Does my lens have a focusing issue? (EFS 15-85mm)

Messages
9
Name
Craig
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi all.

I recently purchased a lens off eBay to use on my Canon 60D - an EFS 15-85mm - and I've been on a few outings now where I just felt that the lens wasn't as sharp as I thought it would be. Using autofocus with the lens seems to be a little hit-and-miss in that sometimes I get OK results, but mostly everything feels a bit hazy like there's Vaseline on the lens or something.

I'm very new to photography, but I've taken a series of images of a newspaper page all the way through the zoom range from the widest to narrowest apertures. I also took a few shots where I focused the camera manually (mainly at the lowest F number available at that zoom setting) to try and illustrate that the lens can deliver okay results.

Basically what I want to know from one of the experts is:

1. Am I doing something really obvious wrong?
2. Is this a defective lens?
3. If the focus is off in some way, can I adjust it within the camera and what is the best way to do this?

I've uploaded the images to my Picasa account here: https://picasaweb.google.com/102794...authkey=Gv1sRgCPT-p_Hhn4n3_AE&feat=directlink

The images I manually focused are:

IMG_1582.JPG
IMG_1584.JPG
IMG_1602.JPG
IMG_1604.JPG
IMG_1622.JPG
IMG_1639.JPG
IMG_1657.JPG

Thanks,
Craig
 
If you stop down too far you end up with diffraction making the image a little soft. What exposure details, ie shutter speed and were you using a tripod, all these things can affect the quality of your image. I use the 15-85 on my 7D and it's a cracking lens.
 
If you stop down too far you end up with diffraction making the image a little soft. What exposure details, ie shutter speed and were you using a tripod, all these things can affect the quality of your image. I use the 15-85 on my 7D and it's a cracking lens.

Hi. I used a tripod for all the images taken and there was also a 2 second delay from me pressing the shutter to the image being taken to reduce the shake further. I had the camera set to aperture priority so shutter in all instances was determined by the camera and varied from 1/40 sec to 2.5 sec.
 
I think the first image illustrates my issue the best:



The top one is autofocus and the bottom one I focused manually - same environment, taken seconds apart.
 
Clearly the top image is less sharp, but they're not a straight comparison. Focal lengths are different for a start, and exposures.

You need to do a properly controlled focus test. Lots of threads on this, but start with something like this as a target. Focus on the flat face of the box, square to the camera, lowest f/number - say 50mm from 2m distance. Then see on the ruler where the focus has actually landed.

IMG_3381-1.jpg
 
Clearly the top image is less sharp, but they're not a straight comparison. Focal lengths are different for a start, and exposures.

You need to do a properly controlled focus test. Lots of threads on this, but start with something like this as a target. Focus on the flat face of the box, square to the camera, lowest f/number - say 50mm from 2m distance. Then see on the ruler where the focus has actually landed.

IMG_3381-1.jpg

Hi, the images were both taken @ 15mm / f4.0 and the sharper one has a shutter speed of 1/25th versus 1/30th on the other. They're basically as identical as I could make them.

Thanks for the image above, it was useful to know how others do it (as mentioned previously I'm somewhat of a newbie).

I've done some tests (from approx 2M away - all on a tripod) going from 15 - 85mm and all at the lowest possible f-stop. In all instances the center metering spot flashed red to indicate that the center of the image should have been in focus (clearly in some of the images it isnt): https://picasaweb.google.com/102794...&authkey=Gv1sRgCKikzOKm6uf-Jw&feat=directlink

Also - the front of the box sits at the 26cm mark on the ruler.
 
Last edited:
the images of the newspaper...I would have put money on them being different apertures and this was affecting the sharpness
if both are at f/4 then it could be focusing calibration
I had this problem with a sigma lens, it would front focus or something
you can have it recalibrated or just go into the menu system and calibrate it in your camera, I think the 60D can do this.
to test it out, use this chart/instructions, page 18. http://focustestchart.com/focus21.pdf

edit ( bah, it can't)
well test using the chart and if required, have it recalibrated at a service centre
 
Last edited:
Hi, the images were both taken @ 15mm / f4.0 and the sharper one has a shutter speed of 1/25th versus 1/30th on the other. They're basically as identical as I could make them.

No they weren't. You've got them mixed up somehow. First shot might have been at 15mm, but the second one is longer - look at the barrel distortion on the first one, that's typical wide-angle.

Thanks for the image above, it was useful to know how others do it (as mentioned previously I'm somewhat of a newbie).

I've done some tests (from approx 2M away - all on a tripod) going from 15 - 85mm and all at the lowest possible f-stop. In all instances the center metering spot flashed red to indicate that the center of the image should have been in focus (clearly in some of the images it isnt): https://picasaweb.google.com/102794...&authkey=Gv1sRgCKikzOKm6uf-Jw&feat=directlink

Also - the front of the box sits at the 26cm mark on the ruler.

That's the idea, but you're not properly square to the box and I can't read the ruler clearly though it looks to be in the zone. One with clearer markings will make things easier. Ruler should be right close to the edge of the box (in case of field curvature). If you're being critical, it's got to be accurate.

BTW, do not use that test chart linked above. It will lead you astray. And don't be tempted to move too close to the target in order top see the focus on the ruler more clearly. You need to shoot at a typical distance, and something like 2m with 50mm focal length is about right for say a portrait, ie typical.
 
No they weren't. You've got them mixed up somehow. First shot might have been at 15mm, but the second one is longer - look at the barrel distortion on the first one, that's typical wide-angle.



That's the idea, but you're not properly square to the box and I can't read the ruler clearly though it looks to be in the zone. One with clearer markings will make things easier. Ruler should be right close to the edge of the box (in case of field curvature). If you're being critical, it's got to be accurate.

BTW, do not use that test chart linked above. It will lead you astray. And don't be tempted to move too close to the target in order top see the focus on the ruler more clearly. You need to shoot at a typical distance, and something like 2m with 50mm focal length is about right for say a portrait, ie typical.

Hi,

Yeah you're correct - I uploaded the wrong images side-by-side :-) I've amended that and uploaded a correct comparison here:



I only have one ruler I'm afraid, but I've done some more snaps with the ruler on the other side to show the inch markers (which are further apart) - I hope this makes it easier to see. The box is level with the 10inch mark. I've also tried to get everything straighter and stuck to the 50mm shots.



 
Looks like it's front focusing. Does that tally with your real world pics?

I don't think the 60D has AF microadjustment, so it's a back to Canon job. Do you have any other lenses? If they're also front focusing, then it's likely the camera is the problem and Canon may need that too.

I'd email Canon Elstree, attaching a couple of sample pics, and take their advice.
 
Looks like it's front focusing. Does that tally with your real world pics?

I don't think the 60D has AF microadjustment, so it's a back to Canon job. Do you have any other lenses? If they're also front focusing, then it's likely the camera is the problem and Canon may need that too.

I'd email Canon Elstree, attaching a couple of sample pics, and take their advice.

Hi - Is there any defitive way to tell from these pictures?



The top one is the 15-85mm EFS lens @ 50mm, the bottom one is the kit 18-55mm lens @ 46mm (I tried to get it around 50). Both images were taken seconds apart to keep the environment as similar as possible.
 
Hi - Is there any defitive way to tell from these pictures?

<snip>

The top one is the 15-85mm EFS lens @ 50mm, the bottom one is the kit 18-55mm lens @ 46mm (I tried to get it around 50). Both images were taken seconds apart to keep the environment as similar as possible.

This is a new set, yes? You've moved the ruler. In which case, if the camera is focused on the box, then it's front focusing. Sharpest point is clearly around the 10in mark on the ruler, both pics.

The fact that it's two lenses doing the same thing suggests it's the camera that's out of whack.
 
Download this http://www.scribd.com/doc/266756/Camera-Focus-Test-Chart ......Read it...Read it again and Read it once more until you fully understand it.
Print of the chart and do exactly as it tells you.
Dont do 15mm or 46mm,,,,,Do 85mm Only. 15mm is too wide for a good reading and its doubtful it will be worse at 15mm than it is at 85mm.
When you take a reading its 10 second delay...not 2 and get a very bright room.
You want wide open only. Take 5 pictures and select the best of them and post the results.
None of the pictures you have posted are bad once pp has been done on them. They are all acceptably sharp.
If you want pin sharp out the camera wide open then go buy a few £1,500 primes and a MK4 with a AF that locks on like a missile.
 
Download this http://www.scribd.com/doc/266756/Camera-Focus-Test-Chart ......Read it...Read it again and Read it once more until you fully understand it.
Print of the chart and do exactly as it tells you.

No, don't. There are all sorts of problems with that test. What could be easier, and absolutely reliable, than the test the OP has just done?

Dont do 15mm or 46mm,,,,,Do 85mm Only. 15mm is too wide for a good reading and its doubtful it will be worse at 15mm than it is at 85mm.
When you take a reading its 10 second delay...not 2 and get a very bright room.
You want wide open only. Take 5 pictures and select the best of them and post the results.
None of the pictures you have posted are bad once pp has been done on them. They are all acceptably sharp.
If you want pin sharp out the camera wide open then go buy a few £1,500 primes and a MK4 with a AF that locks on like a missile.

Which pictures are you looking at? They're nowhere near acceptable, and nowhere near what the camera is capable of. And that level of mis-focus is not rescuable in post processing.

Even the Lynx effect won't save them.
 
Last edited:
I've done one additional test after doing a bit of reading - I've also taken RAW images in the hope that they might be useful too.

If you go here: https://www.dropbox.com/sh/pq7081bqpo5xxi6/Gfzd-AEu9u?lst I've uploaded a series of 6 images.

The first 3 were taken with the 15-85mm lens @ 50mm in Auto Focus, Live View, and Manual

The second 3 were taken with the 17-55mm lens @ 50mm in Auto Focus, Live View and Manual

To me it looks as if the live view mode is focusing better, but I would do with an experts opinion on this matter.

Edit: I forgot to add - HoppyUK: yeah, I had to recompose the scene, so the ruler sits on the box at the 13 inch mark.
 
Last edited:
I've done one additional test after doing a bit of reading - I've also taken RAW images in the hope that they might be useful too.

If you go here: https://www.dropbox.com/sh/pq7081bqpo5xxi6/Gfzd-AEu9u?lst I've uploaded a series of 6 images.

The first 3 were taken with the 15-85mm lens @ 50mm in Auto Focus, Live View, and Manual

The second 3 were taken with the 17-55mm lens @ 50mm in Auto Focus, Live View and Manual

To me it looks as if the live view mode is focusing better, but I would do with an experts opinion on this matter.

Edit: I forgot to add - HoppyUK: yeah, I had to recompose the scene, so the ruler sits on the box at the 13 inch mark.

1) front focused, 2) okay, 3) front focused.

4) okay, 5) okay, 6) front focused.

Live view should always be 100%, completely different AF system that should be cock-on unless a trick of the light fools it. How are you manual focusing, in live view (should be relaible if you use max magnification) or through the viewfinder (which is frankly hopeless for this kind of thing)?

How many more standard range zooms have you got?! It's looking from that (and assuming you'e not mixed anything up ;)) that the 17-55 is okay. It's possible you've got some inconsistency going on* but not to anything like the degree of error you've shown.

* shoot a series with the same lens, same everything etc, defocusing between shots.
 
1) front focused, 2) okay, 3) front focused.

4) okay, 5) okay, 6) front focused.

Live view should always be 100%, completely different AF system that should be cock-on unless a trick of the light fools it. How are you manual focusing, in live view (should be relaible if you use max magnification) or through the viewfinder (which is frankly hopeless for this kind of thing)?

How many more standard range zooms have you got?! It's looking from that (and assuming you'e not mixed anything up ;)) that the 17-55 is okay. It's possible you've got some inconsistency going on* but not to anything like the degree of error you've shown.

* shoot a series with the same lens, same everything etc, defocusing between shots.

The only live-view shot was the second shot from each group of three. The first shot was using 'one-shot' AF with the central AF point chosen as the focus point. The second was live-view and the third shot was MF with me looking through the viewfinder and attempting to focus manually.

From what you stated above then, do you believe that it's more likely that the 15-85 lens is a little faulty?
 
The only live-view shot was the second shot from each group of three. The first shot was using 'one-shot' AF with the central AF point chosen as the focus point. The second was live-view and the third shot was MF with me looking through the viewfinder and attempting to focus manually.

From what you stated above then, do you believe that it's more likely that the 15-85 lens is a little faulty?

Possibly. If I've understood it right, the 15-85 is front focusing, so is the kit zoom, but the 17-55 is okay.

Personally, I'd send them all back and just swallow the bill - but it would all be properbly sorted.

Maybe if the 15-85 is duff (maybe that's why it was on e-bay) and you're not worried about the kit lens, just get that fixed. But if the body is out for some reason you'll be back at square one - was everything okay before the 15-85 arrived?
 
Possibly. If I've understood it right, the 15-85 is front focusing, so is the kit zoom, but the 17-55 is okay.

Personally, I'd send them all back and just swallow the bill - but it would all be properbly sorted.

Maybe if the 15-85 is duff (maybe that's why it was on e-bay) and you're not worried about the kit lens, just get that fixed. But if the body is out for some reason you'll be back at square one - was everything okay before the 15-85 arrived?

I only own 2 lenses and the kit lens is the 17-55mm. I bought the 15-85mm as a straight replacement for the kit lens. Based on your suggestion above I've done 10 more test shots with the 15-85mm lens @ 50mm. The first 5 are autofocus shots and after each shot I've defocused the camera. The second set of 5 are live-view and again after each shot I've defocused the camera.

https://www.dropbox.com/sh/pq7081bqpo5xxi6/Gfzd-AEu9u?lst they're in a sub-folder of this share called '10 more'
 
I only own 2 lenses and the kit lens is the 17-55mm. I bought the 15-85mm as a straight replacement for the kit lens. Based on your suggestion above I've done 10 more test shots with the 15-85mm lens @ 50mm. The first 5 are autofocus shots and after each shot I've defocused the camera. The second set of 5 are live-view and again after each shot I've defocused the camera.

https://www.dropbox.com/sh/pq7081bqpo5xxi6/Gfzd-AEu9u?lst they're in a sub-folder of this share called '10 more'

I haven't looked at them all. It's easy enough to see where optimum sharpness is, and where it should be. All we can say with certainty from this is that your camera with the 15-85 is front focusing with normal AF. Live view and manual is irrelevant here.

Why not sent that to Canon, with the evidence, and see what they say? If they come back with it's okay, then send them the camera too.

BTW 18-55 is the kit zoom, 17-55 is an entirely different animal ;)
 
Back
Top