Feedback needed for our Friendly Competition

S

Sybersteve

Messages
211
Name
Stephen
Edit My Images
No
We need your input. Three dudes working together want to keep their enthusiasm for photography high by having a friendly competition amongst ourselves, but need feedback from you guys as to who has submitted the most pleasing photo for a range of catagories. This one being Macro.

Number 1 up for feedback is Dazman32.

url=http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/gallery/showphoto.php?photo=62028]
Dazman32_Fly.jpg
[/url]

Number 2 up for feedback is Spike

url=http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/gallery/showphoto.php?photo=62029]
Mikes_Fly.jpg
[/url]

Number 3 up for feedback is Sybersteve

url=http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/gallery/showphoto.php?photo=62035]
spider8.jpg
[/url]
Thanks in advance for your comments
 
All three shots are pleasing, but I would have to say that #2 with the subject standing out of the OOF background and foreground works really well and just gives the shot that something extra.
 
no 2 for me. good focus, well lit and nice DOF.

no3 2nd. i like spider shots but this lost out due to the angle. a bit lower to see its face more would have been nice.

3rd would be no1. lovely sharpness and focus, but blends a little too well with the background for me. the colours are a little dull for my tastes as well:)

all three are nice shots and i would be happy with any. so well done and congrats, look forward to seeing more from your comp
 
2 would be for me as well, then 3 and 1 Keep it going (y)
 
number 1 - lacks depth and ambience, almost 2d - 3 stars

number 2 - spikes picture - 1 star

number 3 - thinks sybersteve needs to clean his shed out more often so these little critters dont reproduce, but overall a nice picture - 2 stars

winner for me picture 1
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top