Dull day flat images

Messages
1,675
Name
Chris
Edit My Images
No
I took a few shots in my lunch today and they are all rather flat looking. I am guessing this is mainly down to the cloud cover (sunny now of course....) Is there anything I can do when shooting to improve things or is it just as case of adding some contrast and colour back in in PP?

Example:
DSC_00014.JPG


I've installed NX view and done rough contrast boost to something like what I'd like.
DSC_0001_001.JPG


I know isn't the greatest shot but they pretty much all sucked today. :'(
 
A little diffused fill flash would help - otherwise just what you've done in PP
 
Okay then, I'll try sticking the flash on next time. Am I better off aiming it right at the subject or up (with a soften copy on in both cases).
 
Nothing to bounce from outdoors - so aimed at the subject - possibly take it off camera for more interest/texture/shadows.
 
If you want contrast then you want hard light striking across your subject/scene, much like the sun. Contrast is caused because you get highlights and shadows. If the shadows vanish the contrast drops. If the highlights vanish too then you will get flat images.

Adding on camera flash won't really help much. It will fill in what might have been shadowy holes and furrows in the textres of the scene, which is kind of counter-productive. Consider a full moon. That a bit like lighting the scene from the camera position, as though on camera. You can't make out texture in the surface at all. It is evenly lit and rather a dull image. That's with hard light - a small light source relative to the distances involved and very directional. Now think of a partially lit moon, with the sun lighting it from one side. Suddenly the texture of the craters appears as shadows form in and behind craters and highlights reflect off the edges.

20090812_003105_1552_LR.jpg


The bit that has the most visible contrast and texture is the part where the sun is glancing across the surface relative to the camera position. The fully lit, shadowless part has barely discernable features.

When you have dull, grey, cloudy days the light is coming from all around. It fills in every nook and cranny. There are no shadows. There are no specular highlights. It is the softest natural light imaginable - the cloud cover is a giant softbox.

So, if you want to add punch then add hard light from the side, i.e. off camera flash. However, because of the inverse square law and the rate of light falloff with increasing distance you'll have a problem lighting a large scene like that, and even more of a problem lighting it evenly. One little flash gun doesn't quite have the power of that big ball of fire above us.

I think you've done a good job at pepping the scene up with your edit, but I think that if you want to avoid doing that you will need nature to provide the right sort of light. That means choosing your day, time, shooting direction and weather carefully. If the light is not right you won't get the shot you want.
 
So realistically other than showing up with a ton of lighting there isn't a huge amount I can do other than wait for a gap in the cloud cover. A flash could help if I am shooting a small area but probably still not going to be enough.
 
Well that's my view. Others might have different ideas, but there is a reason landscape photographers go out at crazy times of day and wait for the weather, season, light to be right. Portrait photographers can put a great deal of effort into lighting their subjects to achieve the appearance they want. Ditto product photographers, auto photographers, architectural photographers and so on. Sports photographers and journos are more likely to have to make do with what circumstance provides, but if it is your intention to make beautiful images then you might need to create or wait for the right light. At the end of the day light is what the camera records. If the light is not right then you may not get the image you want.
 
Last edited:
Went out again today with a bit of sun and the images are far better :thumbs:

Also swapped for the Tamron 55-200 f4-5.6 and between the light and the lens I have got some much better shots.

I think a new standard lens is required as the Tamron always seems to give nicer results.
 
Back
Top