Canon 70-200 F4. Image Stabiliser or not for moving subjects?

Messages
159
Name
Chris
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi,

Thinking about getting a Canon 70-200 F4 for use with my 40D. The main use will be for taking photos of my 19 month old lad running round the park and getting into all sorts of bother..

Already have prime 28mm + 50mm and get some lovely shots, but want something longer to catch shots without being too intrusive..

My question is to image stabilize or not.. Difference in price is significant and my current thinking is that IS is not going to help with a fast moving target (me lad running around). Is that right?

IS would allow me to take photos at slower shutter speeds, great, but if the subject is constantly moving then I need to up the shutter speed anyway..

Is my thinking correct please?

Thanks,
Chris
 
The F/4 has two setting 1 and 2

1 is for general shots 2 is for panning

good day light fast shutter speed good light you could be using f16 and lower so the F/4 would be fine both can be compensated by upping the iso


the is helps at low light and for hand held at slow speeds


here have a read

There are MANY uses for the Canon EF 70-200mm f/4.0 L USM Lens, but portrait photography is one of the best. Classic portrait focal lengths range from 85mm to 135mm effective focal lengths (field of view crop factor included). The 70-200 f/4.0L lens comes with most (or all for full frame and 1.3x body users) of those mms included. I often use even higher focal lengths for tight portraits - 200mm and/or a 1.6x FOVCF body allows for these tightly-framed shots.

Outdoor sports photography is another popular use for the Canon EF 70-200mm f/4.0 L USM Lens. It is an ideal lens for young children's soccer matches when mounted on a 1.6x FOVCF body. You might want to add a Canon Extender EF 1.4x depending on the size of the subjects and their playing field. The Canon 70-200 f4 lens is generally too slow for indoor action photography unless you can utilize an accessory flash such as the Canon 580EX Flash. Early or late outdoor action sports photography is better handled with the Canon EF 70-200 f/2.8L Lens or the Canon EF 70-200mm f/2.8 L IS II USM Lens. Heavily overcast days are also a challenge for action sports photography with the 70-200 f/4L.

Need a walk-in-the-park or a beach lens? The Canon EF 70-200mm f/4.0 L USM Lens is ideal for my uses. Combining excellent image quality with relatively light weight and small size, the Canon EF 70-200mm f/4.0 L USM Lens has a good focal length range for grabbing candids of the kids and family at play.

General wildlife and nature photography is area where the Canon EF 70-200mm f/4.0 L USM Lens may not be ideal, but often finds use in. Depending on their size and distance, wild subjects may not frame tightly enough with the bare 70-200 focal length. But, this lens starts having some nice reach while retaining very good image quality when paired with the Canon Extender EF 1.4x II on a 1.6x body. Wary small birds and animals will likely require a longer lens alltogether.

When thinking about a landscape lens, many photographers immediately think wide angle lenses. Wide angle lenses can take in vast scenes, but the 70-200mm focal length range is a favorite of professional landscape photographers as it yields beautiful compressed landscape images. When photographing landscapes, wide apertures are generally not needed as narrower apertures are generally used for greater depth of field. When photographing landscapes, packing light makes the long hikes often required to get to the beauty easier. As some of the beauty of landscape photography is in the form of flowers and other smaller objects, the magnification ability of the 70-200 f/4 is useful for this purpose. Thus, the Canon EF 70-200mm f/4.0 L USM Lens is ideally suited for landscape photography use.

Those contemplating a Canon EF 70-200mm f/4.0 L USM Lens purchase are typically considering the Canon EF 70-300mm f/4-5.6 IS USM Lens as well. Priced similarly with an extended focal length range and an excellent implementation of IS, this lens fills many of the same requirements as the 70-200 f/4. I usually recommend the 70-200 f/4 over the 70-300 IS because of its physical and optical advantages, but read the 70-300 review to find out which is better for your needs.
 
the is helps at low light and for hand held at slow speeds
Thanks for the info.

I *think* you are confirming my suspicions that IS isn't generally required for the situation I've described..

Ta,
Chris
 
IS is designed to eliminate/reduce camera shake, which is a problem encountered when trying to hold the camera steady. If you are moving the camera around trying to follow a moving subject, IS isn't going to be much use.

Many IS lenses have two settings, the first for stationary subjects, and the second for use when panning with a subjuct. The idea of this second mode is that the IS will only try and reduce unsteadiness in the vertical plane, as there is obviously going to be a considerable amount of movement in the horizontal plane as you pan the camera.

If your lad is moving all over the place, then IS even in mode 2 isn't likely to help much.
 
If you take the hand-holding rule of thumb, then IS will benefit you whenever your shutter speed drops below 1/320sec (at 200mm). Even when moving the lens around in mode 2, the direction of movement will tend to be horiziontal. Basically, unless you can guarantee high shutter speeds all the time, you will benefit from IS.

Apart from that, the IS and non-IS versions of the 70-200L 4 are optically and mechanically completely different. They are not the same lens at all, and the IS version is better all round.

If you decide that IS is important (and personally I wouldn't consider a lens of that range without it) but the extra cost isn't worth it for you, then look at the 70-300 IS. Still a damn good lens :)
 
HoppyUK said:
If you decide that IS is important (and personally I wouldn't consider a lens of that range without it) but the extra cost isn't worth it for you, then look at the 70-300 IS. Still a damn good lens :)

+1 here. The 70-300 IS USM is very underrated.

Steve

Sent from my iPad using TP Forums
 
IS is designed to eliminate/reduce camera shake, which is a problem encountered when trying to hold the camera steady. If you are moving the camera around trying to follow a moving subject, IS isn't going to be much use.

I'll go further than that - in my experience using IS can actually be harmful to IQ when tracking tricky subjects. I don't think there is anything wrong in the IS modes when you use them as intended, but if you are trying to follow a subject that is moving randomly or making movements which are not simple pans left/ right or up/down (e.g. diagonal tracking) then IS won't help at all. Just the opposite. The IS will fight your efforts to follow your subject, causing a peculiar jerking of the image in the viewfinder, and may cause a fuzziness in the captured image.

There's also the issue of shutter speeds. The intent of IS is primarily to help you steady the lens when shooting at slow shutter speeds. That's all fine and dandy, but at high shutter speeds it appears to be superfluous and again potentially harmful to IQ. Certainly I disengage IS when shooting BIF at speeds of 1/800 and above, even when shooting at 400mm on a crop body. Experience informs me that the results are better without IS than with in those situations. YMMV.

For Nikon shooters there is an interesting article by Thom Hogan about VR. I suspect his arguments apply to Canon IS as well, in principle at least.

http://bythom.com/nikon-vr.htm
 
The f4 is a cracker of a lens and you'll not be disappointed with it.

IF you can stretch to the IS version then personally I would as there will be occasions when it would be good to have it.

But there is nothing wrong with the non IS version and you wouldn't loose much money on it if you decided you wanted to upgrade in the future.
 
+1 here. The 70-300 IS USM is very underrated.

Steve

Sent from my iPad using TP Forums


dont bother to use it for birds at 300 anyway, its not worth it, but apart from that yes indeed its a very good lens.

Yet sold it to make room for the 70-200 f4 IS... havent had it long enough to say if the extra cost was worth it. I remember that 70-300 up till 200 used to be very very sharp
 
Well ended up going for a 2nd hand IS version from classifieds here. It's an amazing bit of kit and looking forward to learning how to get the best out of it over the coming months. Thanks again everyone for replying.. :thumbs:
 
You did the right thing. I bought the non-IS version originally (also bought mine 2nd hand) but having read on so many forums/articles how superior the IS version was optically I decided to upgrade after about a year. I managed to sell my non-IS at the same price I bought it for (I did buy well in the first place though!) and got hold of an IS version that was only a couple of months old, so as good as new. Haven't looked back at all - lovely lens and a fair bit sharper (which is saying something as non-IS was also very sharp!).

My filosophy is that you can always switch IS off but can't switch it on if the lens doesn't have it!!

Enjoy the lens - I'm sure you will.
 
Back
Top