Guardian eyewitness uses photoshop to create an image

Messages
194
Name
Gavin
Edit My Images
Yes
I was doing my regular look on the guardian in pictures page this morning while enjoying a coffee and clicked onto the Eyewitness gallery and for the 22 August the image was a stunning half and half shot of some butterflyfish with a mountain backdrop. Awesome. I love doing this type of shot. They are extremely diffcult to get right, but the photographer seemed to 'nail' this one.

Then I read the caption. The shot is actually 5 images. Not 1, not 2 even, but 5!

you can see the shot here: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/picture/2012/aug/22/1

The Eyewitness, like the rest of the galleries are supposed, in my opinion, be stunning news shots. One off moments not a cobbled together set of images designed purely to stun the viewer.

I am a realist and know photoshopping goes on in pretty much all images, but touching up a picture is one thing, creating something that wasn't there is another.

Am I alone in thinking this?
 
I actually do not like the image, because it is so unnatural. If you look at the Butterfly fish they go from being in focus to being out of focus. If you look at the mountains in the background, they are sharp.
You could get a far more impressive image, by going to a location where the water is crystal clear, calm and shallow, there are plenty of fish and a scenic backdrop. By using a polarising filter and the smallest aperture - f32/64, you may be able to produce a far more pleasing shot.
 
Agreed, the shot doesn't look in any way natural in the first place, so would never have thought it was a single shot in the first place

No idea about what these shots are supposed to be as i have never been on the Guardian site before, so can't really comment on if these should be single shots or not
 
its interesting but not particularly very good - I don't really care if it was one shot or five.
 
Thats great
Im sure ive seen them fish in what looks like a cod water lake
:-/
 
Why not spend the time getting what is there right, it gives a much better result!

Well, I very much doubt you're going to get it in one shot - what with air and water having radically different refractive indices, it will throw the focal distances all out if you're looking through both media at once.

That said, I'm with the OP; a comped shot does seem out of place in the Eyewitness series.
 
I actually do not like the image, because it is so unnatural. If you look at the Butterfly fish they go from being in focus to being out of focus. If you look at the mountains in the background, they are sharp.
You could get a far more impressive image, by going to a location where the water is crystal clear, calm and shallow, there are plenty of fish and a scenic backdrop. By using a polarising filter and the smallest aperture - f32/64, you may be able to produce a far more pleasing shot.

I completely agree. It just doesn't look right.
 
The fish look bloody big to me, I wouldn't go swiming there if I was you.... :lol:

:thumbs::lol:

Whoever did that was on an acid trip. I don't know why they didn't go the whole hog and add giant Hula Hula girls on the beach and a surfer being eaten by one of the fish;)
 
Musicman said:
Well, I very much doubt you're going to get it in one shot - what with air and water having radically different refractive indices, it will throw the focal distances all out if you're looking through both media at once.

All I meant was that I don't really like the whole creating something that's not there with Photoshop or similar :-)
 
The thing is you can get all that in one shot but you have to:
a. Be very very lucky that the conditions are right.
b. have both good strobes and a split neutral density filter
c. The knowledge to get the shot
d. A really large dome port for the fisheye lens on the front of the camera.

My point really, I guess is, a top class photographer could, if the conditions are right and it was planned out, get that shot in one hit. That would have impressed me enough to want to see it on the Eyewitness gallery. But if the Guardian is taking any old rubbish that's been cobbled together in PS then what's the point in working hard at getting the right shots.

Its a sad day for photography
 
I thought it was deemed 'not cool' to crit the work of another photographer who isn't around to state their case?...

Personally I don't like this kind of work per se but there are plenty of people who do. The fact it's done in PS isn't something that should be picked at; so what if it's a digitally manipulated image? We're not in the dark ages guys, PS is not some form of witchcraft that should see the offender being drowned...
 
specialman said:
I thought it was deemed 'not cool' to crit the work of another photographer who isn't around to state their case?...

I don't think the OP (and my comments at least) are criticising the photograph itself; just its (inappropriate) placement in The Guardian's Eyewitness gallery. I think newspaper photo editors are fair game under forum rules :)
 
I agree with most of the other posts on here.....I'm not impressed with this image it just looks so unnatural.

I've not got a problem with using photoshop - it's just another tool (like a polarising filter, grad filter etc,etc ) to get an end result that the photographer is after, but in this case, IMHO, the end result is not worth the effort.
 
Ive seen better composite images certainly. It looks unnatural.

Split shots are very difficult to get right. You need a large dome, ideally calm water, overhead or behind sun lighting conditions, usually high power strobes and even then narrow apertures due to the massively differing focus distances.

I dont tend to think eyewitness news style photos should be minimal processing, certainly not bits of images that aren't actually there pasted onto the top.
 
Back
Top