Do I really need a 'set' of ND filters.

Messages
467
Name
Steven
Edit My Images
Yes
Do I really need a 'set' of ND filters.

Or can I get away with just one (like an ND8 / 0.9 / 3 stop).

I don't currently have any ND filters, but would like one for having a little more control with: water / clouds / bright sun / snow glare / using shallow DoF / video on DSLR.

I'd rather use screw in filters rather than a holder, and don't really want a big stopper (10stop).

Does anyone else just 'manage' with one decent ND filter (although I can't afford a vari), rather than a kit of cheap ebay ones?
I currently have Hoya pro1 CP filter - are their ND filters decent?

Thoughts / recommendations please....
 
I have an ND8 Hoya for each of my lenses as they all have different diameters. So far as I am still only intermdiate I haven't found myself needing different ones yet. I am sure over time that will change though
 
Depends what you are wanting to photograph, e.g. in landscape a gradual ND in a holder will allow you to offset a bright skyline whilst keeping the rest 'clean'. A screw-in won't do this as it will affect everything in the pic.
 
I wasn't really thinking of graduated ND - just plain old ND. I guess that if I wanted to recreate the graduated ND look, I could slap the ND on and fix in post (LR), especially if I use exposure bracketing (and the landscape is stationary).
 
Wildman has an ND8 for each lens diameter?, why when with a holder you simply buy the appropriate adapter ring. For slow water etc a std ND filter is fine, for holding back a sky etc a grad is good.
 
Wildman has an ND8 for each lens diameter?, why when with a holder you simply buy the appropriate adapter ring. For slow water etc a std ND filter is fine, for holding back a sky etc a grad is good.

Yes, I made the novice mistake of false economy !! :(

When I started out with photography I wasn't sure if it was something I would continue. Turns out now that it is. So over the last 18 months I went from my A200 with only the kit lens, to having a 50 f1.8 and a sigma 70-300. Each of those has a different diameter. I am also eyeing up a Tokina 11-16mm.

So now I think its time to get a different filter system such as cokin or Lee where I can just slide the filters in as I need them. I think that as I am now serious about keeping photography up as my full time hobby its worth investing in decent kit.
 
Depends if you want to try and get the results in the camera or you like post processing.

I have just bought he cokin p holder which works with kit lens and wider lenses and you buy n adapter for whichever lens you are using. Then bought a set of 3 hi-tech Nd filters for 30 pounds.

The Cokin system allows you to stack 3 filters together to reduce the light further.

If you search in eBay you can get holders and filter sets together to save money.

Kal
 
I'd rather use screw in filters rather than a holder, and don't really want a big stopper (10stop).

I was thinking about getting a 77mm filter as all my lenses are less than this.

Also, I was asking about a single filter, so that I'm not lugging stacks of gear.

I am aware of the benefits of a holder / set but I was hoping someone could say 'I have an nd8 from brand X and find it great - its about £30/40'.
 
aeronic said:
I am aware of the benefits of a holder / set but I was hoping someone could say 'I have an nd8 from brand X and find it great - its about £30/40'.

I did see a screw in variable Nd filter being sold by jessops or amazon where you could change the slider to increase the intensity. Not sure what they are like but think hey were around 40 pounds.
 
I did see a screw in variable Nd filter being sold by jessops or amazon where you could change the slider to increase the intensity. Not sure what they are like but think hey were around 40 pounds.

If you have a circular polariser already, buy a linear polariser to put on the front and you can have your own VND filter for under a tenner.
 
I could, but it's only a 67mm CPL, and I do anticipate getting a 15-85mm canon soon, which has a 72mm thread.

In addition, it messes with autofocus, which will be tricky, as the viewfinder on my canon 550d is quite small - and I dont like LV x10 focusing.
 
Last edited:
This is a really fun argument, there are those that fall in the camp of no do it in processing and there are those like me that fall into the yes camp :thumbs: an ND grad can be a very useful tool :thumbs: and I don't think that it can every be fully recreated in PP :shake:

Matt
MWHCVT
 
The problem with not using a grad for a bright sky is that it is then impossible very difficult to take a single shot where there is say a 3 stop difference between sky and foreground. Which then means taking at least 2 bracketed shots (one for the sky, one for foreground), then blending, and adjusting in post, which not all people want to do.
With an ND grad it is easier to do with a single shot. Of course then you get into the realms of which grad to use, depending on the exposure difference between sky and foreground, so a set becomes necessary so all bases are covered.
I just got myself a Lee holder, and a set of 6 NDs. 3 are grads, and 3 are straight NDs.
 
Last edited:
And which filters do you find you use the most? I would imagine that the 1stop gets used very infrequently.
 
And which filters do you find you use the most? I would imagine that the 1stop gets used very infrequently.

Of my grads I would say that the most used is the 3 stop soft grad :thumbs:
 
Plan ND? Nope. Unless you want smooth water etc so use a 9 stop or higher.

ND Grads? Double no. Do it in RAW processing or layers.

PPing the effect of a grad is only good if the dynamic range of the shot is less than the limit of your camera. Try doing it with a really dark foreground and a really bright sky and you'll either block the shadows or blow the highlights.

Similarly using layers is only good if nothing has changed between shots. Try doing it with a moving scene like a seascape or with trees blowing in a wind and you'll soon wish you'd done it in camera with grads.
 
MWHCVT said:
This is a really fun argument, there are those that fall in the camp of no do it in processing and there are those like me that fall into the yes camp :thumbs: an ND grad can be a very useful tool :thumbs: and I don't think that it can every be fully recreated in PP :shake:

Matt
MWHCVT

I'm kind of sat on the fence here, I used be be firmly in the fix it in Lightroom camp, but have got better results using filters.

I just have one grad and one solid ND filter, on the basis that tweaking my a stop either way in Lightroom is much easier than 3 stops.
 
PPing the effect of a grad is only good if the dynamic range of the shot is less than the limit of your camera. Try doing it with a really dark foreground and a really bright sky and you'll either block the shadows or blow the highlights.

The sky is usually within a few stops so easy in post. Layers are fine for that even moving shots - the massive problem with hardware grad filters if they ignore things sticking above the horizon line like trees, mountains, buildings etc creating the odd look. They're only handy on flat horizons.
 
The sky is usually within a few stops so easy in post. Layers are fine for that even moving shots - the massive problem with hardware grad filters if they ignore things sticking above the horizon line like trees, mountains, buildings etc creating the odd look. They're only handy on flat horizons.

I disagree, try going to Scotland or the North Yorkshire Moors where the heather is really dark, and now throw a bright cloudy sky into the mix, the dynamic range will be much more than a dSLR can manage. I know, I live on the edge of the NY Moors.

Also I use hard grads on all sorts, if something intrudes in to the grad you can always brighten it up a little in PP.

Trust me, if I could have avoided using filters I would have saved the best part of £1000 I've spent on them (Lee hard 1,2,3, Lee soft 1,2,3, CPLs, Big Stopper, wide angle adaptors, Hitech reverse grad etc etc) but the alternative is second best
 
Ive got completely the opposite. Haven't touched a single filter (other than CPL and 10 stop which i agree cant be done in post) in years as for every single shot ive taken ive found doing it in post has been faster, more accurate, far more flexible (in that i can choose). 90% of the time its a ND grad in software, occasionally its PS for layers. Im well aware what heather and moors look like - i live in one!
Ive not found a scene yet that wasnt better done in software than at the time. Maybe i will but after 3 years im seriously doubting i will. Each to his own i guess.
 
Im just getting into landscape and bought a cokin P series set of filters, they work fine and much better than circular ones . You can also do HDR with no filters. Take a load of shots on a tripod at different exposures for land sky etc (changing only the shutter speed NOT the aperture) and use photoshop to blend them together in HDR ( High Dynamic Range ) if you dont over do it you get nice realistic images.
 
Back
Top