- Messages
- 247
- Name
- Barnaby Jaco Skinner
- Edit My Images
- No
Just checking I understand it right... anything I get wrong please correct me 
So if I bought a 17-55mm DX lens for a D7000 and a 17-55mm FX lens for a D700 and compared them next to each other, say one eye in the D7000 and the other eye in the D700, apart from looking like a moron they would not match. To make them match I would need to buy a 25.5-82.5mm FX lens for my D700, then the focal lengths would match and it would be like looking through odd shaped binoculars. This is because the DX sensor is physically smaller than the FX sensor and creates what's known as 'crop factor'.
This 'crop factor', although created by the sensor and not the lens, suggests that all DX lenses on DX bodies do not actually produce the focal length they advertise, instead it's (displayed focal length) X (crop factor)?
This in-turn suggests that the smaller the physical size of the sensor the greater the 'crop factor' when used with the same focal length... which might help to explain how Nikon can squeeze over 800mm out of the new Coolpix lens?
Finally, if I put the 17-55mm DX lens on my 12MP FX body it would truly give me a 17-55mm focal length BUT because the DX lens' rear element hole is smaller than that of an identical-in-focal-length FX lens it would only use half the FX sensor therefore produce a 6MP picture?
Why don't Nikon put the converted focal length on the DX lens rather than the cropped FX equivilent? Seems a little more logical even if not technically correct. :bang:
Thanks for your brain cells, it's been emotional
So if I bought a 17-55mm DX lens for a D7000 and a 17-55mm FX lens for a D700 and compared them next to each other, say one eye in the D7000 and the other eye in the D700, apart from looking like a moron they would not match. To make them match I would need to buy a 25.5-82.5mm FX lens for my D700, then the focal lengths would match and it would be like looking through odd shaped binoculars. This is because the DX sensor is physically smaller than the FX sensor and creates what's known as 'crop factor'.
This 'crop factor', although created by the sensor and not the lens, suggests that all DX lenses on DX bodies do not actually produce the focal length they advertise, instead it's (displayed focal length) X (crop factor)?
This in-turn suggests that the smaller the physical size of the sensor the greater the 'crop factor' when used with the same focal length... which might help to explain how Nikon can squeeze over 800mm out of the new Coolpix lens?
Finally, if I put the 17-55mm DX lens on my 12MP FX body it would truly give me a 17-55mm focal length BUT because the DX lens' rear element hole is smaller than that of an identical-in-focal-length FX lens it would only use half the FX sensor therefore produce a 6MP picture?
Why don't Nikon put the converted focal length on the DX lens rather than the cropped FX equivilent? Seems a little more logical even if not technically correct. :bang:
Thanks for your brain cells, it's been emotional
Last edited:
