Help me nail my focussing demons once and for all!

Messages
434
Edit My Images
Yes
I'm turning to you for help once again..... I've been doing this for about 10 months now, and the one consistent problem I've always had with my images has been focussing/sharpness. I'm sure it's fairly common but would have thought I could have nailed it by now. I've asked for advice before - here, friends etc. And I've had conflicting advice which could be part of the problem. I have plenty of books on photography and none of them are any help at all. They cover the subject in too basic a way. So whilst other aspects of my photography improve, such as use of natural light and composition, these are held back by softness issues on many otherwise cracking shots, and I do find it a huge disappointment that it's this one thing holding me back.

As advised by someone somewhere I currently have my Canon set to AI Servo, all focus points selected (as I was having trouble getting more than one person across the frame in focus even with smaller aperture), and have set it up so that I can focus using the star button at the back (good for firing off lots of shots) rather than half compressing the shutter. ETA - AI servo and all focus points partly because my main subjects have often been lively wriggly children who won't stay still.

I understand that other aspects such as available light, shutter speed, aperture, camera shake and the lens will all affect focus too...... I just need to nail this once and for all. I know my camera can take a very sharp image (with the above settings, too), but I shot a wedding on Sunday (a freebie with no pressure as they had no money and wanted to let me practise), and I got plenty of good shots but will have to sharpen the less good ones such as the confetti shot and the register signing shot. I have my best friend's wedding to do in September (I am only doing the wedding party shots) so would like to nail these demons by then, please help!

I'm wondering how much of the problem is having all focus points selected - intuitively I don't think this can be the right approach, yet if I switch to a single focus point I'm struggling again - unless this is because of AI Servo? Heeeelp :(
 
Last edited:
On my 40D I use AI Servo, back button focus and usually the centre focus point only.

BUT I try to use the focus point nearest the thing I want to focus on, focus recompose is useful in some situations but picking the best located single point is better.

Like this



This does mean that sometimes you have to compromise your composition a bit but it's worth it to nail the focus consistently.

You don't say which lenses youare using but I think using small maximum aperture lenses (like the 18-55, 17-85 etc) is likely to lead to focusing errors especially at wide angle settings and in low light.

AI servo with all the focus points selected I have found to be dissapointing as it's usually quite difficult to tell when the focus point being used has moved from the centre. A brief flash of the new focus point would be useful but they don't.

HTH

David
 
Can you post some sample shots. This often helps determine the exact problem.

Also the setting you are using on the camera Av, Tv etc ISO settings.

I'd also suggest that if the subject isn't moving significantly take the camera off AF servo and see if this makes a difference. Also be careful of having all focus zones active as it could select an area to focus on which is not the one you want to concentrate on.

Try a simple test, select the central point focus and then photograph a simple non moving subject and see this in focus
 
Personally, I would suggest moving to one shot focussing and using a single focus point, as using all leaves it to the camera to decide what it is that should be in focus.

With single shot, single point, you will be in control as to which part of the shot you want to be in focus. If you use the centre point (not essential - it could be any of them) and use this to focus on what YOU want to focus on, half press, recompose, and shoot, you'll find before too long it becomes second nature and you nail a higher percentage of shots.

It's all about personal preference and finding what works for you, but doing it this way will at least give you a better idea of what is going wrong if and when it does, as you know what your intended target was rather than leaving it to the camera.
 
I'm wondering how much of the problem is having all focus points selected - intuitively I don't think this can be the right approach, yet if I switch to a single focus point I'm struggling again - unless this is because of AI Servo? Heeeelp :(

Undoubtedly this is holding you back. The camera can only possibly focus sharply at one particular distance. Having sufficient DOF will have to carry you the rest of the way, which means choosing your aperture wisely. Having the camera guess at what you want to focus on is not going to help at all. You should be in charge of focusing. Pick the AF point you want the camera to use and place that point carefully where it belongs within the frame.

I might add that the behaviour of the AF system when you use all points active is coimpletely different in AI Servo mode vs One Shot. In One Shot the camera will focus on the nearest thing that has sufficient contrast. Often that may be what you want to happen, and often it will not. In AI Servo the camera will always assume that the centre AF point covers your subject, initially at least. The camera will (should) only hand over control to alternate focus points if it loses track with the centre point. For focus continuity to be maintained the camera needs to be able to work out what else in the scene is your subject, or it cannot hand over focus reliably. If you are using focus/recompose technique then I can't see any value at all in shooting with AI servo and all points. If you keep AF active the camera may change focus as you recompose, or it may hang on to the original subject. Either way I'd say it's a bit of a gamble, and one you can take steps to eliminate. If you don't recompose then you can be assured the camera will be focusing wherever the centre point is aimed. The peripheral points will do you no earthly good, and may trip you up.

There are times when using all points can be advantageous, but I'd have my default arrangement as single point only, switching to all points only if the subject would benefit.

For the time being, and to try to get you moving ahead, I'd recommend the following....

1. Choose your own focus point and make it a point which requires the minimum recomposition after focusing.
2. Shoot in One Shot mode unless you have a moving target.

Once you are getting consistant results with those settings then look at expanding your options. Of course, if your subject is moving then you will need to use AI Servo, but try to avoid enabling all AF points unless there is a real need. Remember as well that AI Servo needs up to a second to figure out what sort of motion you have and to be able to predict where to be focused by the time the shutter is released. You can't just hit the AF-On button and instantly release the shutter. Also remember that if you need to enable all points while using AI Servo you must lock focus with the centre point first. Only then can the camera know where your subject is.

Of course there are many other considerations, as you have pointed out, like camera shake, subject blur, insufficient DOF and also diffraction softening if you stop down too far. There are also issues of AF calibration accuracy and photographer stability, especially when shooting up close and having shallow DOF. There's a lot involved in securing sharp shots, but a good place to start is with choosing the right focusing technique.
 
Are you shooting in RAW? If so, there's generally little to no sharpening done in camera as there is when shooting JPEG. Also, most DSLRs have a antialiasing filter which tends to soften the image a bit. That's the two main reasons that you need to sharpen your images in post production (when shooting RAW).

Other than that; if using a very wide aperture, say f/1.4, it's quite difficult to get the focus right and it requires some practice.

Other things to look out for, as you mention, is shutter speed. Is the softness due to subject motion or camera shake? Increase shutter speed.
 
I'm wondering how much of the problem is having all focus points selected - intuitively I don't think this can be the right approach, yet if I switch to a single focus point I'm struggling again - unless this is because of AI Servo? Heeeelp :(

Practise just using one focus point and get the hang of shifting the focus point quickly. IMHO having all points selected is a recipe for disaster especially on AIservo for your type of photography.

I shoot lots of toddlers and young kids and always keep control over the focus point, use one shot as much as possible switching to AIservo when necessary and for most client shoots don't go much below f4 to ensure that I'm nailing focus. I'd still class my business as in the fledgling stage and leave the f1.8 shots to my own personal work until I'm confident I can deliver 100% on paid shoots
 
David, thank you - in the above example (and sorry for the stupid question) but how does using that focus point ensure that the further away eye is in focus?

That's controlled by the DOF or f number that you choose
 
I would try shooting some test shots. Set up your tripod with the camera on remote pointing at a tree or other non moving object. Focus and shoot. This SHOULD be perfect. If not there is a possibility that some setting is a bit out and maybe adding micro focussing or something is needed. If the focus is ok then try hand holding it. There are various techniques for getting a steady camera whilst holding it. Again watch for the shutter speed (this is something Mrs C is currently trying to sort out!).... get your shot lined up and check what the shutter speed is it needs to be at least the reciprocal of the focus length ie 50mm requires 1/50th s, 200mm requires 1/200th s. If it is not then up the ISO or aperture size till you do get that.
 
paul g it's good to read that your work is often with young children as that it what I thought was the problem with my focussing in the earlier days when I was using one shot (actually it may just have been inexperience and too low f number or SS).

thanks Son - I thought I'd read that I needed to focus between the two eyes somewhere, perhaps I'm making it up. You've seen some of my sharper shots of Laura and Sam and some of the softer ones so you know about my hit or miss success rate!

Cowaski - thank you for all the tips, I had wondered if the camera was playing up but surely then there would be no good results. I will try what you've suggested.
 
Simmotino, thank you. I'll definitely give this a try. I got confused a while back by reading about using the star button to lock the focus - I could never get it to work. It's not necessary anyway is it? Going by what you've said i.e. half compress to focus, move camera to recompose then shoot.

I wouldn't give up on using * to focus along with AI Servo yet tbh, it has too many advantages to not use imo, especially for fast moving subjects.

I would guess that it is mainly the number of focus points you are trying to use that are causing the OOF shots - the only cameras I'd consider using all focus points are the 1 series & even then I prefer to use selected points if at all possible - for precise shots, the camera doesn't know you want an eye in focus, it just goes for the high contrast area & you'd just have to hope your aperture is set low enough to give enough DOF to your shot.

Try setting up single focus points & rather than focusing & recomposing (it does work for some people in some situations but for portraits at high apertures where nailing focus is paramount, it is a bit too hit & miss for my liking - even the slightest movement at say f/1.4 will throw your subject out of focus) I'd try moving the focus point around instead (feels weird & slow at first but speed does increase as you get used to it & takes all of the decision making away from the camera)

(Make sure your lenses aren't back/front focusing too - it's not always user error (unless it's me :lol: )
 
Darren

"get your shot lined up and check what the shutter speed is it needs to be at least the reciprocal of the focus length ie 50mm requires 1/50th s, 200mm requires 1/200th s."

2p...dont know Canon but if it's a crop sensor the shutter speeds would need to be faster than this...?
 
Moomike, I DO like the star button, I remember when I switched from using the shutter to focus, to the star button, it was like a revelation. Am really hoping the MAIN problem is the focus points - will report back for sure.

Also, another weird one - some of my shots that I've assumed are soft - when I view them at 50 or 100 percent they look SHARPER - thought it would be the other way round, i.e. when smaller they'd be sharper?

Finally, some of the photographers that I really admire don't appear to necessarily leave out shots which to me look soft on the screen ?!?!? Am I placing too much stock on it? (I'm talking portraits and weddings). Although - I know I need to be able to consistently nail it before I can take myself semi-pro.
 
Yardbent - I can't get a shot sharp with SS of 1/50 - no way jose, I must be a shaky bird.

not saying you should.....i never shoot below 1/125 unless i have to, as hands are a bit shaky

prefer to raise the ISO instead, within limits
 
Moomike, I DO like the star button, I remember when I switched from using the shutter to focus, to the star button, it was like a revelation. Am really hoping the MAIN problem is the focus points - will report back for sure.

Also, another weird one - some of my shots that I've assumed are soft - when I view them at 50 or 100 percent they look SHARPER - thought it would be the other way round, i.e. when smaller they'd be sharper?

Finally, some of the photographers that I really admire don't appear to necessarily leave out shots which to me look soft on the screen ?!?!? Am I placing too much stock on it? (I'm talking portraits and weddings). Although - I know I need to be able to consistently nail it before I can take myself semi-pro.

Which software are you using? Photoshop has weird magnification issues at midway zoom ratios (33.33% or 66.67%%, etc) but cleans up at nice, rounded ratios like 50% or 100% I'd check your images in other programs too just to make sure.

I have used plenty of OOF shots for my wedding clients but it's just luck of the draw imo, if you've missed focus on purpose then great, artistic license is the way to go :p

If, on the other hand, you've missed focus by accident then I'd normally just bin it unless the shot works better for it (artistic license again :lol: ) As photographers, I think we often get too caught up in the technical aspects rather than asking whether or not the photo actually works :thumbs:
 
Some of my ISO 400 shots look grainy, which makes me a bit cautious about high ISOs....

I wouldn't worry about ISO400, unless it's a really bright day, my camera lives at ISO400. Look into either Noise Ninja or Neatimage if you are really worried (noise ninja is easier to use imho whilst still maintaining amazing noise reduction) I think they still offer free trials from their websites :thumbs:

Your camera shouldn't be producing much noise at ISO400 unless you are underexposing & trying to bring it back with post processing. Maybe post one of the shots the amount of noise is evident - I find higher ISO shots don't maintain as much detail & this may be influencing your OOF problems?
 
YES that's it moomike - brightening up a too dark image (I struggled inside the church with my too crappy flash which doesn't really seem to work with ttl). I thought this might be what was going on. Also some of the brighter ones looks noisy to me though - weirdly I have one with f 5 and SS 1600 - seems odd settings, sometimes when I'm trying to expose (I do this only by pointing my camera at subject then asjusting SS usually around what f number I want to use), sometimes it jumps all over the place........
 
If it is not then up the ISO or aperture size till you do get that.

Bear in mind that opening up the aperture will decrease the DoF. If this becomes smaller than the depth you actually need to get sharp, it can look like you've stuffed up your focus in the resulting picture.

Also, lenses aren't generally sharpest at their maximum aperture. If you're shooting wide open and getting soft (rather than OOF or blurred) shots, try stopping the lens down a couple of stops.
 
ps. to view images I'm using Digital Photo Processing - it comes with the Canon camera and for editing I use PS7, Lightroom or sometimes just lighten/darken/sharpen/tweak contrast in DPP.

Are you using the latest version of DPP? Some versions have very soft rendering of images when viewing at "Fit to screen" size. They will sharpen up considerably at 50% or 100%. Make sure you are using the latest version of DPP. It might help. If nothing else it may have new features, because over time new things have been added. It's a free download from Canon, so you might as well update if you need to.
 
<snip>

I'm wondering how much of the problem is having all focus points selected - intuitively I don't think this can be the right approach, yet if I switch to a single focus point I'm struggling again - unless this is because of AI Servo? Heeeelp :(

Yes.

Undoubtedly this is holding you back...

<snip>

Agree with Tim, and the good advice above. Basically, I would switch to using the centre point only for starters.

The other thing is I think you need to understand depth of field better. That is, the zone of sharpness in the picture, which extends both behind and in front of the point you have focused on. But this varies a lot depending on a couple of things, and is one of the main creative techniques in DSLR photography.

Depth of field varies according to the f/number, and also the size of the image (magnification). When the subject is bigger in the frame - because you have either moved closer or are using a longer focal length, dpeth of field is reduced. In turn, when the subject is further away or you use a shorter focal length lens, it is increased.

A useful rule of thumb is that depth of field commonly extends about one third in front of the subject and two thirds behind it, hence the saying 'focus one third in'. Example: if you have a group of people in front of you and the nearest person is 2m away and the furthest is 3.5m, then if you focus around the 2.5m point you will have the best chance of getting them all sharp.

Of course, you then need to select the right f/number to ensure you've got enough DoF to cover them all, in this case you need 1.5m, which is something you just have to learn, but if you refer to this on-line calculator http://www.dofmaster.com/dofjs.html you'll see that in this case using a 30mm focal length you would need f/5.6. Focused on 2.5m, at f/5.6 you will get sharp focus from 1.93m to 3.55m.

To get a better handle on this, try a very simple experiment at different distances. First of all find a fence or maybe a line of parked cars and stand at an angle so the subject is in a line running away from you. Set the focal length around 30mm and focus on a point about 4m away and shoot at a range of f/numbers from lowest to highest.

Then move inside maybe to the kitchen and line up a few cerial packets on the worktop from say 2-3m away. Space them out to resemble a group shot and focus around one third in, and shoot through the range of f/numbers again. Finally, swap the cerial packets for a line of mugs/cups/apples/oranges lined up from about 1-2m. Same routine.

Now if you compare the images, you will get a good idea of how much depth of field you are getting at each f/number, and how this changes dramatically as you move closer (as the subject gets bigger in the frame).
 
Last edited:
I'm having focussing issues too and am following this thread with interest. I noted the advice about starting by using one shot rather than AI servo for static objects. If you are using back button focus doesn't holding and letting go of the af-on button equate to being in one shot mode? If it does do you need to hold the button for at least one second even though the subject is not moving?
 
It's your choice but I found that with a bit of practice my camera never needed to leave AI Servo - you'll get a better feel for when your camera hits focus this way & learn to trust your own judgement. Pressing & letting go of the * button does equate to One shot & as to whether you need to hold focus for one second is dependant on your cameras/lens focus speed. I imagine the 50D is pretty snappy so I wouldn't worry too much.

A good way to test this may be to set your camera so it won't let you take a shot unless focus is obtained (do make sure you turn this off after testing though!) just so as you can see how quickly your camera focuses. :thumbs:
 
I didn't know yuo could set the camera to block from a shot being taken until focus had been achieved!!! I will scour the manual for this :) Thanks.
 
Hi Kitsch. I only use single focus point and toggle to the areas I want to focus on, it is something I have sort of mastered so it works for me. You need to be quick though with the kids. Also, your DOF is paramount, if you are close in to your subject then you arent going to have a lot in focus to start with. I dont shoot weddings but I would probably use smaller apertures, think about your lighting and where it lies and look out for harsh shadows. If you have nice soft diffused light maybe increase your ISO to help with the s/s but I would not recommend doing so in dark areas otherwise you get the dreaded grain. You should be able to comfortably shoot at f5.6 or f8 and have eyes, ears etc in focus. If you shoot wider open and without lining all your subjects up like soldiers you may want to avoid this on the day of the wedding. Hope all is well, havent seen you around for a while. Jen
 
I didn't know yuo could set the camera to block from a shot being taken until focus had been achieved!!! I will scour the manual for this :) Thanks.

I think it's one of the custom function options on the 50D/500D but I haven't been able to find a list of them to double check :thumbs:
 
Last edited:
Oh wow guys, you can do that? Sorry for dumb question then but why not always make sure your camera only lets you take in focus shots?

Jen, great advice, thank you! My dark inside the church pics are well speckly.... all is well thank you, been so lazy on Flickr but meaning to take it up again and get busy on there, it's ace for inspiration. Hope all is well with you and your gorgeous kids :)
 
You know, after a few years of shooting Nikon I am going to have to double check this for you as I may well have got my wires totally crossed (I am now back with Canon & am still in the transition period :bang: ) That is unless I have totally imagined my cameras in the past having this function :lol: Sorry for the confusion if I'm wrong.

Oh wow guys, you can do that? Sorry for dumb question then but why not always make sure your camera only lets you take in focus shots?

Better a very slightly OOF shot than no shot at all imho :)
 
Last edited:
In Canon land, when in AI servo mode there is no such thing as getting focus lock. The camera will confirm whether it is able to track, but since it is always anticipating motion and predicting where it should be focusing next it never actually "locks".

On the 1 series cameras and the 7D you can set the "focus priority" option or the "release priority" option, the former of which will not let the shutter release until the camera thinks it has focus. Whether it actually has or not is another matter. The "release priority" option just means the camera will fire regardless of whether you have anything in focus at all. This will allow you to maintain full shooting speed in frames per second, but may lead to more OOF images in a sequence.

So, if you want to leave the camera in AI Servo mode and use back button focusing to simulate One Shot operation, you are not going to get a confirmation of focus lock. As soon as you release your thumb from the AF-On button the camera is no longer in any active AF mode and you are free to take as many OOF pictures as you like. The camera will not stop you.

If you want to be sure that you have a proper AF lock, and to prevent the camera from taking the shot until you do, then you need to be in One Shot mode. Of course, that only works for a static subject, but if you are trying to eliminate errors or improve your own focusing technique I really think that is a good place to start. I don't recall ever seeing any focus testing procedure recommend that the camera be set to AI Servo mode. It's worth adding that if you are using back button focusing then, once again, when you release pressure on the AF-On button the camera is no longer in an active AF mode, so it will not prevent shutter release if you are not actively focusing. It's also worth a reminder that, having achieved AF lock confirmation, if you or the subject moves then you will no longer have focus, but because the camera achieved a lock in the first place you are still free to release the shutter. If that wasn't the case then focus/recompose wouldn't work as a technique.

One Shot mode is also more precise in its focusing for static subjects because without the pressure to constantly be re-evaluating subject distance and adjusting it can afford the time to take a little longer collecting focus data and figuring out exactly where it needs to be for a perfect lock. In bright light this may not be an issue one way or the other. In dim light it can mean the difference between being able to focus at all and failing completely.

As for the behaviour of AI Focus (not to be confused with AI Servo), I wouldn't touch it with a barge pole. Even Canon cautions that it may trip you up. Of course, the 1 series bodies don't offer AI Focus as an option. I'm sure there is a good reason for that.
 
Last edited:
...On the 1 series cameras and the 7D you can set the "focus priority" option or the "release priority" option, the former of which will not let the shutter release until the camera thinks it has focus. Whether it actually has or not is another matter.

AHA, I knew I wasn't going insane...well, I was 90% sure :lol:
 
Back
Top