Creativity a 'mental illness' (special mention for photographers!)

gaz_jameison said:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-19959565

Creativity 'closely entwined with mental illness'
By Michelle Roberts
Health editor, BBC News online

Creativity is often part of a mental illness, with writers particularly susceptible, according to a study of more than a million people.

Writers had a higher risk of anxiety and bipolar disorders, schizophrenia, unipolar depression, and substance abuse, the Swedish researchers at the Karolinska Institute found.

They were almost twice as likely as the general population to kill themselves.

The dancers and photographers were also more likely to have bipolar disorder.

As a group, those in the creative professions were no more likely to suffer from psychiatric disorders than other people.

But they were more likely to have a close relative with a disorder, including anorexia and, to some extent, autism, the Journal of Psychiatric Research reports.

Lead researcher Dr Simon Kyaga said the findings suggested disorders should be viewed in a new light and that certain traits might be beneficial or desirable.

For example, the restrictive and intense interests of someone with autism and the manic drive of a person with bipolar disorder might provide the necessary focus and determination for genius and creativity.

Similarly, the disordered thoughts associated with schizophrenia might spark the all-important originality element of a masterpiece.

Dr Kyaga said: "If one takes the view that certain phenomena associated with the patient's illness are beneficial, it opens the way for a new approach to treatment.

"In that case, the doctor and patient must come to an agreement on what is to be treated, and at what cost.

"In psychiatry and medicine generally there has been a tradition to see the disease in black-and-white terms and to endeavour to treat the patient by removing everything regarded as morbid."

Beth Murphy, head of information at Mind, said bipolar disorder personality traits could be beneficial to those in creative professions, but it may also be that people with bipolar disorder are more attracted to professions where they can use their creative skills.

"It is important that we do not romanticise people with mental health problems, who are too often portrayed as struggling creative geniuses.

"We know that one in four people will be diagnosed with a mental health problem this year and that these individuals will come from a range of different backgrounds, professions and walks of live. Our main concern is that they get the information and support that they need and deserve."

-------------------------------

Opinions!?!?! :lol::lol::lol:

Erm [PLEASE DON'T TRY TO BYPASS THE SWEAR FILTER] lol
 
Erm [PLEASE DON'T TRY TO BYPASS THE SWEAR FILTER] lol

I had a feeling that would be your response... dunno why... just call it a hunch.
 
Mental illness is undoubtedly real however it's a fact that anti-depressants are being dolled out like smarties in much the same way that antibiotics were previously.

It's all due to Doctors looking for the "quick fix" to hit targets rather than the best fix and IMO just leads to further issues down the line when in 9 out of 10 cases actual therapy would have been the best fix.

There are lots of studies out there and one of the most telling was a fairly recent one where 100 people suffering from depression were given a placebo instead of actual anti depressants. Over time the figures showed up as only very marginally worse than when proper medication was prescribed but with obviously less after effects.

While I understand that it would be impossible to do an MRI on everyone who claims to have depression to check for a chemical imbalance there should be a better way than just "here's some pills"

BTW I base all of this on an keen interest in Psychology, living with my fiancé who worked through and gained degree at York Uni in Psychology, living with and around an ex whose Mother was bi-polar and a trip to the docs with my fiancé to discus the fact that she felt "a little run down" and worn out due to high workload where she walked out with a prescription for anti depressants as she had a "chemical imbalance in her brain" (doctors immediate diagnosis just through talking to her for 5 mins with absolutely no tests done what-so-ever to confirm!! I am in no way trivialising people who have or indeed those who “think” they have any form of mental illness. In fact my thoughts are the complete opposite in that I think more should be done so that these people who, on the whole just want to discuss their issues and ultimately GET BETTER can do so permanently without having to also get over the withdrawal symptoms that come with anti-depressants IF they’re not needed and not being just left to it if they are needed without any further psychiatric care or discussion.

Dean
 
Pookeyhead said:
I had a feeling that would be your response... dunno why... just call it a hunch.

Care to explain why? Or are you just making a pointless response
 
Last edited:
No, and no. I'm tired of you.
 
I was diagnosed with seasonal affective disorder about 16 years ago. I suffered episodes of acute anxiety and severe suicidal depression for many years previous to this diagnosis. I was on antidepressants most of the time (tricylics).

When I say diagnosed, at first it was self diagnosis. I was given a leaflet about SAD and I realised that this was what I was suffering from. I bought a light box and the transformation was remarkable. I joined the SAD association and found out that SSRI's may be better than the antidepressants that I was using at the time. This proved to be correct and have used them and a light box to control the illness. I have had fantastic support from my family, friends, work colleagues and my gp. If I have to be on medication for the rest of my life I really don't care, they are non-addictive and give me a quality of life that I wouldn't have otherwise have had.
 
If medication is the only option then it is clearly better than nothing. The point here is that is is quite often not the only option but the time and knowledge required by doctors is not available to pursue getting to the root causes.
As an example (not related to mental health), the Food Hospital program that is currently running proves that point very well. Changes to diet can have a better effect than medication but the typical doctor would not have the time or knowledge to even start to apply these sort of alternatives and it is easier and quicker to write a prescription out.
 
SSRIs were a god send to me no way would i have coped without them. was on them for 6 years and came off them earlier in the year. It's tuff to control but bein off drugs does make it better.
 
Don't get me started on "Mental Health", sorry but i'm of the school of thought that if you are feeling a bit down/depressed, then go out and have some fun with your mates, not go straight to the doctors and put on a course of anti-depressants (and yes, i do know a few people who have done this)

It just seems that there are more and more "Mental Health" issues being discovered every year, back when i was younger it was virtually unheard of that anyone had mental health issues, now it seems every other person you meet has

As for the article above, i just see it as everyone is an individual, some people are creative, some are not, i don't see the need to have to label certain people as having certain disorders, even if it is just statistically

(PS, sorry if i offended anyone, these are just my personal opinions)

With all due respect, your post is extremely ignorant. What you perceive as more and more issues being "discovered" every year is, in fact, symptomatic of society's increasing openness about issues that have existed since the dawn of man, issues that until recently were considered taboo (when you were younger, nobody spoke about them but they certainly existed). If you think depressed people simply need to get out and have some fun, then clearly you don't know anyone with a depression problem, and you don't know that serious depression is the result of chemical imbalances in the brain, often with genetic links. These imbalances aren't cured by going out and having fun, no more so than that activity would cure any other illness.

I'm a raging socialite with a wide circle of friends who mostly loves being out and about. And yet I've struggled with a certain depression problem (I'm not going to go into specifics) which suddenly showed up in my later teenage years, despite a perfectly lovely childhood, and it's a serious issue that's persisted despite numerous medications, which I eventually simply gave up on. Most people I know would never, ever guess that I have a depression problem because I am one of those loud, energetic people who is always laughing and joking around, so the suggestion that you just go out and have fun is clearly no solution. My particular problem clearly runs in my family on my father's side, with at least two of his siblings, both of whom developed extremely destructive lifestyles and are now dead, having suffered from it too. Which doesn't ex actly set an inspiring precedent but I soldier on as best as I can. In some strange ways, my disorder is actually quite beneficial sometimes in my line of work as an artist, but frankly if I had the choice, I'd prefer to not have it at all, because most of the time it's a private hell. My only weapon against it is to keep myself very busy, whether it's with work or hobbies or friends. Anyway, I don't mean to ramble on but my point is that depression is a very real problem that can affect even the most chipper, social people like myself.

On the subject of the article itself, while many studies have shown links between depression and creativity, it's important to remember that correlation does not equal causation. Creative people aren't necessarily all depressed and neither are all depressed people creative, and for this reason I'd say the article's suggestion that "creativity is often a part of depression" is misguided, as it implies a measure of causation where none has been proven.
 
Last edited:
I'm almost halfway through a "365" style cartoon drawing project, is it this which is driving me nuts or I'm mad enough to do it in the first place? :D
 
Don't get me started on "Mental Health", sorry but i'm of the school of thought that if you are feeling a bit down/depressed, then go out and have some fun with your mates, not go straight to the doctors and put on a course of anti-depressants (and yes, i do know a few people who have done this)

)

thing is theres a difference between being a 'bit down' and suffering depression - part of the problem is people say "oh i'm depressed" when they mean" i'm a bit miserable, my job is crap, my boss is an arse etc"

that isnt being depressed and that sort of thing can be 'cured' by having fun with your mates, walking it off, having a good old chat etc

however propper depression is a mental health issue and isnt going to be cured by the sorts of things that might normally lift a mood - that is where either counselling or tablets come in.
 
Back
Top