Deciding on the type of ND Grad Filters

Messages
2,537
Name
Dave
Edit My Images
Yes
I'm reading an article at the moment in Advanced Photographer on ND Grad Filters and in order to decide the appropriate filter the author suggests the following -
''I point the camera downwards to exclude the sky and take a reading. I then aim the camera towards the sky and take a second reading and the difference between the two is the required density of filter. For instance, if the first reading for the land is f11 at 1/30sec and the reading for the sky is
f11 at 1/250sec then the exposure difference is 3 stops meaning you need a 3 stop filter''
How is the calculation done to determine that a 3 stop filter is required
Appreciate any help
Dave
 
Why not shoot HDR and achieve the same thing without the use of filters?
 
A 1 stop change is a doubling or halving of the exposure.
From 1/30 to 1/60 is a 1 stop change, from 1/60 to 1/125 is another 1 stop change, from 1/125 to 1/250 is a further 1 stop change.
So from 1/30 to 1/250 is 3 stops in total.
 
I'm reading an article at the moment in Advanced Photographer on ND Grad Filters and in order to decide the appropriate filter the author suggests the following -
''I point the camera downwards to exclude the sky and take a reading. I then aim the camera towards the sky and take a second reading and the difference between the two is the required density of filter. For instance, if the first reading for the land is f11 at 1/30sec and the reading for the sky is
f11 at 1/250sec then the exposure difference is 3 stops meaning you need a 3 stop filter''
How is the calculation done to determine that a 3 stop filter is required
Appreciate any help
Dave

That technique will tell you the difference in brightness between the sky and the land, and the exposure necessary to render them both mid-grey. It's a very good guide and tells you where things are, but needs to be modified as that is not necessarily what you want.

If you do that measurement, it will usually show a very large difference, like 3-6 stops, and if that's interpreted literally the effect will be dramatic, and often artifically obvious. When the sky begins to get as dark as the land, it looks like a massive thunderstorm, or sometimes more like a nuclear dawn. A grad is usually used to darken a sky that would otherwise blow to white, or at least over exposure, and make it look normal.

In practise though, the filter you want varies, according to the effect you want and the brightness of the sky. Being realistic, it is quite often defined by what you've actually got in the bag and not many folks have a full range of everything. You quickly get to know what's going to look about right and, as the author if that article also points out, the easiest way is to try it. Takes two seconds.
 
Last edited:
Why not shoot HDR and achieve the same thing without the use of filters?

Because for the most part it looks like POOH!

Only my opinion of course, grads are a must for landscape photography if you want your images to look "real", exsposure blending can work in some instanses and is pretty simple to do in PP.
 
Thanks Kev for the simple answer and I now understand the stop changes and Richard really appreciate the additional information which is very helpful when you do not have a full set of filters.
Liam.......if I asked the author your question I would not like to be around to hear his answer...LOL
Hmm...is that Donki POOH
Thanks again

Dave
 
Last edited:
Back
Top