How much of a face needs to be in focus?

joescrivens

Suspended / Banned
Messages
15,052
Name
Joe
Edit My Images
Yes
From a discussion in another thread about portraits I was wondering what people thought about how much of a face needs to be in focus in a portrait shot.

Do you think it should be in focus from nose right through to hair strands or are you someone who concentrates purely on the eyes.

Personally I concentrate on the eyes and I actually find that having parts of the face out makes the eyes stand out even more.

thoughts
 
Depends on the face...:)

Personally though I'm the same, I tend to concentrate on the eyes.
 
As much of the face as is needed to convey the message intended by the photographer. Could be all, could be none.
 
It depends what you are trying to do and what the photo is for.

Casting head shots then you would want it all in focus.

Fashion less so.
 
agreed, the general consensus really is it depends on the subject, and the style of the photographer - there is no "right or wrong"
 
I have a preference for wider apertures on location / available light / creativity and for general portraits / studio work I'll go with more in focus but it's all preference absolutely no rules.

Generally, the further away you are the more in focus you will want but of course that's not a rule just "the norm".

I don't think it's fair to say "for this type of shot you should...." as preference governs everything in this particular question.
 
For me its a case of how OOF the face is. Subtle OOF can improve the look of the face especially on children and young people. Heavy OOF just looks odd imo. On a crop camera with 50mm as close as possible I find anything below f2.2 looks strange. But f1.4 a few feet back is perfect. There is a lot to consider with DoF and there is not really a one size fits all answer to your question.
 
Strange you should post this as I have been doing a few shots with my daughter and testing out shots from f1.4 to f4 to see what a difference it makes.I was for ever shooting between 1.4 and 1.6 with my 85mm and concentrating on the eyes.Some shots looked great and some did look a little bit over the top at times.I think around the 2.8 is a nice setting but as others have said it depends on the situation at the time.Maybe you have no option to shoot wide open with what light is available and so on.

Got any examples Joe of some pics that you think look right and which look wrong?
 
i agree, there is no right or wrong.

the only thing i would say is that i think the amount of what's in focus should follow the normal rules of dof - ie the smaller the subject in the frame (ie the further away), the more we assume it to be in focus.

a close up portrait with just the eyes in focus, nose, lips, ears all slightly out can look beautiful and dreamy, it can also look wrong or plain soft - it all depends on the composition and processing.

but when the subject is quite small in the frame i find it strange when i see some funky effects with tilt-shift lenses with bits of the subject or frame out of focus where i would expect them to be in focus. sometime the effect is neat, but most of the time i think it looks messy.
 
There may be no rules, or you won't go to prison perhaps, but unless you get at least the nearest eye sharp you'll not win many fans.

You can let the rest go, according to taste, but personally if you're going for the shallow DoF look, I don't like OOF noses. Eyes sharp, anything in front of them sharp, and move the focus point/aperture to get that.
 
I agree, the nearest eye has to be in focus or it looks horrible. Here is an example of how the subtle OOF face can work to enhance the eyes and still not look strange.

muslimgirl-.jpg
 
Phil Young said:
I have a preference for wider apertures on location / available light / creativity and for general portraits / studio work I'll go with more in focus but it's all preference absolutely no rules.

Generally, the further away you are the more in focus you will want but of course that's not a rule just "the norm".

I don't think it's fair to say "for this type of shot you should...." as preference governs everything in this particular question.

This is a very interesting thread. I am just about to start photographing people (as soon as I buy a flash) and don't even know what questions to ask yet. I was wondering about the further you are away the more in focus part. What is the purpose of this approach? Just curious and want to take in as much as I can before I start. Thanks.
 
shaylou said:
This is a very interesting thread. I am just about to start photographing people (as soon as I buy a flash) and don't even know what questions to ask yet. I was wondering about the further you are away the more in focus part. What is the purpose of this approach? Just curious and want to take in as much as I can before I start. Thanks.

Same purpose as pretty much everything - to make the image as easy on the eye as possible.

You don't need a flash, I didn't start with a flash until months into portraiture. Start with available light and just do lots of practice shoots with friends etc.
 
Phil Young said:
Same purpose as pretty much everything - to make the image as easy on the eye as possible.

You don't need a flash, I didn't start with a flash until months into portraiture. Start with available light and just do lots of practice shoots with friends etc.

Thanks Phil. I met a pro photographer and he was nice enough to offer me one of his flashes to play with. I will be getting it in the next few days so I will be like a tourist on holiday soon. I'm sure I will have a lot of questions.
 
HoppyUK said:
There may be no rules, or you won't go to prison perhaps, but unless you get at least the nearest eye sharp you'll not win many fans.

This is my only rule.
 
jacob12_1993 said:
I agree, the nearest eye has to be in focus or it looks horrible. Here is an example of how the subtle OOF face can work to enhance the eyes and still not look strange.

That's nice - small DOF but you have eyes, nose and mouth in focus.
 
That's nice - small DOF but you have eyes, nose and mouth in focus.

On the full size ones the nose and mouth are actually subtly OOF so it adds emphasis to the sharper eyes but its not enough to detract and look odd which I think is right for this image. On an elderly person with lots of character in their face I would be tempted to use more DoF to make the facial features sharper. So as with everything its the photographers decision based on the subject in front of them :thumbs:
 
Got any examples Joe of some pics that you think look right and which look wrong?

I don't have any examples where it looks wrong, I think as long as the eyes are sharp then it works. But i'm talking about normal portraiture - not fashion or commercial.

In this shots for example I see no issue with the eyes being the main focus point whilst the hair is oof:


9R4C8758 by JoeBoyMan, on Flickr

this was the shot that sparked the conversation off by the way because it's not in focus from nose to hair.


2012_06_20web by JoeBoyMan, on Flickr
 
One shot at f1.4 which I think looks a little ott.

And this one shot at f1.7 which looks a lot better and probably would have looked better at f2.2-2.8 imo.

you can't compare those two though because one is at an angle and needs more dof to get both eyes in focus. Personally I prefer the first shot because the subject has such blue eyes that focussing on them whilst the rest is out of focus makes them look much larger
 
you can't compare those two though because one is at an angle and needs more dof to get both eyes in focus. Personally I prefer the first shot because the subject has such blue eyes that focussing on them whilst the rest is out of focus makes them look much larger

Trying to find another one to compare but realize I do shoot at f1.4-1.6 an awful lot as that is all I keep seeming to find on exif.:lol:
 
joescrivens said:
I don't have any examples where it looks wrong, I think as long as the eyes are sharp then it works. But i'm talking about normal portraiture - not fashion or commercial.

In this shots for example I see no issue with the eyes being the main focus point whilst the hair is oof:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/37599844@N04/7590194452/
9R4C8758 by JoeBoyMan, on Flickr

this was the shot that sparked the conversation off by the way because it's not in focus from nose to hair.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/37599844@N04/7696707882/
2012_06_20web by JoeBoyMan, on Flickr

My personal preference on number 1 would have been to have more in focus and that's because the composition isn't necessarily anything "out of the norm" combined with a clean background.

I'd most likely of shot at the same aperture as you did in shot #2.
 
combined with a clean background.

thats where you are decieved. The background was about as far from clean as you can get given that it was a very messy bathroom. The extreme dof was to give the impression of the clean background and it looks like it worked :thumbs:
 
joescrivens said:
thats where you are decieved. The background was about as far from clean as you can get given that it was a very messy bathroom. The extreme dof was to give the impression of the clean background and it looks like it worked :thumbs:

Ah well done. Looks like a white wall on my phone so obviously you achieved what you wanted :)
 
Back
Top