Just got an email from the other tog.....(.I had originally emailed him to ask for his permission, but hadn't replied that why I posted here).
He states and I Quote
" I would prefer that you make no changes to the file in question as I feel that my client is going behind my back and breaching her contract with me. I Feel she should have returned to me with her request and I would then have took action to carry out her wishes if I seen fit. I hope you understand"
I totally agree with his reply as I would hate if someone had wanted to do this to my images, but it was my understanding , saying she had the digital file that he had released it to her to reproduce as she seen fit. maybe I am wrong with that thought but I release files all the time (for extra money of course) to my clients and I have seen them tweaked and played about with and even used on web sites and adverts...#
All very legal/Illegal!!!!! Who know unless you are a Lawyer.....but I think I will pass on this Job and let her find someone else....
Many Thanks Guys/Girls for all the opinion.
Have a great weekend
If the original photographer has handed over the copyright, or a license that just says 'here you are, do what you like with them' or quite possibly doesn't actually say anything as there is no written agreement, then legally he has no right to stop her doing anything.
The prudent route would have been to grant a license, and that would say you can do this and that with them - put images on the web, send to friends etc - but might exclude the production of extra prints and things like photoshop afterwork. If this was the case, he would only have supplied low-res files for web. The license should also have a clause about derogatory treatment, which is also covered in copyright law, in order to protect the author's reputation.
Very often in these cases, there is fault on both sides. The client doesn't know anything about copyright (and why should they) nor do they care. And the photographer who does know about copyright but doesn't have very good knowledge of it, has not considered all possibilities and has failed to either prepare a proper license agreement or even explained the deal. To the man in the street, if they have been provided with a set of image files, then they think it's fair to assume that they can do what they like with them.
And when it comes to moral rights, they think 'well, I paid for them in the first place and it's my flippin wedding' which is when the current copyright laws go against most people's idea of natural justice. IMHO, this is at the heart of most copyright disputes - it doesn't seem fair. In the current government review, it seems likely that the law will reverse the present position and go back to the pre-1988 situation which was, whoever pays for the pictures to be taken, owns copyright, not the photographer.