How to deal with a breach of release form.

Messages
381
Name
Tom
Edit My Images
Yes
Sorry if this is in the wrong place!

About a year ago, I worked with a model on a shoot in South Wales. We had a great shoot, I got some fantastic photos, and so far as I know we both had fun. This is the release form I asked her to sign, except it of course referred to me. As you can see, she has the rights to use it for her self promotion only. So, the problem I'm having is this.

The photo I took...

4874_199104080532_514015532_7336554_2061460_n.jpg


Someone's edit...

Here

:gag::gag::gag:

The colours, that ghastly explosion, yuck! What more is there to say? And again, my photo...

4874_199104500532_514015532_7336612_7105955_n.jpg


And someone's less than tasteful edit...

Here

Again, yuck!

Now, I enjoyed working with this model and would be quite happy to work with her again, and I certainly don't want to offend her or anything. But, these edits, leave me in a catch 22 situation really. The release form states that any of my photos should be credited, these however are not. However, they are so *bad* that I do not want my name anywhere near these.

So, I must ask her to take them down and not allow anyone else to edit them. After all, I never agreed that she could use them as stock in the first place.

Any tips on how I should politely ask her to take them down and point out I never gave her permission to let others edit my photos like this? Thanks!
 
The primary thing here was whether or not the edits where done with her permission/blessing or even requested..

I know a lot of girls have images stolen from either sites they have posted them on or from photobucket accounts that get hacked.

These are then often reposted all over the web with no regard for either copyright or the wishes of either photographer or model.
 
Oh no! These are edits other people have done, and then she's posted them on her facebook account. She knows full well they're being edited.
 
I feel sad that someone would rape your work like this, but I still can't stop laughing at the explosion edit!

If she's worked with other togs as well, she must be fully aware of the limitations on use of the portfolio shots.. No harm in a gentle nudge. Or paste her head on a dog and send it over? :naughty:
 
I feel sad that someone would rape your work like this, but I still can't stop laughing at the explosion edit!

If she's worked with other togs as well, she must be fully aware of the limitations on use of the portfolio shots.. No harm in a gentle nudge. Or paste her head on a dog and send it over? :naughty:

Thank you! I know, that explosion thing is HORRIBLE! I mean, what the hell was the person doing it thinking? For a start the colours are totally screwed up, secondly why would the waves on the beach reflect the explosion so perfectly, and finally, what's up with the explosion anyway? *weeps* :'(
 
Can't help a little snigger ;) People do take liberties, usually unwittingly so probably a gentle nudge if you're really that upset.

However, from her point of view, and the retoucher's, you've now gone and posted images on here, that are joint copyright with you and the artist, presumably without knowldge or permission, and have made derrogratory comments about both of them!

It's easy to do things without thinking things through isn't it!
 
They really are horrendous. But regardless of whether they are good or bad she can't edit them without asking you. The problem is that these things happen, what you have to work out though is which is worst? Having those pictures out there on facebook or the potential danage to your reputation if you have a go at her about and she reacts badly, models can be a fickle breed.
 
Can't help a little snigger ;) People do take liberties, usually unwittingly so probably a gentle nudge if you're really that upset.

However, from her point of view, and the retoucher's, you've now gone and posted images on here, that are joint copyright with you and the artist, presumably without knowldge or permission, and have made derrogratory comments about both of them!

It's easy to do things without thinking things through isn't it!

I weighed up the benefits of getting some advice and the small chance of any other parties involved coming across this thread, and think I made the right choice :P

So far as her being fickle and all is concerned, I like to keep to my principles and what she did was wrong, so I need to stop it.

Any advice on what to actually say? xD
 
Say what you mean. If you want her/them to stop defacing your work you can only be blunt and to the point.
 
Agree

First get Facebook to remove the images

Then send he a "blunt and to the point" cease and desist
 
I weighed up the benefits of getting some advice and the small chance of any other parties involved coming across this thread, and think I made the right choice :P

So far as her being fickle and all is concerned, I like to keep to my principles and what she did was wrong, so I need to stop it.

Any advice on what to actually say? xD

Your principles don't count for much bud. So it's okay to say bad things about people and abuse their copyright into the bargain, so long as they don't find out?!?
 
Your principles don't count for much bud. So it's okay to say bad things about people and abuse their copyright into the bargain, so long as they don't find out?!?

Can't help a little snigger ;) People do take liberties, usually unwittingly so probably a gentle nudge if you're really that upset.

However, from her point of view, and the retoucher's, you've now gone and posted images on here, that are joint copyright with you and the artist, presumably without knowldge or permission, and have made derrogratory comments about both of them!

It's easy to do things without thinking things through isn't it!

If I'm not mistaken, the modified images are infringing copies of the original. Therefore, OP owns the copyright to them. I highly doubt a judge would rule in favour of the "artist" who adapted the work as they themselves have infringed copyright (and in the first instance if posting the adaptations here was considered copyright infringement).

To answer the initial question: I would shoot her an e-mail and just clearing up what rights you actually granted her in the release. Your release is actually quite confusing. Just underneath the model's signature you don't limit modification or adaptation, you merely say that you must be credited; yet under another heading, which I would presume applies only to models who receive their images on CD, you state that they cannot modify the images.

It would be worth clearing up your contract to make it crystal clear what they can and cannot do as that presumption might make the clause unenforceable.
 
If I'm not mistaken, the modified images are infringing copies of the original. Therefore, OP owns the copyright to them. I highly doubt a judge would rule in favour of the "artist" who adapted the work as they themselves have infringed copyright (and in the first instance if posting the adaptations here was considered copyright infringement).

To answer the initial question: I would shoot her an e-mail and just clearing up what rights you actually granted her in the release. Your release is actually quite confusing. Just underneath the model's signature you don't limit modification or adaptation, you merely say that you must be credited; yet under another heading, which I would presume applies only to models who receive their images on CD, you state that they cannot modify the images.

It would be worth clearing up your contract to make it crystal clear what they can and cannot do as that presumption might make the clause unenforceable.

There is no question that the modified images are the joint copyright of the OP and the artist. Whether or not the OP's orignal copyright was infringed by the addition of the artwork is moot, as he's given permission for the model to use the images for her self promotion and the artist will have taken her word for it. In her eyes, that's what she's doing. As I say, moot.

Ignorance of the law is no defense but she has acted unwittingly and made no attempt to conceal what's been done. On the other hand, the OP has infringed that copyright, knowlingly since I pointed it out, and at the same time dissed both the model and the artist. He then says it's okay because they won't see it!

We are talking principles here, or at least the OP claims to be. I might have booked that girl for tomorrow and now she's accused of acting unprofessionally on an open public forum.

Pot kettle black.
 
Wait, so despite me owning the copyright to the original images, and despite never allowing the images to be edited like that in the first place, I don't have the copyright of the edit images at all? That doesn't seem to make much sense, you're saying that you can create your own copyright on someone else's IP just by editing it. I'm somewhat lost here!
 
I actually like the second edit lol

just ask her to remove them politely and next time actually explain the release form. lay people are generally not very smart lol

if you find out who did the retouching email them and let them know you are not happy and will pursue legal action the next time they breach your copyright or put in a small claims court action :)
 
Wait, so despite me owning the copyright to the original images, and despite never allowing the images to be edited like that in the first place, I don't have the copyright of the edit images at all? That doesn't seem to make much sense, you're saying that you can create your own copyright on someone else's IP just by editing it. I'm somewhat lost here!


no you can sue their ass for breach of copyright.
 
Wait, so despite me owning the copyright to the original images, and despite never allowing the images to be edited like that in the first place, I don't have the copyright of the edit images at all? That doesn't seem to make much sense, you're saying that you can create your own copyright on someone else's IP just by editing it. I'm somewhat lost here!

If you didn't deny permission for edits, there isn't much you can do about it beyond asking the model nicely to take them down and ask for it to be avoided in the future. She probably will do if you professional about it.

If you did specify she can't edit them, then you still own them entirely and can decide what happens to them.
 
If you didn't deny permission for edits, there isn't much you can do about it beyond asking the model nicely to take them down and ask for it to be avoided in the future. She probably will do if you professional about it.

If you did specify she can't edit them, then you still own them entirely and can decide what happens to them.


Permission to edit is specifically denied in the release form he originally supplied.

Perhaps send her and the person who edited them a nice email and include a scan of the release form with the relevant section highlighted, you could even offer to do another shoot with her if she's looking for something different and even include the photoshopper, that might soften the blow?
 
On the contrary I would suggest leaving this alone unless it is used for a commercial or promotional purpose. It's a horrific edit and it took a beautiful shot and made it grotesque. Sometimes we can become over sensitive (with due cause) when it comes to copyright but in this case the use of the image does not infringe upon your brand (not credited) or your ability to earn from these shots.

You might be in your right to complain about it but if you did it every time someone photochopped your photo you will have an ulcer.
 
Hmm I certainly don't want to sue anyone!

So your option are:

Step 1) Ask politely to have the images removed, explaining why (and you knew this already)

Step 2) There is no step 2

Copyright is civil law (unless you are a big music/movie company) and so enforcement action can only be through the civil courts - that means you spending money and going to court.

Probably not worth it unless you perceive an actual financial loss - because that is what the court will care about.
 
Send a polite e-mail to the model telling her that you have noticed the edited photos on her Facebook account and you would like her to remove them. Make it clear to her in laymans terms that the model release form does not allow her to have the photos re-edited. If you want to you could offer to provide her with a more professional looking re-edit of the photos if she’s not happy with the originals. Whether you want to charge for that service is up to you.
 
First question - were the images supplied on CD?

If so a polite mail pointing out what she agreed to should suffice. If she refuses or will not reply then you can always get facebook to take them down - they tend to act upon any copyright claim without much investigation...

Secondly, did you use that exact model release form just amended for your name? Surely that is in breach of copyright from the site you downloaded the form from?
 
Wait, so despite me owning the copyright to the original images, and despite never allowing the images to be edited like that in the first place, I don't have the copyright of the edit images at all? That doesn't seem to make much sense, you're saying that you can create your own copyright on someone else's IP just by editing it. I'm somewhat lost here!

No. You do not. The edited image constitutes a new and original work and is subject to joint copyright belonging to both you and the artist. This is very common. Neither of you can publish it without the other's permission.

The fact that it has been published by the artist/model/whoever without your permission has no bearing. You have breached the artist's copyright. If you can prove that the artist did indeed breach your copyright in producing the new work, a court could order it to be destroyed, but you can't publish it.

Whether or not your copyright has been breached by the artist is very far from clear. This kind of work is not excluded on the form she actually signed, which is overriding, and no other documents or terms/conditions have any relevance at all. Indeed you have given specific permission for her to use the images for self promotion, which is exactly what she's done.

It's ironic that we read posts on here objecting to copyright abuse and the public's general ignorance of the law, yet don't seem to understand it properly ourselves.
 
it is not joint copywrite. the photographer has given a limited license of use for the images not joint copyright. Therefore the edited image can be removed from publication.

No. You do not. The edited image constitutes a new and original work and is subject to joint copyright belonging to both you and the artist. This is very common. Neither of you can publish it without the other's permission.
.
 
it is not joint copywrite. the photographer has given a limited license of use for the images not joint copyright. Therefore the edited image can be removed from publication.

The new work is joint copyright.
 
No. You do not. The edited image constitutes a new and original work and is subject to joint copyright belonging to both you and the artist. This is very common. Neither of you can publish it without the other's permission.

The fact that it has been published by the artist/model/whoever without your permission has no bearing.

Sorry to pop my head up here but I'm struggling to comprehend this point. Please explain why you seem to be contradicting yourself? If neither the aritist or tog can publish without the other's permission, why does the fact that she, the model, has published - irrespective of BooPop's use of them in this thread - without his permission have no bearing? Surely she should have asked his AND the artist's permission to publish them provided that neither had an objection. Just a thought. :thinking:
 
There is no question that the modified images are the joint copyright of the OP and the artist. Whether or not the OP's orignal copyright was infringed by the addition of the artwork is moot, as he's given permission for the model to use the images for her self promotion and the artist will have taken her word for it. In her eyes, that's what she's doing. As I say, moot.

Ignorance of the law is no defense but she has acted unwittingly and made no attempt to conceal what's been done. On the other hand, the OP has infringed that copyright, knowlingly since I pointed it out, and at the same time dissed both the model and the artist. He then says it's okay because they won't see it!

We are talking principles here, or at least the OP claims to be. I might have booked that girl for tomorrow and now she's accused of acting unprofessionally on an open public forum.

Pot kettle black.
From what I understand having just read S. 27 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. The adaptations are infringing copies of the work as it's making in the UK constituted a breach of copyright through it being copied (S. 17 (2)).

As the main design of the work is the same (the model and scenery), the author of the adaptations cannot, in my opinion, be protected under S. 64 of the Act. Nor can they, in my opinion, be protected under S. 76 of the Act as we are not dealing with literary, musical or dramatic works. This would mean that the author of the adaptations does not own copyright over them, either jointly or solely.

However I agree with you in principle, the infringing copies should not have been posted here to save any issues that might arise later, it also makes OP look unprofessional with the comment that they won't see it.

All of this has been taken from the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 accessible in the Office of Public Sector Information linkie
 
No. You do not. The edited image constitutes a new and original work and is subject to joint copyright belonging to both you and the artist. This is very common. Neither of you can publish it without the other's permission.
Actually, it doesn't constitute an original work as the main design of the work is taken from the OP's photograph. If it constituted an original work, the OP would have no rights to the adaptations whatsoever. The point of the matter is that the adaptations are infringing copies, the person committing the infringement does not own copyright over infringing copies otherwise, how would copyright law be enforceable?

If the main design were different in each of the images (ie, the model were not there), then it would be a different case altogether and likely would be considered original works.

The only way this argument would be resolved would be in a court. We can argue here until we are blue in the face, it will make no difference.

I would also agree that the model release is ambiguous on the matter. That should be cleared up as the model could argue that they have not breached the agreement you signed.
 
Sorry to pop my head up here but I'm struggling to comprehend this point. Please explain why you seem to be contradicting yourself? If neither the aritist or tog can publish without the other's permission, why does the fact that she, the model, has published - irrespective of BooPop's use of them in this thread - without his permission have no bearing? Surely she should have asked his AND the artist's permission to publish them provided that neither had an objection. Just a thought. :thinking:

Hoppy is answering a separate point, about the reproduction of the modified image in this thread, which is probably copyright infringement as the OP doesn't have permission to reproduce the artists work. To that specific point, it makes no difference that the artist shouldn't have made the work in first place.
 
Given that they're hosted on Facebook, presumably at the location uploaded to by the person who altered them (or the ex), he hasn't actually reproduced the "artist's" work. He's simply linked it, not duplicated it, thus no copyright breach has been made.

The only issue would be if facebook cares that their bandwidth is being used to hotlink these images from their servers.
 
Hoppy is answering a separate point, about the reproduction of the modified image in this thread, which is probably copyright infringement as the OP doesn't have permission to reproduce the artists work. To that specific point, it makes no difference that the artist shouldn't have made the work in first place.

Dohhh!!!! Thanks for the explanation :thumbs:
 
As a slight aside, if I understand correctly then had the op simply put a link to the facebook page then no-one would be questioning his possible breach of copyright on the modified image?

So potentially the difference between infringing, and not infringing, copyright is down to the presence of '
' on a forum post...
 
As a slight aside, if I understand correctly then had the op simply put a link to the facebook page then no-one would be questioning his possible breach of copyright on the modified image?

So potentially the difference between infringing, and not infringing, copyright is down to the presence of '
' on a forum post...

In that case, fixed! In my (weak) defense, it was late at night when I made the comment about them not seeing it, and this is the first time I've dealt with something like this...

I saw her deviantart not long ago, she's actually offering them up as stock quite willingly >.< I think I might just ask her to stop offering them as stock, and allow the works already done to remain...
 
Hoppy is answering a separate point, about the reproduction of the modified image in this thread, which is probably copyright infringement as the OP doesn't have permission to reproduce the artists work. To that specific point, it makes no difference that the artist shouldn't have made the work in first place.

Cheers Rev :thumbs: Thank you.

The facts are that the model and artist have done wrong, unwittingly or otherwise, with or without meaning any harm. Presumably no harm was intended and indeed the model obviously likes them. At least she didn't post anything saying that the original photos were so rubbish they needed changing, which is effectively what the OP has done to the modified images!

But regardless of the rights and wrongs of that, the OP posting them here is a clear and knowing infringement of the new joint copyright. I'm amazed that so many people seem to be unaware of what has happened there. And the OP's and others' comments made alleging the model's unprofessionalism and the artist's poor work only make matters worse.

It's wrong, and it's hypocritical.

Given that they're hosted on Facebook, presumably at the location uploaded to by the person who altered them (or the ex), he hasn't actually reproduced the "artist's" work. He's simply linked it, not duplicated it, thus no copyright breach has been made.

The only issue would be if facebook cares that their bandwidth is being used to hotlink these images from their servers.

That is a subtley that would be wasted on any court, and would get thrown straight out. That kind of wriggling amongst the fine print is generally looked upon badly by a judge and jury, whom you are trying to win over with a clear case of injustice.

The OP caused them to be published here, without permission. End of.
 
My post above crossed post with these comments.

As a slight aside, if I understand correctly then had the op simply put a link to the facebook page then no-one would be questioning his possible breach of copyright on the modified image?

So potentially the difference between infringing, and not infringing, copyright is down to the presence of '
' on a forum post...

Yes.

In that case, fixed! In my (weak) defense, it was late at night when I made the comment about them not seeing it, and this is the first time I've dealt with something like this...

I saw her deviantart not long ago, she's actually offering them up as stock quite willingly >.< I think I might just ask her to stop offering them as stock, and allow the works already done to remain...

Excellent! :thumbs:

BTW, some very nice work on your website - love the pregnant nudes :)
 
I wouldn't consider it "wriggling amongst the fine print", it's not been reproduced, no copyright has been broken, kinda simple really.

Bandwidth theft is another issue.
 
I wouldn't consider it "wriggling amongst the fine print", it's not been reproduced, no copyright has been broken, kinda simple really.

Bandwidth theft is another issue.

If it's not been reproduced, what were the images we were looking at? The OP made them appear on this site, he published them.

If he hadn't changed them to links, usually the mods on here would have done that for him. One of the reasons I didn't link a qoute to the OP was so that they didn't appear again in my reply, compounding the fellony which the OP would not have then been able to correct - I'd have had to do it (or the mods).

Pregnant nudes? What pregnant nudes? =O

Sorry, I assumed that you were Primavera Photography - the site you linked to for the model release form in your OP. Apologies. They're still good though ;)

I won't mention copyright on the model release form you've been printing out then LOL
 
Back
Top