Classic Canon fit lenses? Not L glass.

Messages
1,195
Name
Gordon
Edit My Images
Yes
I'm trying to get a list together of no longer manufactured Classic non L glass Canon EOS fit lenses.

I have some which I believe fit into this category, can you help me add to it.

Canon 70-210 f4 (push pull slow AF, but great image quality)
Canon 70-300mm f4-5.6 IS USM (we all know this was a great lens)
Sigma 70mm f2.8 (probably the sharpest lens ever made)
Sigma 24-60mm f2.8 (sharper and smaller than the 24-70mm and best colour and contrast)
Sigma 70-200mm APO EX HSM (the original)

I own the above, but want to add to the collection of obsolete gems, any suggestions?
 
I have an old Mk1 Canon 28-80mm that I sometimes dig out for studio stuff when I'm in the mood to play. Not sure you'd call it a classic but it's certainly better than more recent non L lenses.

You can't have it of course - I was just letting you know it's worth getting if you see one :)
 
I'm sorry, but the 28-80mm or the 24-85mm don't seem to have good enough reviews to get into the hall of fame.
 
My favourite lens in this category is also a 70-210, but this time the 70-210 f/3.5-4.5 USM. Lovely IQ and very quick focusing, it's the lens that stops me buying a 70-200.
 
My favourite lens in this category is also a 70-210, but this time the 70-210 f/3.5-4.5 USM. Lovely IQ and very quick focusing, it's the lens that stops me buying a 70-200.

That lens seems to have had some good reviews, but i'm not sure if it quite makes it, I'll give it some thought.
 
85mm 1.8 ?
70-210 f/3.5-4.5 ?

EF-S 17-55 ?
 
Last edited:
Dinners you have misread the OP I think - two of those lenses you mention are still in production today.
 
Dinners you have misread the OP I think - two of those lenses you mention are still in production today.

Very true and the other one has also been proposed.

Remember they don't have to be Canon lenses only Canon fitment.
 
Hi folks

Didn't see the 'no longer manufactured bit'......
 
28/70 3.5/4.5 metal mount non usm (mk1 I think)

Matt
 
Cracking lens after one of those to use with my EOS10

Agreed, tried mine against my 50 and 85 primes, not a lot of difference, and tbh not a lot of difference against my 70/200 f4 IS L. Sometimes see them on e-bay for about £60/70.

Matt
 
I don't understand why current lenses are being rejected when the OP put a current lens on the list (the 70-300 IS)? If you meant the original 75-300 IS then it could perhaps make the list solely by virtue of being the first IS lens, rather than its optical or mechanical quality... In that case what about the first consumer-level ring-USM (35-135 USM which would have been the first mechanical FTM lens, as the early pro USM lenses had electronic manual focus) or the first micro-USM lens, since these introduced similar technologies?

The 24-85 was a very good lens at the wider end stopped down (ie F8-F11, 24-50mm). If used that way it was better than the 28-105 and 28-135 that were also current, but it wasn't an outstanding lens across the board.
 
I don't understand why current lenses are being rejected when the OP put a current lens on the list (the 70-300 IS)? If you meant the original 75-300 IS then it could perhaps make the list solely by virtue of being the first IS lens, rather than its optical or mechanical quality... In that case what about the first consumer-level ring-USM (35-135 USM which would have been the first mechanical FTM lens, as the early pro USM lenses had electronic manual focus) or the first micro-USM lens, since these introduced similar technologies?

The 24-85 was a very good lens at the wider end stopped down (ie F8-F11, 24-50mm). If used that way it was better than the 28-105 and 28-135 that were also current, but it wasn't an outstanding lens across the board.

I put the 70-300mm IS on the list because I understand it has now been discontinued. It is no longer on the Canon web site. I did have the 35-135mm USM and that was a great little lens.
 
28/70 3.5/4.5 metal mount non usm (mk1 I think)

Matt

This was a little gem optically, but the mechanics let it down a bit. I will give it some thought.
 
The 70-300 is still on canon USA's website. Canon UK's site is all over the shop and rarely updated - it still shows the 75-300 IS as current but as you say has no mention of the 70-300 IS. I would be inclined to take the USA site as definitive, and that currently shows all three stabilised 70-300s as current. http://www.usa.canon.com/cusa/profe...onal_cameras/ef_lens_lineup/lens_telezoom_pro

Okay, I will assume that Canon UK is incorrect and remove the 70-300mm IS USM.
 
My favourite lens in this category is also a 70-210, but this time the 70-210 f/3.5-4.5 USM. Lovely IQ and very quick focusing, it's the lens that stops me buying a 70-200.

I'd second that it was a very serious contender when I got my 70-210 f4 and I'm still tempted to pick one up for a comparison. I love the f4 but the snappier quieter focussing would be a massive advantage at times!
 
I'd second that it was a very serious contender when I got my 70-210 f4 and I'm still tempted to pick one up for a comparison. I love the f4 but the snappier quieter focussing would be a massive advantage at times!

I had one of these for a while, and I found the AF to be remarkably good considering it's age. I'll have to dig some shots out but I remember using it to track running dogs.
 
I use it for shooting tennis mostly, here's one of Serena Williams with it from Wimbledon this year:


Serena Williams by Pam & Ben, on Flickr

More in the Wimbledon and Nottingham Masters sets on my flickr.
 
My favourite lens in this category is also a 70-210, but this time the 70-210 f/3.5-4.5 USM. Lovely IQ and very quick focusing, it's the lens that stops me buying a 70-200.


I had the USM version and it was pretty good on crop, superior to the old and noisy f4 plastic drainpipe. I did get the L which is better and sharper, and that made me get FF to make the most of it.

Perhaps Tokina 28-70mm f/2.6-2.8 II and 20-35mm f/2.8 are worth the place there.

BTW, if you do consider the performance of some of these lenses on FF, things would look rather less impressive. Crop can take lenses as long as they have v. good centre sharpness, regardless of awful corners. That would include nearly all non-L Canon-branded zooms.
 
BTW, if you do consider the performance of some of these lenses on FF, things would look rather less impressive. Crop can take lenses as long as they have v. good centre sharpness, regardless of awful corners. That would include nearly all non-L Canon-branded zooms.

That's a very good point, crop sensors allow lenses designed for full frame to really shine. I have used the 70-210 on 35mm film but I'd be hard pushed to find an example. I've just got a "new" 1N HS and was planning to run off a few test shots of my son's football match this weekend with it, so I'll so how it fares under those circumstances.
 
EF 50mm f/1.8 Mk1

[ducks]

I've got this lens and honestly I'm staggered how the 'updated' version is so pants in comparison (other than the noise of the autofocus) - I can't find any detailed reviews about the mkI to see if my experience is similar or I have a particularly naff mkII.
 
I've got this lens and honestly I'm staggered how the 'updated' version is so pants in comparison (other than the noise of the autofocus) - I can't find any detailed reviews about the mkI to see if my experience is similar or I have a particularly naff mkII.

I had both (very briefly). The optics were fairly identical (super sharp from f/2.8-4, but awful bokeh), but the build was day and night. mk1 has metal ring, non-rotating filter thread (80% sure), and proper focus ring. The noise was fairly similar from both. That makes mk1 look like a very decent small cheap lens, not so for mk2!
 
That's why used mk Is are worth more than a new mk 2. One day I'll probably sell my mk 1.
 
Okay, I agree with the Canon 50mm f1.8 Mk1 and I think the Tokina 20-35mm f/2.8 is worth a place. Not sure about the other proposals.

So the list so far of the discontinued Canon classic little gems is:-

Canon 70-210 f4 (push pull slow AF, but great image quality)
Sigma 70mm f2.8 (probably the sharpest lens ever made)
Sigma 24-60mm f2.8 (sharper and smaller than the 24-70mm and best colour and contrast)
Sigma 70-200mm APO EX HSM (the original)
Canon 50mm f1.8 Mk1
Tokina 20-35mm f/2.8 (great IQ and built like a BSH)

Removed awaiting confirmation if it has been dicontinued:-
Canon 70-300mm f4-5.6 IS USM (we all know this was a great lens)

Any more suggestions?
 
Removed awaiting confirmation if it has been dicontinued:-
Canon 70-300mm f4-5.6 IS USM (we all know this was a great lens)

Any more suggestions?

I thought that there was a new (Mk II) version of this lens, and the original 70-300 f4-5.6 IS USM had now been dropped. It may well be on some sites as they may still have stock.

I have to say that I've been quite impressed with how well this lens performs on my 7D, and I'll never let my Mk1 50mm f2.8 go, I bought when I got my EOS 620 about 22/23 years ago..... (I still have the 620 too!)

Steve
 
I thought that there was a new (Mk II) version of this lens, and the original 70-300 f4-5.6 IS USM had now been dropped. It may well be on some sites as they may still have stock.

I have to say that I've been quite impressed with how well this lens performs on my 7D, and I'll never let my Mk1 50mm f2.8 go, I bought when I got my EOS 620 about 22/23 years ago..... (I still have the 620 too!)

Steve

Yes I think it has been discontinued, somebody else thought that it may not have been. It is a fantastic lens, I'm always surprised by the resuts. I think we will assume it has been dropped and add it back into the list.
 
Back
Top