Have you ever held back a photograph for ethical reasons?

straycat

Suspended / Banned
Messages
3,582
Edit My Images
Yes
this is over 20 years old now so no harm can be done.

i was at the scene of a massive fire.
after a while one of the fireman came over and said please dont use any photos of us with our helmets of [quite a few had removed them] as we would be in trouble.he didnt notice his mate smoking.
to be honest i hadnt thought about them following health and safety if he hadnt asked i would have thought nothing of it.

when i got back to the newspaper and developed the film i noticed the smoking fireman.

my editor was a very hard nosed female,she had allready told me of for going back and giving photos away to some sick children i had photographed and other soft things i had done.

i knew it would be used with some witty caption and the firemen would never trust me again,so i didnt do any more prints and never showed her the photo.

would you have done the same?



wwwwqw_zps28134766.jpg
 
there are certain pictures I refuse to publish on my website that i know others do (up to them) ... I do a lot of sport.. i wont publish injuries but most of all.. children in distress.. hurt or crying.. sometimes crying because they lost.. very emotive but a big nono for me...

however for the newspaper? thats the job.. i wouldnt have held that back because thats exactly what your there for and holding that back is you cheating your paper/employer IMHO but its exactly that.. InMyHumleOpinion and you did ask :)
 
no i understand,i had a bit of a dilema but i had promised the fireman and you can see how close i was.
i wouldnt have got that close again,my longest lens was 105mm.
 
I would have submitted it. It's a decent pic and the attitude towards smoking was very different twenty years ago.

I can understand your editor's attitude to you giving away their photos though. It's how locals and regionals make extra cash, especially the picture desk; you were effectively knackering your own budget.

Being picky btw - do you have a licence to publish that photo? :)
 
That aside, you did as requested, the firemen have their helmets on. It would have been up to your editor to decide on the fate of the image. Seems quite bonkers that a fireman would be smoking whilst putting out a fire?
 
That aside, you did as requested,

eh? he was working for the paper not the fire brigade.. so in fact he didnt do as requested..he didnt bring back all the newsworthy pics for the editor to decide.. he held some back
 
KIPAX said:
As picky goes.. thats well up there mate :)

Yup it is, but we can hardly complain about papers nicking our photos when we do exactly the same with theirs!

If your employed as a staffer ( which is implied here) then you don't own the pics, the paper does, and you need a licence to even show them in your portfolio! :)
 
Similar to Kipax above. A few years ago I was photographing a football match (that Kipax was also at funnily enough) and one of the players broke their leg. I got an absolutely awesome photo of the moment of impact and the look of pain on the players face. Possibly one of the best football photos I've ever taken.

As soon as I looked at the back of the camera I could see from the photo that the players leg was broken. A split second later I pressed the delete button and the picture was never to be seen again.
 
A few years ago I was photographing a football match (that Kipax was also at funnily enough) and one of the players broke their leg. I got an absolutely awesome photo of the moment of impact and the look of pain on the players face. Possibly one of the best football photos I've ever taken.

Not so much a case of 'Give us a smile' more one of 'Give us a break...'
 
eh? he was working for the paper not the fire brigade.. so in fact he didnt do as requested..he didnt bring back all the newsworthy pics for the editor to decide.. he held some back

Perhaps, but my take on it is he got a newsworthy pic, about the fire, not the firemen, which I take it was the assignment. Having to balance being allowed access by compromise is surely what you have to do? I am thinking of my own project with the fire brigade - there were some activities that were out of bounds, you agree or else you can't shoot at all ...
 
Perhaps, but my take on it is he got a newsworthy pic, about the fire, not the firemen, which I take it was the assignment.

Surely we are seeing what he didnt show not what he did show? also the job is to get everyhting and as you already said.. the picture editor should decide whats used not the photogrpaher.. thats the problem..

Having to balance being allowed access by compromise is surely what you have to do? I am thinking of my own project with the fire brigade - there were some activities that were out of bounds, you agree or else you can't shoot at all ...

no this is a news job..different alltogether when your shooting somehting that happening as news as apposed to an arrangment.
 
The OP had given his word to the fireman that the photo wouldn't be published and he kept his word. If he was in the employment of the paper, there may be copyright issues but I'm sure that after 20 years, they would give permission (OK, the hard nosed female possibly wouldn't but I would think she's probably move on by now).

If I had given my word, that would take precedence over any loyalty I may have felt for an employer - Then again, I really have told several employers where to shove their jobs because of ethics. (Last time was 25 years ago yesterday, the day of the big storms. My then boss decided there was more money to be made faster by going into replacing roof tiles and slates rather than painting and decorating. Since NONE of his workforce were trained roofers and I for one was too heavy to be on roofs without causing more damage, I told him I wouldn't be back, apart from to return the work's van.
 
Turning this around slightly, I have seen photographs that will never be made public, but in the context of learning from what happens in a major incident they where invaluable. Now these photographs came from a tog who was just there to shoot a match and although a couple where published most were just handed to the police.
 
I have a rule not to publish couple kissing shots or similar as postcard stock for 3-4 years simply in an attempt not to mess up someones life if they ever did see them... and also a rule not to take advantage of the homeless or addicts for sensational story alone... although I have been guilty once or twice I prefer not to show faces in an effort to not abuse their plight just for the 'oh how sad' patronising impact these type of shots always confer. Generally I'm soooo not a totally ruthless street snapper as some would like to think.
 
I have a rule not to publish couple kissing shots or similar .

ha good point.. forgot about that one.. got a fantastic shot of two girls kissing on an open terrace at a football match (only them in pic and long range so didnt even know until i got home)... love the pic.. never published or shown anyone...

no you cant see it :)
 
i still had a good photograph to publish,if i had used this one he would have been in trouble,my remit was to cover the fire not cause a sensation.

the other side of it is when i had anything to do with firemen again, i was given better access than some and no comeback.

same with the kids mothers when i returned for a follow up story they couldnt do enough to help me.

sometimes what goes around comes around.:)

ps you try telling a 5 year old sick child she cant have a picture unless she pays.:lol:
 
Last edited:
Usually I've found the paper will chicken out before I do when it comes to "gruesome" type images.

As far as the OP's question about the firemen, I'd have shot away, it's not only a good shot but those helmets are their for their protection, maybe a reminder from the chief might just save a life. As for being un-popular, you need a thick skin to be a good press photographer.

As the old story goes, you see a person drowning, do you.... shoot with f2.8 to freeze the action, or go to f11 for some blur.... :lol:
 
I always stop shooting if a child is injured in a game, I did get a request once from a parent "did you get a shot of my son when he was sparked out?" I did get the shot of the collision but deleted it as it was a kids boot in the face of another resulted in a kid on the floor for a while.
 
KIPAX, I got it from this post... (my colouration)


no i understand,i had a bit of a dilema but i had promised the fireman and you can see how close i was.
i wouldnt have got that close again,my longest lens was 105mm.
 
There is nothing wrong with just being a nice guy and respecting the fire fighters request. IMO it's like everything in life, you look at the good and bad of what will come of it and make your decision based on that. I'm sure you got many more shots that were more flattering than this one so why is it a big deal to hold a few back. I don't think it is a big deal and I think you were just being a good guy when you made your decision.
 
Just taken from a website with details on press photographer job role:

"Work may be stressful if you are recording an accident or people's emotions and may also involve ethical decisions related to intrusion into private lives, and the possible consequences of the publication of photographs."

I take that as there will be two types of person for the role, those that will submit who are a bit less caring of the consequences and those that wouldn't submit, who perhaps do care what the re-percussion is.

I know little about press photography but could understand how the above statement would apply to certain situations (such as a photographer that managed to get a shot of somebodies leg blown off and the newspaper wanting it).

Some really wouldn't want friends and family to see it, others may think of their own finances or reputation etc.

I know that was a bit more of an extreme example than the smoking fireman :) (great image by the way).
 
You kept your word. That's really all that matters as far as I'm concerned.
 
I have a couple of portraits of older chaps that I am delighted with but the men were in a care home and suffer from mental health problems and are at risk so there's nothing I can do with them
 
Just taken from a website with details on press photographer job role:

"Work may be stressful if you are recording an accident or people's emotions and may also involve ethical decisions related to intrusion into private lives, and the possible consequences of the publication of photographs."

I take that as there will be two types of person for the role, those that will submit who are a bit less caring of the consequences and those that wouldn't submit, who perhaps do care what the re-percussion is.

I know little about press photography but could understand how the above statement would apply to certain situations (such as a photographer that managed to get a shot of somebodies leg blown off and the newspaper wanting it).

Some really wouldn't want friends and family to see it, others may think of their own finances or reputation etc.

I know that was a bit more of an extreme example than the smoking fireman :) (great image by the way).

It's not about caring Phil, it's about doing the job your paid to do.

Theres also another side to it, by showing whats happened you may get public opinion to actually prevent a disaster/accident/drowning etc from happening again, making people aware with graphic images can bring about changes for the better.
 
swanseamale47 said:
It's not about caring Phil, it's about doing the job your paid to do.

Theres also another side to it, by showing whats happened you may get public opinion to actually prevent a disaster/accident/drowning etc from happening again, making people aware with graphic images can bring about changes for the better.

I think there would be arguments for both sides Wayne.

Its a job and I'm sure applicants would be well aware of this fact...but they may still feel uneasy about handing over shots that (in their head at least) could upset people.
I guess its much more relevant to paps but there has to be situations for press where they have to question "is this right to hand over this shot" and not be just about the job...?

Maybe I don't know enough about the role and am talking rubbish....
 
Was covering a Point-to-Point race once, when just as I focused on a horse it slipped and snapped a leg. The image I got showed the horse falling, the female rider falling and the leg flailing around. Might have had a curiosity value to some publications, but as the horse had to be put down on the spot, and the rider was really upset, I erased the image.
 
i wont publish injuries but most of all.. children in distress.. hurt or crying.. sometimes crying because they lost.. very emotive but a big nono for me...

Hmmm....

Ronald Haeberle's Photo of the My Lai Massacre?

Nick Ut's Pulitzer Prize Winning Photo of the young Vietnamese girl running away from a napalm attack?

Sometimes you have to put your sensibilities on hold... there's a bigger picture you need to look at.

Even on a more frivolous level... Jill Greenberg? Snatching a loli-pop from a child to make it cry may be a bit mean, but so what? Very challenging images that were actually taken to make a very strong political point.

Should we not take risks, challenge public perceptions and challenge perceived wisdom?

I think we should.
 
Hmmm....

Ronald Haeberle's Photo of the My Lai Massacre?

Nick Ut's Pulitzer Prize Winning Photo of the young Vietnamese girl running away from a napalm attack?

Sometimes you have to put your sensibilities on hold... there's a bigger picture you need to look at.

a kid injured at football or crying.... no thanks

Even on a more frivolous level... Jill Greenberg? Snatching a loli-pop from a child to make it cry may be a bit mean, but so what? Very challenging images that were actually taken to make a very strong political point.

God help me if I ever purposely make a young child cry and double god help me if I was to do it for photogrpahy.... SICK!


Should we not take risks, challenge public perceptions and challenge perceived wisdom?

I think we should.

So do I ..but not if it includes purposely making a child cry to take a picture
 
a kid injured at football or crying.... no thanks

It's all part of the human condition. YOU didn't injure him. It all depends on the context it was created in. Showing it because you thought it was a cool shot, then no, of course not. Showing it because it's a real part of a rough contact sport and telling the full story of children's sporting events and the level of competition they can be subject to.. well. that's something else. There's a real reason for it being there. It's not being exploitative for your own aggrandisement. It's telling a story... and that's what photographers do.



God help me if I ever purposely make a young child cry and double god help me if I was to do it for photogrpahy.... SICK!

She took a loli-pop off a child for 10 seconds.... well boohooo... It's hardly sick.


So do I ..but not if it includes purposely making a child cry to take a picture

I see far more offensive examples of poor parenting on a daily basis... all of it apparently socially acceptable. Looking at this holistically, this is a non issue.
 
Phil Young said:
I think there would be arguments for both sides Wayne.

Its a job and I'm sure applicants would be well aware of this fact...but they may still feel uneasy about handing over shots that (in their head at least) could upset people.
I guess its much more relevant to paps but there has to be situations for press where they have to question "is this right to hand over this shot" and not be just about the job...?

Maybe I don't know enough about the role and am talking rubbish....

I don't think you are talking rubbish at all. I think that with any situation you can find Justification to go against your word or what is morally right. If that was the one and only shot that was taken than yes it's your job to turn it in but that is not the case here so that doesn't make it your job to turn in every picture. as long as you cover the assignment you are good right?
 
first off looking back at my post.. sorry.. being a bit of a drama queen.. didnt mean to be.. what i meant and how it reads comes out a bit different :)

It's all part of the human condition.

yes i agree and i have seen others post these things... I guess we all have our own lines.. i have mine and i draw it at displaying images of children upset or in distreess ie crying...


She took a loli-pop off a child for 10 seconds.... well boohooo... It's hardly sick.

hmm its wrong.. to purposely make a child cry so you can take a picture.. in my world thats just so wrong.. purposely making a child cry is.. doesnt matter if its for 10 seconds or not.. but to make one cry so you can take a picture... sorry but no.. I couldnt do it to my kids and certainly not to anyone elses..




I see far more offensive examples of poor parenting on a daily basis... all of it apparently socially acceptable. Looking at this holistically, this is a non issue.

oh I see bad parenting all the time.. I see it in asda.. i see it in the street... doesnt mean its OK to join in :)
 
shaylou said:
I don't think you are talking rubbish at all. I think that with any situation you can find Justification to go against your word or what is morally right. If that was the one and only shot that was taken than yes it's your job to turn it in but that is not the case here so that doesn't make it your job to turn in every picture. as long as you cover the assignment you are good right?


No. Not if you are a staff photographer you aren't. Every frame belongs to the employer.
 
No. Not if you are a staff photographer you aren't. Every frame belongs to the employer.

Just another tuppenyworth!

Not sure the OP's ever said he was a staffer - plenty of freelancers around shooting for papers.
 
Nod said:
Just another tuppenyworth!

Not sure the OP's ever said he was a staffer - plenty of freelancers around shooting for papers.

He was either a staffer or a freelance on contract- it's all there in the first post if you read it.

Also: plenty of freelancers shooting for local/regional papers in the early 90s?
A few, yes, but certainly not plenty.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top