DOF: Aperture vs Manual Focusing

49487

Suspended / Banned
Messages
80
Edit My Images
No
I consider myself quite intermediate in Photography, I generally know most of the techniques and usage of manual and use it 24/7 however there's one thing that always confused me.

Bokeh.

I presume we all know what Bokeh is, so I'll skip the explanation. However, I'm confused about DOF and Bokeh. I know that setting a wide Aperture and zooming in (Or not, if it's prime) causes a shallow depth of field and bokeh. However, it seems to me that simple manual focusing causes the exact same effect.
Whilst playing on a DSLR in a camera store, I turned the focusing ring until just the foreground was in sharp focus and achieved bokeh and a shallow depth of field using a leaflet as a subject. Without sounding like a noob, why do people use Aperture to create bokeh and DOF when manual focusing does it instantly? Or is that not quite right?
 
did you try auto focusing on the exact same area? It'd give you the same result.

Yes, you're right. So does merely focusing on an object give the same DoF effect as a wide aperture?
 
The depth of field is caused by two things. Aperture and MAGNIGICATION. Manual focus has nothing to do with DoF.

The magnification is what is causing this. With a your prime your feet are the zoom.

So if you are shooting a subject close to you with a wide aperture you will have a shallow DoF.

Bare in mind that the distance from the subject to the background also differs the look of the DoF. If you shoot your subject with say a wall 2' behind them, the wall will likely look fairly sharp and the bokeh will be pretty much non existant. Now stand on the edge of a football pitch with a long distance from subject to background and with the exact same camera settings, same magnification, the background will be much more blurred and you'll see the bokeh effect.

Not sure what lens you were using or what aperture or magnification but manual focus should not affect the DoF if it's focusing on the same point as you were with AF.
 
Last edited:
Yes, you're right. So does merely focusing on an object give the same DoF effect as a wide aperture?

? Focus and aperture are two different things.
 
Depth of field SHALLOWs (reates more bokeh in the background) for two reasons

1. Closeness of the subject to the film plane. The closer the subject the shallower the depth of field

2. The aperture in use.

So, take your focussing distance to your leaflet and set the camera on a tripod and get it all focussed and how you want it. look at the bokeh at f2 and then stop down to f22 and compare....all the aperture settings in between will create a gradual transition from the one extreme (f2) to the other (f22)

The bokeh you experienced was down to the focus distance, for that lens, nothing else. If you had taken 5 steps backwards using the same lens at the same wide open aperture, but altered the focussing distance (distance between sharp subject and film plane) the bokeh would have changed and you would have seen less background blur compared to the close focus version.


The same change is found going from telephoto lens to wide angle, you get more critical focus and less depth of field with a telephoto than with a wide angle, whether you use the same focus distance, or the same subject size, the wide angle will produce less out of focus background due to the greater inherent depth of field.

It is nothing to do with manual focussing. It is all to do with focal length and focus distance and aperture. The longer the focal length, the closer the focussing distance or the wider the aperture, the greater the bokeh.
 
Not sure if I understand but were you judging the DoF by what you could see through the viewfinder?
Most, (if not all?) cameras focus with the aperture wide open so what you see through the viewfinder or on the screen has a small DoF but is nice and bright. The aperture only closes down when you take the picture although some cameras have a DoF preview button which closes the aperture down to its setting and you can see what actual DoF you will be getting.
 
The wider the aperture the shallower the depth of field around what you are shooting.
If you keep the same aperture:
Making the subject larger in the frame either by zooming in or moving the camera closer will make the DoF smaller. If you get very close the DoF is very thin. Moving the camera further back or zooming out will give a larger DoF.

Focussing on something will set where the DoF is centered*, how much is in focus is related to the focal length and distance to subject.
Longer focal lengths have a narrower field (angle) of view so there is a smaller section of backgound in the shot. Less background has less detail to fit in so it looks more blurry. Also increasing the distance from your subject to the background will make it more out of focus.

(*not exactly, it extends further behind than it does forward.)

ETA: Missed a couple of posts while typing this, but Suvv may have it. Lenses using fully open apertures to help focus will have a shallow DoF through the viewfinder.
 
Last edited:
Suvv said:
Not sure if I understand but were you judging the DoF by what you could see through the viewfinder?
Most, (if not all?) cameras focus with the aperture wide open so what you see through the viewfinder or on the screen has a small DoF but is nice and bright. The aperture only closes down when you take the picture although some cameras have a DoF preview button which closes the aperture down to its setting and you can see what actual DoF you will be getting.

That may be the answer I was looking for. Thanks. :D
 
Back
Top