Filters am I wasting my money?

Messages
1,241
Name
Bal Sanghera
Edit My Images
Yes
I have been looking at some filters and came across the Hoya 77mm Pro1 Digital ND16 Filter.

I have started to a lot more outdoor work but skies are always blown, there seem to be so much out there not really sure where to begin without just simply wasting my money.

Any advice?
 
I have been looking at some filters and came across the Hoya 77mm Pro1 Digital ND16 Filter.

I have started to a lot more outdoor work but skies are always blown, there seem to be so much out there not really sure where to begin without just simply wasting my money.

Any advice?

to reduce the exposure of the sky you need a graduated filter

the top half is dark grey [ doesn't affect the colour], gradually reducing to clear at the bottom

so the sky is 'held-back' whilst foreground is correctly exposed

grads are 'soft' transition for landscapes
or 'hard' transition for seascapes....though i use 'soft' for both

have a look through the Cokin web-site....................:D
 
I've never heard of an ND16 filter before, although I have an ND8 myself, but it won't help with blown out skies. It will simply darken everything - foreground and skies equally. You can do that without a filter by raising shutter speed, narrowing aperture or lowering ISO. A plain ND filter is good for allowing you to shoot at slower shutter speeds, to increase the blur effect of motion or to allow you to hit flash sync speed at wide apertures in bright conditions. It won't correct an imbalance of brightness between different parts of the scene.

What you need is a GRADUATED ND filter, which will allow you to apply darkening to the sky region while leaving the foreground untouched. The best solution will be square filters and a filter holder, which will allow you to position the graduated portion of the filter exactly where you need it within the frame.

Other options are to shoot HDR and combine exposures, to avoid shooting towards bright skies in the first place or to expose for the sky and then raise the foreground exposure in post. If you shoot at low ISO then you can probably apply this last technique without noise becoming too offensive. If you shoot raw it will give you more latitude to recover highlights and push shadows than JPEG.
 
you will need

an adapter plate same thread as your lens [77mm.?] which screws into the lens

a holder which slides onto the adapter
if you have a wide-angle lens - get the WA holder which has only one filter slot
the usual holder has 3 slots but this can be seen in a WA lens

a square ND Grad filter which slips into the holder
it can be slid up and down to match the grad line with the horizon
 
Welding glass is closer to 13 or 14 stop, hence why a simple 4 stop isn't anything unusual. I think the multiple ways of expressing the power of a filter (0.3, 0.6; ND2, ND4; 1-stop, 2-stop) gets folk confused.

However the OPs problem is simple.. it's the wrong type of filter, rather than the wrong strength..
 
Ive used all 3 techniques as mention ed above (a) graduated filters (b) HDR and (c) brightening the foreground in post production.

Id suggest (a) is probably the best fix as it is captured in camera and saves time in post production. HDR has its place too (although I know lots of people dont really like it as it can give a certain fee to a picture).
 
boccers_2000 said:
Ive used all 3 techniques as mention ed above (a) graduated filters (b) HDR and (c) brightening the foreground in post production.

Id suggest (a) is probably the best fix as it is captured in camera and saves time in post production. HDR has its place too (although I know lots of people dont really like it as it can give a certain fee to a picture).

If you use Lightroom and shoot raw you can use the 'software' graduated filter up to about 2 stops. It works really well and I don't bother with grads anymore but I'm not primarily a landscape photographer, if you want to be then grads might be something to look into.
 
It's nice to do things in-camera with grads, somehow purer and more 'photographic' but there's no doubt that using software gives better results. And it's free, much quicker, and more versatile.

Problem with grads is that unless you shoot seascapes all the time, there's usually something that sticks above the skyline - tree, building, church spire - and that gets darkened along with the sky. I hate that.

HDR only looks naff when you overdo it.
 
I think I will be giving grads a miss but look at getting a polariser and see how it improves my outdoor shoots.
 
I think I will be giving grads a miss but look at getting a polariser and see how it improves my outdoor shoots.

I love my polariser, gives a very "top gear" style shot in clear skys with the darker blues to the top, like the edge of space or somthing

Not that good of an example, but you get the idea, doesn't vignette with the new lens too :D

155034_472963672720_657987720_6146193_3875371_n.jpg
 
I was going to suggest a polariser as well, though they have less of an effect on cloudy days (maybe a good thing)
 
Back
Top