from what I feel)


Also, I would be grateful for any tips on using this prime effectively as I tried several shots but they are a bit blurry or not as pin sharp as the pics I've seen on here.
(Used for indoor shots so far)

Thanks
 
How close are you getting to the subject? I've had mine a few days and already noticed if you're getting up close you might have to close down a few stops to f2.2ish otherwise you lose focus quite quickly from the focal point outwards.
 
How close are you getting to the subject? I've had mine a few days and already noticed if you're getting up close you might have to close down a few stops to f2.2ish otherwise you lose focus quite quickly from the focal point outwards.

I've tried objects from half a metre to 3-4 metres away under lamp light to 100w light bulb. Clearest was on lgiht streaming through window but was expecting better results under low light.

Also, mine seems to clunk a couple of time if subject is too close to the lens. Worried it might smack open. :/
 
clunking is ok :)

you need to show a pic for us to decide.. i love my nifty fifty :)
 
I've got the nifty fifty I use on the 450D. The minimum focus is 450cm (1 1/2 feet). Mine is not sharp at f1.8 and is at it's best between f2.2 & f18. Test your lens by putting it on a tripod and shoot a page of fine print having the same lighting using a different f stop each time from a distance of about 1 meter and then compare the results. You could do this using AF as well as MF.

Paul
 
clunking is ok :)

you need to show a pic for us to decide.. i love my nifty fifty :)

Good call. I'll try and get some pics later on as I'm at work now.

I've got the nifty fifty I use on the 450D. The minimum focus is 450cm (1 1/2 feet). Mine is not sharp at f1.8 and is at it's best between f2.2 & f18. Test your lens by putting it on a tripod and shoot a page of fine print having the same lighting using a different f stop each time from a distance of about 1 meter and then compare the results. You could do this using AF as well as MF.

Paul


Snap. I'm using a 450D (well a rebel XSi)

I'll try out what you said as it would a good test.



Thanks
 
I thought I had a problem with my fast 50 when I got it, but it turned out that at large apertures, the depth of focus is so small that a tiny error in focusing results in a blurry picture. Indoor light can throw some AF systems slightly and this was enough to worry me until I went outdoors and suddenly it was razor sharp.
 
Make sure you up your iso to increase your shutter speed.
 
First of all, make sure it is sharp somewhere.

I think no-one would usualy recommend this for checking focus of a lens, but, it is valid for checking for sharpness.
Get a tablecloth, or sofa cushion, something that is flat, and put a ruler down on it horizontaly, point left to right around half-way down it.
Now set your camera to Av mode, and adjust your ISO (or even use flash) until you get at least 1/100th of a second.
Now, at a distance of around 1m, at an angle of around 45 degress use the autofocus to focus on the ruler.
Now pixel peep at the image.
We are not checking for focus accuracy. This is not a test for that. Angled targets are not ideal for that.

However, what you should find, is a horizontal band in your image, where the fabric is lovely and sharp.
(However, on the 400d I had, ISO handling wasn't great, so maybe try not to go above 400 ISO?)
If the sharpness band is not horizontal, but diagonal, it either means that you were not square on, or there is a problem with the lens.
If it is horizontal, but doesn't meet the ruler (remember this strictly wasn't an autofocus test), then either the lens/camera is front/back focusing, or the fact that the camera uses a vertical line of sensors is meaning that the focus was of, or, if you are like me, you took a breath in between focusing and pressing go.
The depth of field is very shallow, a cm could be enough to through focus off.


Edit:
I have just done this as a test myself. Here are two 100% crops. As you can see, the area of focus is less than the width of the ruler at f/2.0, so you need to be sure of where you are focusing.
One is focused on the ruler, and then the other is focused on the material itself (with a bit of grass for help).



(the ruler is actually somewhat sharper on my screen, but saving at jpeg level 4 to get it under 200k makes things more blury)
 
Last edited:
I took delivery of my nifty-fifty a few days ago. I wanted to check whether I have a grey import or if it is normal?

The one I received has a USA/Canada warranty card inside.
Mine is made in Malaysia (which is fine from what I feel)


Also, I would be grateful for any tips on using this prime effectively as I tried several shots but they are a bit blurry or not as pin sharp as the pics I've seen on here.
(Used for indoor shots so far)

Thanks

Looks like you are the proud owner of a GREY import. Canon UK may refuse to repair any faults. :'(
 
Looks like you are the proud owner of a GREY import. Canon UK may refuse to repair any faults. :'(

Fortunatly there is still comeback on the vendor - and often vendors that import will also deal with warranty issues for you.
 
:(

Don't think I can trust getting something like this again from a 'Fulfilled' partner on Amazon.
 
This is a wide open shot at 1250 ISO (I think) with my nifty fifty. It's had just a touch more than normal sharpening in LR3 and then none further on reduction and saving to jpeg, which should bring it back to about normal. This is what you should expect.
5135348882_f868e35134_b.jpg
 
I,ve got a nifty too, agree you should get sharpnes like The23rdman's shot
Canon should cover the warranty on grey lenses, its camera bodies that have to be bought in the UK
 
Back
Top