Found some of my images on a website.

Messages
3,163
Edit My Images
Yes
I was doing a quick reverse google image search and found a website using 5 of my images (4 are still up, the other shows up in the search results but I can't see it on the site).

What should I do, if anything?

Here is the site, and here is my Flickr. The images in question are Initialled Epitaph (mono), Wooden Stare, Llywelyn's Light, Eyes Front and the one I can't see on there despite showing in the search results, Gwyl Y Felinheli Festival 2011.
 
First thing to do is take screen grabs. BUT what recourse you have depends entirely on what you signed up to on flickr. If you have put them in an open to the public section, then you will have a battle to get anything done other than them removed.

If you had them marked as copyright on flickr, then you can invoice them, after you have writen to them and thanked them for selecting your pictures for inclusion. You cannot charge a huge amount, but why should they get work for free? Everyone else gets paid, even the window cleaner, so why not the photographer?

Good luck.
 
what did you want to do... we have no idea what you signed up to on flickthingy ... they seem to be linking back as required.. whats the problem ?
 
Thanks lensflare, they were my initial feelings too.

what did you want to do... we have no idea what you signed up to on flickthingy ... they seem to be linking back as required.. whats the problem ?

As far as I know, I have retained full copyright for the images I have posted on Flickr (I have checked, apparently all my images are "all rights reserved". Additionally, the images include a "cGJones" watermark which is clearly visible.). You'll have to explain the rest of your post as I'm afraid you've lost me! Are you saying that because on that site, in addition to my images, there is a "view image on Flickr" link (pointing to the original images on my flickr), that it's ok? That seems a bit poor.

What I want, in a nutshell, is for people (especially commercial websites) to not be using my pictures for their own benefit without my permission.
 
Last edited:
I have been discussing this site with a fellow member recently, I'm not overly pleased at the operation of the site but it is not very different from a google image search in many respects, and we don't bill google every time out images come up in a search :shrug: though if you can find any details to contact this sites owner I would be very interested in them :thumbs:

Matt
MWHCVT
 
The site might be using the Flickr API to search for and display images. You can change your image permissions in your preferences on Flickr to exclude them from sites using the Flickr API.
 
Thanks lensflare, they were my initial feelings too.



As far as I know, I have retained full copyright for the images I have posted on Flickr (I have checked, apparently all my images are "all rights reserved"). You'll have to explain the rest of your post as I'm afraid you've lost me! Are you saying that because, in addition to my image, there is a "link to the original image" (pointing to the original images on my flickr), that it's ok? That seems a bit poor.

sorry what bit of my reply did you want explaining?
 
sorry what bit of my reply did you want explaining?

Sorry, this bit "...they seem to be linking back as required.. whats the problem ?"

Does this mean I can use any image I like on my website, as long as I have a link somewhere to the original image?
 
Sorry, this bit "...they seem to be linking back as required.. whats the problem ?"

Does this mean I can use any image I like on my website, as long as I have a link somewhere to the original image?

if its hosted on flikr thats the general rule isnt it? pretty sure i ahve read on here enough times that people can grab your pics off flikr so long as they link back.... main reason why i wouldnt use such a place in a month of sundays.
 
if its hosted on flikr thats the general rule isnt it? pretty sure i ahve read on here enough times that people can grab your pics off flikr so long as they link back.... main reason why i wouldnt use such a place in a month of sundays.

That may be an unwritten rule or custom amongst some bloggers but I very much doubt it trumps the "all rights reserved" status. I could be wrong though, does anyone know for sure?

Sheesh, if you're right, I'll delete my flickr account right away!
 
Last edited:
That may be an unwritten rule or custom amongst some bloggers but I very much doubt it trumps the "all rights reserved" status. I could be wrong though, does anyone know for sure?

you didnt tell us what settings you had on flikr..
 
I mentioned it in post #4 - "all rights reserved" (hence the reference to "all rights reserved" in post #10). I believe it's the default setting, which is fair play.
 
Last edited:
8th option down in privacy and permissions, is this set to yes? Its 'Hide your stuff from public searches'.
 
I mentioned it in post #4 - "all rights reserved" (hence the reference to "all rights reserved" in post #10). I believe it's the default setting, which is fair play.

you are pulling me up on my post at #3 .. how the hell am i supposed to know in post #3 what you are going to post in #4?

:( :bang:
 
8th option down in privacy and permissions, is this set to yes? Its 'Hide your stuff from public searches'.

That's the fella, thanks - I have now set it to "yes". :)

This seems to be a worrying loophole - when is an image search not an image search?
 
you are pulling me up on my post at #3 .. how the hell am i supposed to know in post #3 what you are going to post in #4?

:( :bang:

You've lost me again, sorry! :lol: What settings do you mean?
 
Seems a few members are concerned about these search and link , we came to the conclusion it was a flickr API and works as google image search does,

Im not sure how you turn it off completely, as I have set who can share/link, but not the search exclusion method, on a free account, unless its hide from public searches, which is what I dont want as having a free account I cant find my older than 200 images, so if anyone knows Id be interested,
 
Last edited:
:lol:
 
That's the fella, thanks - I have now set it to "yes". :)

This seems to be a worrying loophole - when is an image search not an image search?

Even with it off my images are still being used with flickr back links on a site in Brazil. I can't see any point in getting het up about that though, not much chance of reparations!
 
As an example,

Here is a link from the Dundee Courier who consistently use Flickr as a source for free images in exchange for a small link back to the photographers Flickr page.

In this case the link is at the end of the report and the credit is to Stewart Lloyd-Jones

There are heaps of the images used all the time in this manner and this is one of the reasons I do not use Flickr.
 
If they're linking to your picture you could get a bit creative with it ;)

As soon as you replace a photo on Flickr, any existing links to the previous image are broken. This prevents swapping the images from under anyone's feet, unfortunately.

Despite any "all rights reserved" settings, the Flickr API doesn't prevent images being used off-site.

Either remove the images from Flickr or take it up with the third party/Flickr.
 
As soon as you replace a photo on Flickr, any existing links to the previous image are broken. This prevents swapping the images from under anyone's feet, unfortunately.

Despite any "all rights reserved" settings, the Flickr API doesn't prevent images being used off-site.

Either remove the images from Flickr or take it up with the third party/Flickr.

Yup! also if you change the privacy settings the link will be broken.
 
One question: Are you ******ed off about this or are you happy that your photography is being noticed?
 
specialman said:
One question: Are you ******ed off about this or are you happy that your photography is being noticed?

I really don't like they way that they are displaying the images :shrug: I have come across sites the put up a thumbnail and then that directly opens to flickr that I have no issue with, with this site the are showing an abysmal and distorted thumbnail that go's to a larger version of the image still on this site, this makes no reference to the copyright owner and only offers a link to the actual image on flickr below the image, but by this stage the user has seen the image so has no real reason to click to flickr, also it is far easier to steal an image from this site that it is from flickr when you have the right click disabled on flickr :)

Short answer is yes I am a little annoyed

Matt
 
One question: Are you ******ed off about this or are you happy that your photography is being noticed?

I really don't like they way that they are displaying the images :shrug: I have come across sites the put up a thumbnail and then that directly opens to flickr that I have no issue with, with this site the are showing an abysmal and distorted thumbnail that go's to a larger version of the image still on this site, this makes no reference to the copyright owner and only offers a link to the actual image on flickr below the image, but by this stage the user has seen the image so has no real reason to click to flickr, also it is far easier to steal an image from this site that it is from flickr when you have the right click disabled on flickr :)

Short answer is yes I am a little annoyed

Matt

This just about sums up how I feel too.

Plus the broader issue that because of some "API" functionality loophole, which as far as I can see was originally intended for image searches, seemingly anyone can use my Flickr images on the web for whatever purpose they wish.
 
Last edited:
I really don't like they way that they are displaying the images :shrug: I have come across sites the put up a thumbnail and then that directly opens to flickr that I have no issue with, with this site the are showing an abysmal and distorted thumbnail that go's to a larger version of the image still on this site, this makes no reference to the copyright owner and only offers a link to the actual image on flickr below the image, but by this stage the user has seen the image so has no real reason to click to flickr, also it is far easier to steal an image from this site that it is from flickr when you have the right click disabled on flickr :)

Short answer is yes I am a little annoyed

Matt

Me too Matt. the images are also accompanied with ads everywhere relating to the images, from google so basically they are making money from our images

This just about sums up how I feel too.

Plus the broader issue that because of some "API" functionality loophole, which as far as I can see was originally intended for image searches, seemingly anyone can use my Flickr images on the web for whatever purpose they wish.

Looks that way :bang:
 
From what I understood the image itself had to link back to Flickr, not a seperate link below the image :shrug:

Paul
 
Matt - I was actually asking the OP :)

OP - so you're narked? Then you know at least one course of action is to get in touch and demand they withdraw your work from the site. As for charging them, then that's something you decide whether it's worth chasing up, but is it going to be more hassle than its worth?
 
specialman said:
Matt - I was actually asking the OP :)

OP - so you're narked? Then you know at least one course of action is to get in touch and demand they withdraw your work from the site. As for charging them, then that's something you decide whether it's worth chasing up, but is it going to be more hassle than its worth?

Fair enough Pat :)
 
That's the fella, thanks - I have now set it to "yes". :)

This seems to be a worrying loophole - when is an image search not an image search?

It's not a loop hole. See my previous post.
 
It's not a loop hole. See my previous post.

I did see your post and thought I understood it. As I see it, there is a big difference between making an image searchable/findable and agreeing to let someone display it on their website.

Or have I misunderstood the intended purpose of the API thing?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top