I m I in breach of copyright?

Messages
5,024
Name
Mike
Edit My Images
No
Recently a bride bought me a digital photo file of her and her husband on their wedding day.....done by another pro tog.......she wants me to photo shop it with various tweaks of her choice........am I in breach of copyright?if I do what she wants:thinking:
 
Just a stab in the dark but I would say a big YES you would be as the photo was taken by another tog. 9/10 times the tog only sells the prints and not the copyrights
 
Recently a bride bought me a digital photo file of her and her husband on their wedding day.....done by another pro tog.......she wants me to photo shop it with various tweaks of her choice........am I in breach of copyright?if I do what she wants:thinking:

If she doesn't have the copyright then yes
 
but when i use to work for another company, they made a minium of 5 changes to the image which then made it a totally different copyright........they done it for years and never were followed...................
 
Since she has the digital file no doubt it's subsequent use to produce images was factored in with the original price, else why would she have the file. So unless you are presenting it as your work rather than just printing for the client, I'd probably not worry.
 
Since she has the digital file no doubt it's subsequent use to produce images was factored in with the original price, else why would she have the file. So unless you are presenting it as your work rather than just printing for the client, I'd probably not worry.

Ah but if the copyright is still with the photographer

a) He is earning money from someone elses work
and
b)Ignorance is no defence in law.
 
You can't do anything without the copyright holder's permission, who might well be your client. Or not.

If you do any work on it, you will hold rights to the Photoshop work only, and the two copyrights will co-exist jointly in the new combined image.
 
You can't do anything without the copyright holder's permission, who might well be your client. Or not.

If you do any work on it, you will hold rights to the Photoshop work only, and the two copyrights will co-exist jointly in the new combined image.

I doubt whether any pro 'tog would allow anyone to alter his photos in any way because if they made alterations not up to his standards it could adversely affect his reputation.
 
I doubt whether any pro 'tog would allow anyone to alter his photos in any way because if they made alterations not up to his standards it could adversely affect his reputation.

agreed and the flipside being it wont enhance your own reputation if the original photographer finds out and makes a very public fuss... do you really want to be know as that guy who alters other photogrpahers work without them knowing?


I would play safe and step away from it..
 
Under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, you would not be permitted to adapt the work (which is what you would be doing) as the act is restricted to literary, dramatic or musical works. You would also be keeping the design the same, so would not be protected under Section 64 of the act, which would allow people to create new artistic works from old ones as long as the main design was changed.

One could also argue that you are copying the image to your systems to allow for it to be adapted, which would be a breach of copyright.

The short of it is: No, get permission from the photographer and do it right.

You can't do anything without the copyright holder's permission, who might well be your client. Or not.

If you do any work on it, you will hold rights to the Photoshop work only, and the two copyrights will co-exist jointly in the new combined image.
I swear we've talked about this before... You cannot jointly own copyright with someone if what you have done is distinctly different from the other author, you must also collaborate with them in the creation of the works. This is spelled out clearly in law, if you have not worked together to create the works and what you have done is distinctly different, then you do not own joint copyright.
In this Part a “work of joint authorship” means a work produced by the collaboration of two or more authors in which the contribution of each author is not distinct from that of the other author or authors.
link
 
Last edited:
<snip>

I swear we've talked about this before... You cannot jointly own copyright with someone if what you have done is distinctly different from the other author, you must also collaborate with them in the creation of the works. This is spelled out clearly in law, if you have not worked together to create the works and what you have done is distinctly different, then you do not own joint copyright.

No, you cannot jointly own copyright. Maybe I expressed it badly but there would be two copyrights existing separately in the work, and neither owner would be able to reproduce the work without the other's permission.

Obviously a crazy situation, so you have to sort these things out properly before hand. If push came to shove in a court of law, and agreement between the two parties couldn't be reached, then I don't think a jury would have any choice but to find that, since the subsequent work was done without permission and that the original work was integral to it, then the subsequent work would have to be destroyed and the original author recompensed.
 
Just got an email from the other tog.....(.I had originally emailed him to ask for his permission, but hadn't replied that why I posted here).


He states and I Quote

" I would prefer that you make no changes to the file in question as I feel that my client is going behind my back and breaching her contract with me. I Feel she should have returned to me with her request and I would then have took action to carry out her wishes if I seen fit. I hope you understand"


I totally agree with his reply as I would hate if someone had wanted to do this to my images, but it was my understanding , saying she had the digital file that he had released it to her to reproduce as she seen fit. maybe I am wrong with that thought but I release files all the time (for extra money of course) to my clients and I have seen them tweaked and played about with and even used on web sites and adverts...#

All very legal/Illegal!!!!! Who know unless you are a Lawyer.....but I think I will pass on this Job and let her find someone else....


Many Thanks Guys/Girls for all the opinion.


Have a great weekend
 
Just got an email from the other tog.....(.I had originally emailed him to ask for his permission, but hadn't replied that why I posted here).


He states and I Quote

" I would prefer that you make no changes to the file in question as I feel that my client is going behind my back and breaching her contract with me. I Feel she should have returned to me with her request and I would then have took action to carry out her wishes if I seen fit. I hope you understand"


I totally agree with his reply as I would hate if someone had wanted to do this to my images, but it was my understanding , saying she had the digital file that he had released it to her to reproduce as she seen fit. maybe I am wrong with that thought but I release files all the time (for extra money of course) to my clients and I have seen them tweaked and played about with and even used on web sites and adverts...#

All very legal/Illegal!!!!! Who know unless you are a Lawyer.....but I think I will pass on this Job and let her find someone else....


Many Thanks Guys/Girls for all the opinion.


Have a great weekend

If the original photographer has handed over the copyright, or a license that just says 'here you are, do what you like with them' or quite possibly doesn't actually say anything as there is no written agreement, then legally he has no right to stop her doing anything.

The prudent route would have been to grant a license, and that would say you can do this and that with them - put images on the web, send to friends etc - but might exclude the production of extra prints and things like photoshop afterwork. If this was the case, he would only have supplied low-res files for web. The license should also have a clause about derogatory treatment, which is also covered in copyright law, in order to protect the author's reputation.

Very often in these cases, there is fault on both sides. The client doesn't know anything about copyright (and why should they) nor do they care. And the photographer who does know about copyright but doesn't have very good knowledge of it, has not considered all possibilities and has failed to either prepare a proper license agreement or even explained the deal. To the man in the street, if they have been provided with a set of image files, then they think it's fair to assume that they can do what they like with them.

And when it comes to moral rights, they think 'well, I paid for them in the first place and it's my flippin wedding' which is when the current copyright laws go against most people's idea of natural justice. IMHO, this is at the heart of most copyright disputes - it doesn't seem fair. In the current government review, it seems likely that the law will reverse the present position and go back to the pre-1988 situation which was, whoever pays for the pictures to be taken, owns copyright, not the photographer.
 
Last edited:
If the original photographer ... doesn't actually say anything as there is no written agreement, then legally he has no right to stop her doing anything.

Er, no. In the absence of any written agreement, the photographer retains all his statutory rights over the image.
 
Er, no. In the absence of any written agreement, the photographer retains all his statutory rights over the image.

Correct.

The only way this could be carried out is if she has a note of copyright from the original tog, or a note of consent. Many photographers do release copyright when giving digital images (which to me is wrong).

But no matter what, the person asking for the alteration is in breach as well as the person doing the work.
 
Er, no. In the absence of any written agreement, the photographer retains all his statutory rights over the image.

Not true, and please quote the whole of my relevant text, which is: "If the original photographer has handed over the copyright, or a license that just says 'here you are, do what you like with them' or quite possibly doesn't actually say anything as there is no written agreement, then legally he has no right to stop her doing anything."

A legal agreement does not have to be in writing, though it obviously helps if it is. The photographer has handed over a set of digital files, and some rights are implicit with that act. The only reason for doing that is so that images can be copied, that is a given, and if there are no clear restrictions put on that (written or verbal) the photographer doesn't have a leg to stand on.
 
I have done this a few times when a client has a digitial file but though I may have worked on the image (always useful to have another photographer's work to experiment on) I never returned it to the client without the original photographer's permission which so far has always been given, sometimes with them approving the work before it is sent to the client though :)
 
Just to my own question on a similar subject.

Our wedding tog gave us a dvd with all the images taken on the day on it.

Nothing was written down in respects of what we can do with it but verbally we were told that we could have all the images to do with as we please i.e get extra prints etc for family friends.

Does that fall into a similar category with the tog still owning the rights?
 
Yes he owns the copyright.
 
Just to my own question on a similar subject.

Our wedding tog gave us a dvd with all the images taken on the day on it.

Nothing was written down in respects of what we can do with it but verbally we were told that we could have all the images to do with as we please i.e get extra prints etc for family friends.

Does that fall into a similar category with the tog still owning the rights?

If the photographer literally said you can do what you like with them, what he has given you is an "unlimited license". He will still retain copyright, so he can also do what he likes with them (including, possibly, withdraw your license - in theory, and not retrospectively). But you do, in effect, now have the same rights as he does.
 
Back
Top