Thanks guys, I agree on location would be better for some of my ideas, this shoot was really just to get in the studio, spend some time there and see what I could come up with.
I love the lighting in 6 but the expression unsettles it a little I think.
3 the shot is not gritty enough to have something added to it by the "stars and bars" which is an overtly raciest symbol and needs to be treated with care. I don't think people in the UK realize exactly how that flag is has been used throughout American history. To this day it is used by racist groups (KKK, Aryan Nations, and the Minute Men to name a few) to intimidate immigrants and minorities. It is basically a Celtic cross, or a swastika.
+1 - I should have mentioned this when I stated it was upside down. And having said that - it could be the right way up if it were on a naval vessel, at sea in the late 1800's
However, the Confederate Battle Flag (fully square version) is still part of the Mississipi state flag, and appears on numerous license plates, in a number of states.
The prop in use is not old enough to make it a historical shot, so it could be taken the wrong way.